[Patrick Barron]

Guest Post: Here We Are Comment Count

andyreid14 November 30th, 2022 at 1:02 PM

Ed-Seth: UFR is going to be late because I was knocked out with a nasty illness that now has my whole family it is grippe. Andy Reid (@misterAndyReid) is a former Michigan beat writer who couldn't not write after Saturday. So here's something to read while you wait.

-----------------------

Do not try to explain this feeling to your friends and loved ones who have never been, like you and me, stricken with College Football Madness. Your words will be meaningless. They know Michigan is having a great season, and they are happy and excited for you, but there is nothing you can say or do that will suddenly open their eyes and make them see what this really means. How can you make someone feel what 10-year-old you felt when A-Train punished another defender? When you found a book in the elementary school library about the Little Brown Jug and the depth and myth-making history of this amazing program unfurled before you? When, as a child, you learned what it meant to take pride in something you love, by watching your Maize & Blue heroes vanquish those ne'er-do-wells from Columbus? And when, after decades of ill-defined malaise, the Wolverines strutted into Horseshoe and smacked the ever-loving hell out of the Buckeyes, claiming their rightful place atop the college football landscape and shouting to the world, “The fallow period is finally over”?

[After THE JUMP: A flood]

I never chose to be a Michigan fan. It would feel less permanent if I had ever had an actual chance to. It is part of me, and always has been, from the first picture of me in my crib, swaddled in a Block ‘M’ blanket, to my first trip to the Big House, when I laid across the laps of my grandpa and dad for a second-half nap, because I was too young to make it through a whole game. Michigan football seeped through the soil of my identity and took root deep, deep down, near the core of everything that makes me, me. My favorite memories with my grandpa are watching the Rose Bowl in his cozy basement den or darting through the tailgate, pretending each packed-in car was an oversized Buckeye defender, and I was Biakabutuka, churning my legs through contact and refusing to be taken down. My favorite memories with my family are road trips to Outback Bowls and losing our damn minds together in Section 37 as Braylon snagged yet another miraculous touchdown in our endzone against Michigan State. My favorite memories of college are wrapped up with the team, too, driving all over the Midwest with my Michigan Daily beatmates and crushing the State News in our annual flag football game. My first real job was covering the team for The Wolverine Magazine. When the magazine restructured and I was laid off, I pulled myself through that disappointment, in part, by realizing that Michigan football was no longer my job and I could enjoy it as a fan, once again.

For me, Michigan football is family. Michigan football is history. Michigan football is home. My childhood is defined by it. My adolescence certainly is, too, My young adult life. My highs and lows. Me. I have moved around and changed careers. I have grown and evolved. I have taken steps back and found my footing again. I have quit and been quit on. I have known success and failure. I have been strong and weak. The one constant throughline, from childhood to now, the passion that never dulled, the love that never faded, is Michigan football. It is who I am.

And, for my entire adult life, this fundamental piece of who I am has been largely… underwhelming. Disapproval isn’t the same thing as disavowment. We Michigan fans have, since the entire college football ecosystem erupted in joy when Appalachian State destroyed the Michigan mystique with one well-timed blocked kick, learned to balance love for our team with disappointment with the state of the product on the field. But it is hard to carry the burden of unmet expectations  — season after season, Ohio State loss after Ohio State loss. To be mad, to be hurt, to feel the burden of spoiled promise and know that you will eagerly sign up for more pain when next year’s season ticket applications are mailed out. College football is weird that way, different from other obsessions: it can — and surely will — hurt you, but it can’t hurt you enough to make you walk away.

I will never be able to quit the Wolverines. But, sitting at the peak of that 45-23 lambasting of Ohio State in Columbus and looking back at the hideous valley out from which we have been climbing for the last 15 years, I can see the few dark crevices that definitely shook my faith and tested my fandom in ways I never thought possible.

The RichRod era was certainly unstable, but 2008 was new and different enough that, even though it is unquestionably the worst Michigan team I have ever seen, I never waivered. The next two years were total chaos, but there was definite incremental improvement and, of course, Denard and every thrilling and inexplicable thing he did in a winged helmet. I witnessed first-hand the infamous Josh Groban moment at the 2010 postseason banquet and never thought of loosening the emotional grip Michigan football had on me.

