DCC: Marcus Freeman

Submitted by Gulo Gulo Luscus on December 24th, 2020 at 2:56 PM

Thanks to all who commented on yesterday's DCC post on Clinkscale. Today I'll recap what I found in taking a closer look at Cincinnati Defensive Coordinator/LB Coach Marcus Freeman. I was pushing diary length on the last one, and this goes even more in depth, but the board has more activity so I'm sticking with it.

Profile

If you're sold on a youth movement, the 34 year old Freeman is a bit beyond "wunderkind" status for 24/7's 30under30 list but nearly half the age of Don Brown. He's another Ohio guy (Huber Heights) and played LB for the Buckeyes from 2004-2008 under then OSU co-DC/LB coach, current Cincinnati HC Luke Fickell. Before joining the Cincy staff in 2017, Freeman spent a few years as LB coach for Kent State then Purdue, eventually snagging a co-DC title for one year at the latter.

If recruiting is your bag, he's brought a couple 4-star Ohio kids to the Bearcats and comes in at 108th nationally for 2021 to 24/7. That's good for 3rd in the AAC, a tough place to recruit, but doesn't quite line up with some of the hype I've seen. Although Cincinnati's 2020 41st ranked class was the best in program history, the perceived inability to capitalize on recent success (45th ranked class for 2021) has been mentioned as a knock on Luke Fickell. Regardless, Freeman is one of five finalists for the Broyles Award honoring the top assistant coach in the country.

Since I failed to address it in the Clinkscale post, I'll note that I see no conflict between the shape of our roster and what Cincinnati likes to run. Eleven Warriors calls it "multiple" with shifts among 4-3, 4-2-5 and 3-3-5 in their 2019 film study. They also note Freeman's use of "Banjo" coverage, which you may remember from Seth's recent Neck Sharpies on dealing with Mesh (i.e. Ohio State WRs dragging across the middle with a rub).

In the News

Freeman has certainly come up on the board quite a bit but I couldn't find any main page content with his name. So no word on how Brian feels about him, to the extent that means anything to you.

Elswehere, his name is coming up all over the country for open jobs. Maize n Brew had him on the short list to replace Brown. Tiger Details calls him "the hottest name in the country" in reviewing options to replace Bo Pelini. Hammer and Rails wants him at Purdue and he's been listed as a candidate for a first-time HC position at Illinois.

That said, he signed an extension with Cincinnati last year and turned down a chance to move to the B1G when Mel Tucker came calling:

"I have goals, personal goals, and one of those is wanting to be a head coach, and I believe I don't need to leave the University of Cincinnati to achieve that goal... going to Michigan State didn't make me feel like I was going to be any more closer to it. Did the relationship with Coach Fickell come into play? Absolutely. Did the relationship I have with our kids here come into play? Absolutely."

Defensive Rankings

Ultimately it's all about performance on the field and Cincinnati's defense has been getting it done at 11th in total defense (314 ypg) and 7th in scoring defense (16 ppg). They're shutting opposing QBs down to the tune of a 94.05 efficiency rating (2nd nationally).

For fans of fancy stats, they jumped from 17th in DFEI in 2019 to 5th this year. One possible concern is that the Bearcats have been one of the most penalized teams in the country every year Freeman has been there. I can't separate defense from offense, and maybe that's a Fickell thing, but you might have to brace for some hair-pulling flags under a Freeman unit.

Summary

There's a lot to like about Freeman. He's got multiple years running an arguably elite defense, which should allay concerns that a young guy needs a mentor. I don't think his actual recruiting record will wow anyone pining for someone with proven chops, but it's tough to tell at a mid-major and people have praised him. The personnel fit looks good. I'd be happy with this hire but less convinced the Brinks truck is enough to bring him into a dicey situation in Ann Arbor. He's a loyal Buckeye and coach in waiting should Fickell move up.

What's your take, MGoBoard?

Mongo

December 24th, 2020 at 3:02 PM ^

No more "multiple".  Fucking stuff the run.  Cover 2 and contain to 28 or less PPG.  Simple, just recruit well and rely on the players.  

Offense needs to win games in this era of college football.  Defense just can't be too complex and get out-schemed into brutal, back-breaking big plays.  Contain, contain, contain.  

RockinLoud

December 24th, 2020 at 3:37 PM ^

I remember when UM ran a scheme like this before and all the board did was bitch about how they need to be more aggressive and attacking. Gotta love the UM fanbase.

