btn

November 28th, 2020 at 3:33 PM ^

We played an injured QB all game because we don’t trust our backup QB, who was the starter all season before today, to throw a ball 10 feet in the air 

jdraman

November 28th, 2020 at 7:56 PM ^

He could not have more obviously been criticizing the coaching staff for their inability to (a) identify and start the better QB for the entire season, (b) pull a clearly injured QB whose hurt shoulder is affecting his ability to throw a pass, and (c) adjust the gameplan to play to our strengths (HH and CE out of the backfield). 

Eng1980

November 29th, 2020 at 12:11 PM ^

It does look bad but I would have to ask who is actually doing the coaching?  Is the HC, OC, or QB coach actually doing most of the hands on coaching of WRs?  The result was awful.  Something is wrong (duh) but I remain open to official titles being irrelevant at times.

That said, I agree, the WRs were not well taken care of.

FLwolvfan22

November 29th, 2020 at 3:11 PM ^

Leadership has to be a hierarchy, not be committee. Greece, Rome, Mongol, Ming Dynasty, all of them, any you can think of had a hierarchical structure. When I heard a few years ago that Harbaugh was doing plays by committee and other such stuff with nobody officially named as the coordinator I just SMH.

A Lot of Milk

November 28th, 2020 at 3:36 PM ^

I was holding on hope for one more year because I thought McCarthy could be the saving grace. But it's clear that even if he is a stud, the coaching deficiencies across the whole team would still outweigh anything he brings.

When there's more negatives than anything salvageable, you have to start over. Credit to Warriner for a great job during his time at Michigan, but everyone has to go on the team. No holdovers. New coaches, (mostly) new players, new recruits 

drjaws

November 28th, 2020 at 3:37 PM ^

They threw what .... 1 pass over 20 yards and 2 slant passes all game?

All other passes were 3 yards out routes, regardless of down and distance.

Absolute shit.

SD Larry

November 28th, 2020 at 3:37 PM ^

Someone made a world class catch on about the only non dink and dunk play called.  Nothing tried over the middle.  Haskins ran hard.  Cade hurt on two plays, and I agree with blogger who said he should not run too much.   Not sure why Zach did not get a run.  Evans looks like he has more to contribute.  Disappointing and frustrating for sure.

Aspyr

November 28th, 2020 at 4:32 PM ^

I'm sure he will land somewhere - not his fault that he was offered OC when he probably was not ready for it. For those wondering where the other so called OC are:

Jedd Fisch* -> QB coach New England Patriots
Pep Hamilton -> QB coach LA Chargers

But Harbaugh has always been the actual OC - with Hamilton he talked about it being a collaborative process - It still is today. Jedd Fisch was successful because then it was just Harbaugh's pro offense and Fisch was teaching it. 

*Job title was QB coach, WR coach & Passing Coordinator

BrightonB

November 28th, 2020 at 4:17 PM ^

I turned the game off after Cade got hurt.  That HAS to be the issue?  I mean I was shocked to read he came back in. If he hurt his throwing shoulder or other bad enough to go in and have it checked out my guess is he was way less than 100% and the throws probably suffered because of it ... no?

 

AF1618

November 29th, 2020 at 9:05 AM ^

Is that the excuse this week? 
Cade was fine. The tests they took during the game were negative and he was fine when he came back in. He didn’t start looking “injured” until he was confused and rattled. He had a deer in headlights look on his face, which is not from an injury.

People on here never learn. Joe Milton is Cam Newton. Cade is Tom Brady... Rutgers is probably the worse program in P5 history. Everybody thinks beating Rutgers is some amazing thing? Cade is a front runner. He will leave as soon as JJ or someone else passes him up. No more stupid, “we are dominating the rest of the season” videos for him...

MidwestIsBest

November 29th, 2020 at 10:28 AM ^

I’m sorry but no. I think this is your (well-justified) cynicism speaking. Last week McNamara hit receivers, threw the ball to where they were or where they were going to be. He seemed to be playing from instinct and not in his head when hurried or flushed from the pocket. This week his throws were wildly inaccurate and the confidence gone. It was more than just PSU > Rutgers.

trustBlue

November 28th, 2020 at 4:55 PM ^

Not exactly a shocker.

Rutgers gave up a ton of short passes to McNamara because they had no prep for him and kept running the defense they had installed to stop Milton.

Penn State was prepared for Cade and had their defense jumping short routes and sitting on the short passes that Cade likes to throw. 

Michigan's best bet is probably to just put in a new quarterback every game.

bluegary

November 28th, 2020 at 3:46 PM ^

Why put a injured quarterback out there. Knowing he can’t get it done. I know Milton is terrible but you can’t keep McNamara out there. Everything Harbaugh does is just fucking pathetic. The smartest thing he can do is quit right now. He will not be missed.

Mannix

November 28th, 2020 at 3:47 PM ^

PSU gives up 36 ppg. Congrats on making Michigan fans everywhere completely cave about caring anymore. 
 

Cade = O’Korn. Mesh routes are banned in this offense. Only outs!