No, there is something worse than being loudly, entertainingly, Capital B Bad.

Sitting in a half-empty Michigan Stadium in 2014 and watching the team run out of gas against Maryland, ensuring that the Wolverines would lose to both them and Rutgers in their inaugural Big Ten season, was gutting. Hearing the boos drown out that day’s announcement that the streak of consecutive 100,000-plus crowds had continued when it so clearly hadn’t was, simply, depressing. The gigantic waitlist for season tickets had dried up. The Michigan Union was advertising that a Coca-Cola purchase in the basement general store came with two free tickets. This was something new. Something awful. Apathy, everywhere. And it was so much more unbearable than another loss to Ohio State.

And then Harbaugh pointed his energy cannon at the problem and immediately made everyone care again. But we know that’s not the end of the story. And maybe the well of emotions that rose up when MIke Sainristil popped that perfect pass out of Cade Stover’s enormous hands wouldn’t have been quite so overwhelming, had Harbaugh simply strolled in and waved a magic wand. No, we weren’t quite done suffering. There was still work to do.

The next, and somewhat more existential, threat to my passion for the Wolverines was the COVID-shortened 2020 season. Harbaugh, it seemed, was not the answer. The apathy was back, heightened by distance — both physical, from the crowd ban at games, and emotional, because the world was so strange and weird, it was hard to jump feet first into the season — and losses and a dreadful feeling that the baldfaced greed that had tightened its influence on college football for the last 30 years had finally gone too far, that forcing the unpaid kids to play a game for our enjoyment, while they were stranded away from their families on an empty campus, slogging through a season no one enjoyed, was simply too much to stomach. These were forces both in and out of Michigan’s control, but, near the conclusion of that miserable campaign, I seriously considered whether I could continue investing myself emotionally in this thing I have loved my entire life. I told my wife at one point that I will be happy to attend games with my family, have fun tailgates and enjoy myself, but I didn’t think I could continue to stir up the same fervor I usually reserve for Michigan football.

Now, here we are.

The heartache that baked itself into the fabric of Michigan fandom is gone. Every streak has ended. The dread has lifted; the storm has passed; the skies are clear and Michigan is — at long last and with no qualifications, nor any ifs, ands or buts — an excellent football team. We are great. There is no team to fear. There is no giant collapse on the horizon. Novembers are no longer poisoned with withering performances and merciless stumbles to the finish line, instead replaced by glorious attention and celebratory joy of a team that has, for two straight seasons now, accomplished its mission. 

I had forgotten this feeling. I had forgotten how electric and kinetic and ALIVE this all felt. Rooting for a team this good is FUN. For so long, the Wolverines could not ascend the mountain this high. My love for Michigan did not dwindle, but the unending misery of consecutive and unalterable mediocrity had certainly dulled the edges. I stuck with it. I cheered. I lamented. I talked about the pieces that were in place for next year. I daydreamed about catching the Buckeyes on the right afternoon. I hoped, but knew better.

There is no more daydreaming. There is no more hoping. The expectations have been met, exceeded and destroyed. We Michigan fans have endured the long winter, and spring has sprung, and our hearts are full, and our team is fantastic, and we can all just be along for the ride. We don’t have to worry. We don’t have to fret. We don’t have to get worked up about missed opportunities or crippling mistakes. We get to bask in the glory of consecutive unforgettable seasons. Consecutive ass-kickings of that team that has kicked our ass for so long it felt like we might always get kicked, never do the kicking, again. Extended success. Dominance. Glory.