"Do thing A!!"

*thing A is ok, not great*

"Idiots! Thing A sucks! Do thing B!!"

*UM does thing B, works for a bit, then doesn't*

"Morons! Why aren't they doing thing A!? I've been saying for years they should be doing thing A!!!"

*UM tries thing A once again, it doesn't live up to expectation"

"FFS! How many times do I have to say they should be doing thing B!?!? Thing B will fix everything!!!!"

 

MGoStrength

December 24th, 2020 at 6:28 PM ^

Yes because that has certainly never happened before. 

I have to assume you're referencing Bo and that was almost 50 years ago.  Can you even think of anyone else ever or at least perhaps in the last 20 or so years jumped ship that either played or coached at OSU to then coach at UM?  Even Al Washington didn't play for OSU.  But, he did play at BC where Brown also coached.  Freeman has zero ties to anyone at UM right now.

Pumafb

December 24th, 2020 at 6:52 PM ^

I don’t know a single coach from the D1 level down, that makes decisions based on some loyalty factor over what is best for their career and/or their pocketbook  I know a decent amount of them to some degree as well. It’s about the opportunity the potential job provides them in relation to their career aspirations. If you said he wouldn’t take it because Harbaugh may be a lame duck and he sees Michigan as too big of a mess right now to risk that move, I could get behind you. I haven’t had a coach tell me yet he wouldn’t take a better job with school A because of his loyalty to school B. 

MGoStrength

December 24th, 2020 at 7:07 PM ^

I don’t know a single coach from the D1 level down, that makes decisions based on some loyalty factor over what is best for their career and/or their pocketbook

Sure you do.  Fickell passed up a P5 job at MSU to stay in his hometown state of OH at Cincy.  There's a difference between turning down more money and a better position at some random place and turning down more money and a better position at a rival.  I think you're underestimating the power of OSU's culture and their hatred for UM.

I haven’t had a coach tell me yet he wouldn’t take a better job with school A because of his loyalty to school B. 

Were any of them former or current OSU players or coaches potentially going to UM?  That's a different animal.

Pumafb

December 24th, 2020 at 7:21 PM ^

If Michigan is on par with MSU then you have an argument. It just may be unfortunately for us which would prevent him from taking it. As for the power of the Michigan/OSU rivalry, its not much different than others as much as you think it is. Especially those down here in the south. 

MGoStrength

December 24th, 2020 at 7:34 PM ^

As for the power of the Michigan/OSU rivalry, its not much different than others as much as you think it is. Especially those down here in the south. 

The evidence is to the contrary.  There are a lot of guys that have coached or played at OSU and I can't think of a single one that went to UM afterwards other than Bo.  One out of thousands is not great odds for Freeman coming to UM.  Maybe he's that one, but it's unlikely.

MJ14

December 24th, 2020 at 3:24 PM ^

Could Michigan offer him a DC position and a promise to be coach in waiting? I’m not advocating for that, but Michigan is obviously a head coaching job that is highly sought after. I’m not sure head coaches in waiting ever really work, but how long do you think Harbaugh will be around even if successful? 

Gulo Gulo Luscus

December 24th, 2020 at 3:33 PM ^

That' usually reserved for scenarios where the HC is either close to retirement or likely to move on to a bigger job. I doubt M would offer anything like that, even informally, nor that any candidates would see it as a good thing to be "coach in waiting" in the sense there's a known risk Harbaugh ends up getting canned down the road.

bronxblue

December 24th, 2020 at 3:56 PM ^

It would less than zero sense to offer a 34-year-old DC from Cincy a "coaching in waiting" promise at one of the top 10 jobs in the country with as sparse a track record as he has.

I know this fanbase is desperate for change but this would only piss off a lot of other coaches for no good reason.

Blue Vet

December 24th, 2020 at 3:39 PM ^

Considering that many of our merry band prefer coaches who PROVE they're good by ACTING intense (e.g., Chris Collins on the floor, Tom Izzo as if he's in an opera)...

... maybe we should get Morgan Freeman. He would do a great job acting like an intense coach.

Bo Harbaugh

December 24th, 2020 at 3:50 PM ^

Sounds great, so we aren't getting him.

We will get a guy we should have gotten 3 years ago.  The Michigan Difference

Always 3-5 years behind the elite in CFB.