Michigan clawed its way back from the brink of the abyss at the end of the 2020 season and gave us a truly special year. When Michigan beat Ohio State in the 100th game of the series in 2003, I was not allowed to join the throng of fans hurling themselves over the Big House walls to rush the field. I was a sophomore in high school, and my dad said it was too dangerous. I would have plenty of time to rush the field after a big win. By the next time Michigan fans joined the players on the field in celebration, it was 2011, and I was a working journalist and couldn’t participate in the festivities. I am so grateful to that team for allowing me to check that off my bucket list — the entire magical ride of the 2021 season, for me, can be summed up in the thrill of hoisting myself over the railing and landing, too hard, on my heels on the playing surface below, streaking for midfield in a mass of euphoric chaos to join the chorus of revelers telling each out to Pump It Up. You gotta Pump It Up, don’t yah know?

That team, led by Aiden Hutchinson’s infectious energy, completely revived my passion. It wasn’t just that they were good. They were fun. And they were having fun, and it was so fun to watch them have fun.  It felt like a magical ride, an incredible confluence of events that snapped a perfect fairytale into reality to help remind us about all the wonder and joy that college football can bring. I had given up on the idea that Michihgan could consistently compete with the truly elite echelon of the sport — I had resized my expectations toward a good program, not a great one.

And once again, now, here we are.

I have never been so happy to be wrong. These Wolverines are better than that special team from last year. They are maulers. The floor is so much higher than I ever thought it could be in the current landscape. The Wolverines have won their most recent game against every other program in the Big Ten. They are 24-2 since that insufferable COVID season. They are reigning and hopeful Big Ten Champions and College Football Playoff participants. They are a team that dominates Ohio State. They are elite. They are an incredible football team.

Last year was purely cathartic. This was something else. The first quarter was overflowing with signals that this would be just like every other version of The Game we have come to expect since Jim Tressel seized control of the rivalry. The Buckeyes scorched right down for an easy opening-drive score. Michigan’s best player, the anchor of the entire offensive identity, made one cut and limped off the field, clearly not able to go. This is where the turtling happens. This is where camera shots of the sideline reveal taut, stern faces. This is where wins turn to losses, and where the overwhelming confidence from the Scarlet force simply drowns out any hope that Michigan could string together enough luck to overcome Ohio State’s obvious advantages in both athleticism and strategy.

And, yet once again, here we are.

It was the Wolverines who were smiling, laughing, and making plays with everything on the line. It was the Michigan side outsmarting Ohio State at every possible turn. It was the Buckeyes who puckered up and played tight. For decades, it has felt like Michigan entered this game with the overwhelming pressure to just win one. On Saturday, one look at Ryan Day’s funereal grimace was all the evidence we needed to know the fulcrum had shifted. It’s now the Buckeyes who are playing like they are afraid of what will happen if they lose. JJ McCarthy, Cornelius Johnson, Mike Sainristil, Donovan Edwards all became legends on Saturday afternoon, grabbing the last albatross around the Wolverines’ neck — a 22-year drought in Columbus — and hurling it into space, like Hercules with the bear. Every burden on the Michigan program has been erased. Every dreadful streak, every pin that could possibly be pricked. The curse of being a Michigan fan these last 20 years has been the knowledge of how great our beloved program used to be, and the ever-creeping doubt that it would ever be able to reach those heights again.

Here we are.

I sincerely want to thank everyone involved with the program for what they have given us these last two years. We have learned, the hard way, that getting to this point — and staying there over the course of multiple seasons — is an incredibly difficult thing to do. The fans are so grateful for this run. I will always love this team. But I will be disappointed when they’re disappointing; mad when they’re maddening; frustrated when they are frustrating — which has been the case for so much of the last 15 years. Right now, I am happy. Thrilled. Ecstatic. Excited. Because my favorite team — my team! — is terrific.

It’s Great

To Be

A Michigan Wolverine.

Comments

tybert

November 30th, 2022 at 2:52 PM ^

RR was likely on his way out, but that banquet experience (and getting mocked by Groban) made him look softer than the run D that had two Wisky RBs combined to run for over 350 yards on us in what turned out to be RR's last home game. "You lift me up" ended turning into a 52-14 crushing by Miss State and into "don't bring me down (Bruce)" (ELO). Given what's happened to RR since, not sure he would have ever lasted here with the off the field stuff that happened at Zona.

goblu330

November 30th, 2022 at 1:25 PM ^

Wow, this is really good.

Particularly poignant is the part about stages of life being kind of "defined" by what Michigan football was doing.  I remember that my first son was born in 2007 largely because my wife was pregnant during Armageddon.  I remember that App State was also 2007 because I had to watch the second half on BTN in a dive bar with my son in a detached car seat because it wasn't on my cable.  I remember that I had knee surgery in December 2016 because it would have been a much better month of immobility if I could have been watching highlights of Michigan winning The Game the whole time.

Michigan football is pretty much the context for every period of my life.  Sad?  Maybe.  But also true.

Koop

November 30th, 2022 at 6:46 PM ^

This fundamental truth is underserved: fandom defines the fans much, if not more, than it does the participants on the field.

My (nerdy) analogues are Marvel Comics' groundbreaking graphic novel, "Marvels," written entirely with the camera turned around to focus on the people watching the historic events in the Marvel universe.

Or I reflect on the (equally if not more-nerdy) Doctor Who episode "Love & Monsters," which focused on London residents who had caught glimpses of the hero and whose group to investigate his appearances turns into a social club with romances and impromptu jam sessions.

The TV coverage, the "30 for 30s," the retrospectives 10-, 20-, and 30 years later will focus on the players, the coaches, and the games. But we fans will remember these events as they happened in our lives--and that fandom will be the through-line amidst life's inevitable ups and downs:

  • September 1990, I arrive at the "No. 1 vs. No One" UM-MSU game with a splitting headache from taking the LSAT that morning and watch in disbelief from the student section goal line as Desmond Howard is tripped in the end zone and there's no call.
  • November 1994, I watch from a hotel room visiting my then-girlfriend and future wife. I'm thinking about what our future life together will look like at Touchdown Tim torches the Buckeyes.
  • November 1997, I've prepared handouts of Michigan-OSU facts for guests who are with my newlywed wife and me watching the game in our young married's apartment on our big enormous 20" screen.
  • September 2002, with our toddler son asleep in a Baby Bjorn, I'm watching Michigan kick a game-winning field goal against Washington. Our son wakes up suddenly to 100,000+ people all screaming in joyful unison.
  • November 2006, I'm watching "Judgment Day" with my now-five-year-old son (a moment that he--now a senior in the Engineering school--tells me is his earliest living memory). As the game ends, with tears in my eyes, I tell him to pay attention to how the players make a point of shaking each other's hands, win or lose.
  • November 2021, I'm watching that same son and his younger sister--now LSA '25--on selfie videos as they stormed the field.

So many memories. We all have them. Cliche or no, they form part of the quilt of our lives.

schreibee

December 1st, 2022 at 7:00 AM ^

Love the perspective - imagine many who read this (and corresponding others of other team's fanbases) share similar personal timelines that mark life events correlating with team failures & successes. 

One quibble tho - "Judgement Day" was at psu 1997. I've never heard at osu 2006 called that before 

Joby

November 30th, 2022 at 1:36 PM ^

Thanks for this, Andy. Enjoyed this article for two reasons: 1) the soaring, Ufer-like prose detailing these last two glorious seasons and 2) the description of the emotional impact of the 2020 season, which gave this program (and college football writ large, and the rest of the world with it) an immediate notice that things had to change.

 

And for Seth: “now has my whole family [in its] grippe. 


I see what you did there! Quick recovery for you.

Lou MacAdoo

November 30th, 2022 at 1:43 PM ^

Epic guest post. We're so very fortunate. Hopefully Buckeye fans will now go through thier own version of this journey and end up a little less spoiled and insufferable at it's inevitable conclusion. Go Blue!

Blue Jam

November 30th, 2022 at 1:45 PM ^

I sent this to my girlfriend who (while supportive) does not quite understand my attachment to Michigan football. Maybe she will now. Thank you, this is beautiful.

Cubbieblue and BLUE

November 30th, 2022 at 4:19 PM ^

I immediately sent this to my wife for the same reason.  She is a Northwestern grad, who didn't care about football until Fitz changed that during her years there.  She doesn't understand how our parent's breed this passion into us from as long as we can remember.  She thinks it's cute that I practically lost my voice by the time Edwards broke his second long run, and I am running around the house jumping up and down like a five-year-old. I will never forget this game as long as I live.

bluebrains98

November 30th, 2022 at 1:45 PM ^

Excellent piece. I have found myself recently contemplating about how odd it is that, before games, I would get as amped up to watch Threet/Sheridan as I do now. This program, somehow, just has me. The difference now is I get to keep thinking about games with a smile on my face after it's over rather than pretending the games didn't happen. I prefer this to the UM football dark ages.

tybert

November 30th, 2022 at 3:05 PM ^

Threet/Sheridan, argh!

I remember being at a very meaningless game at end of a 3-9 season at home in miserable mist/sleet for an ugly low scoring home loss to NW. I think MGOBLOG gave out digital patches to commemorate everyone who sat through that debacle (I think we may have had 30,000 fans). 

flashOverride

November 30th, 2022 at 1:48 PM ^

"Every streak has ended" made me remember something really awesome that I realized over the weekend - Harbaugh has now cleaned up every last of the annoying, persistent road losing streaks Michigan had in the conference. Before last year, Michigan hadn't won at Wisconsin since 2001 and had never won at Nebraska. Before this year, they hadn't won at Iowa since 2005, and Ohio State, well, I think we all know that one. An underrated achievement, because at least for me, a hallmark of Michigan fandom for the last two decades or so was dreading any road game against anyone remotely decent.

Superbly written, by the way!

Gob Wilson

November 30th, 2022 at 1:49 PM ^

Great article. My dad and grandfather took me to games when I was 5 and I also fell asleep. And the article rings true as a UM fan from the early 1960s my memories are gilded by the football seasons and especially The Game. 1968, Ap State and the horror and losing to Toledo in October 2008 were lows along with 2020. It has been a long, slow grinding hike to near the apex of the mountain.

My father used to say that those that start at the bottom of the mountain and have to fight hard to get to the top stay there the longest. This is true and I think Michigan is back.  

M_Born M_Believer

November 30th, 2022 at 1:51 PM ^

I am old enough to have been witness to the '70s, '80s, and '90s.

My oldest son was born in 2000, my second was born in '06.  They grew tired of listening to me talk about how great Michigan is and that someday they can make it back.

For my oldest one, he did buy in from the start and Shoelaces did a whole lot to lock in his fandom.  He did go all bombastic during the '16 OSU game and took the bitter pill in the muffed punt game. But he stuck through it because in '15 when Jim came home, he believed this day would come.

For my younger son, it was a little different, he only saw the disaster of RR / Hoke era, was only 5 at the time they won in '11.  But loves football and is a powerback RB himself growing up, so he started to cheer for Wisconsin as well as Michigan.  His fandom for Michigan was, 'I "have" to pick someone within this state and Dad has highlighted enough BS about the other school that there is no way I am cheering for them.'  But just as my oldest bought in with Jim's arrival, so did my youngest.  Now old enough to understand the whole picture of CFB.

These last 2 years has been unbelievable and vindication of faith I kept instilling into my boys that Michigan once again can sit among the elite football programs.

Went to Indy last year with them and my brother (UM alum class of '87) and we are going back again this year.  Nothing will be taken for granted and experiencing the best part of fandom will be soaked in like a cleansing of the soul.

Vasav

November 30th, 2022 at 4:25 PM ^

yea a competitive rivalry is good but even better is a competitive big ten where M is the dominant power. Like, M wins 6-7 Big Ten 'ships in the '20s, with a rotating cast of dangerous foes and Ohio is only one of them.

Actually i take it back I want to be bama but more.

stetgor

November 30th, 2022 at 1:52 PM ^

Wow!  While I visit this site several times per day, I rarely post - unless, of course, there's something that simply compels me to do so.  This was that post.  Captured many of the ups and downs I've felt over 50+ years of MEEECHIGAN fandom.  Fantastic, and thank you.  

Venom7541

November 30th, 2022 at 2:02 PM ^

I was at the 100th game with my now ex wife. She and I were briefly on Gameday with some random stranger. I don't even remember the field being rushed, but I do remember beating OSU was normal and clueless what the next 20 years would hold. I can now say, after nearly 20 years of mediocrity, that my high preseason expectations are no longer optimistic to the point of delusion, but now realistic.

leidlein

November 30th, 2022 at 2:03 PM ^

I too felt like I had no choice to become a Michigan Wolverine. Most of my family did not attend college, and allegiance to Michigan or MSU was split. In my family, including cousins, aunts, uncles, etc, it would be perfectly fine to choose either school to root for, and many family members rooted for both.

But I recall football Saturdays on my dad's couch at a very young age. Those uniforms. That helmet. Watching Bo pace the sidelines. I was pulled in. I fell in love. This was not a choice.

In high school, when I unexpectedly was admitted to UM, again I had no choice. There was no doubt UM was by far the best school I would be admitted to. I immediately knew I was going to spend the next few years in Ann Arbor. I would have been an idiot to turn that down.

Now as an adult with 3 grown children, one of whom attends UM, another who works at the hospital as a UM employee not too far from my wife's department (also a UM employee at the hospital), UM is such a huge part of who I am. My identity. I am a 2X alum (MBA 2006). I wear that on my sleeve proudly.

I was spoiled during school. I took 5 years to graduate (engineering). The basketball team won a national championship my freshman year, and the Fab 5 took us to two final 4 appearances. The football team went to 4 Rose Bowls in the 5 years I attended UM as an undergrad.

We fell on hard times. I knew we would return. I never lost faith. The football team of the past 2 years, you articulated so well. They have fun, they are fun to watch. Thank you to everyone involved with the team in any capacity.

tybert

November 30th, 2022 at 2:47 PM ^

You were there during some glorious times indeed. The hoops team had three final fours and one title in 5 years. Four RBs, with two wins. I was just happy to see some good times mid 80s when JH was our Qb and Freider (pre ASU) won back to back hoops B1G titles. Loved seeing the basketball team show up for pizza at Thano's lamplighter while having pizza and brew on a Thursday night. What good times!

Blueroller

November 30th, 2022 at 2:07 PM ^

Man that really hit home. I'm a third-generation double legacy. Both my grandfathers graduated in 1924. One was on the faculty for 30 years. My dad had three Michigan degrees before he moved out of the house. My mom didn't go to Michigan but her brothers did and that's how she met my dad. My grandfather had season tickets for 50 years. He had great stories, like trying to drive to Columbus for the infamous Snow Bowl game in the 50s. I went to my first game in diapers. The first one I remember is when I was 13, the 1973 10-10 tie with Ohio State. We had a big tailgating setup at the golf course throughout those years. Even after I became disabled and unable to travel in 1980, I followed Michigan football as closely as I could from home in NY. 

No matter how dark the Dark Ages got, I couldn't pull away. I floundered through various feats of mental gymnastics to keep my soul from getting crushed. In the depths of BPONE I kept thinking, of course Michigan will beat Ohio State. I just hope it happens before I die. Last year was ecstasy. This year was something deeper, a feeling that we are back to something like we were in the 70s, only maybe even better. For my dad and my uncles, Michigan football winning was the natural order of the universe. They took little joy from all but the biggest wins. They were appalled by any loss. I know better. I will never take winning for granted. I'll appreciate years like last year and this year for all they are worth. Living through the Dark Ages of Michigan football made me a better fan. The Glory Days are back! Long may they last! Go Blue!!!

KennyHiggins

November 30th, 2022 at 2:25 PM ^

This post hit me w all the feels, though I was born in Ann Arbor in the 60s to two graduates, and enjoyed my college years in the '80s.  I have more Michigan gear than can fit in a small closet, even after "sharing" much of it w my UM alum kids.  Feels like an eternity since we've been the real Michigan.  Can't wait to be in Ann Arbor next year to celebrate "our" 1000th victory and third straight run to the CFP.  Thank you, Jimmy.  We're back, baby.

Go BLUE