His Dudeness

November 11th, 2011 at 1:51 PM ^

Because most universities understand it takes more than 3 years to begin to win big. It's the Bowden theory and it is true. Michigan wasn't a debacle as much as it was a screw job. If given an actual shot RR will win big. Reasonable people see that.

GetSumBlue

November 11th, 2011 at 2:01 PM ^

Apparently Michigan is not reasonable. Good Lord. The guy is a good coach, but it didn't work out at the winningest program in college football, reasonable people see that as well.

People assume that debacle automatically means "OMG he's trashing RR, KILL HIM". No, it was a failure on all parts, but this has been discussed ad nausem.

His Dudeness

November 11th, 2011 at 2:03 PM ^

Thanks for bringing it up again, man.

It didn't work out because nobody gave him a reasonable chance. 3 years is nowhere near reasonable. Weis got 5. Zook is still going... Michigan is far from reasonable.

Oaktown Wolverine

November 11th, 2011 at 3:20 PM ^

The recruiting was there but not the player development. Coaching is not just Xs and Os, but also technique, fundamentals, etc. Schematically he was great at putting players where they needed to be, but he did not do enough to develop their skills .In any case, wouldn't ND have been better off canning Weis after 3 years instead of 5? 

GetSumBlue

November 11th, 2011 at 2:11 PM ^

That's one of the issues with this board. Someone asks a resonable question: Why do you think a major program would hire RR after MIchigan?

Instead of: Well, some people think he just didn't get enough tme and really would do well with say 5 years. Therefore, they would probably give him a chance.

People get: Fuck off, you're an RR hater. We get it, your a dick, etc etc. RR is my home boy for life!

I don't know, maybe it's just me.

profitgoblue

November 11th, 2011 at 2:17 PM ^

No, no, I think you misunderstand what I'm saying.  That question and discussion is definitely a good one - a very interesting topic.  However, its been discussed numerous times, both intelligently and passionately.  All I am saying is that I think we all know you're position (I have seen you state it several times) and there's no need to rehash all this again.  No more good can come from it.

RowoneEndzone

November 11th, 2011 at 2:18 PM ^

I can see where you are coming from, I just sensed a combative attitude from your posts about RR and like I mentioned up top this has played out many times on the board and some people that spend a lot of time on here will engage quickly when the bait is hanging there.  Read my post up top to see where we are coming from.  

RowoneEndzone

November 11th, 2011 at 2:03 PM ^

Yup, it's so GD hard to relive that.  It's very well written so now it feels like I'm in the locker room with them.  I slowed down at page 200 but was reading like 40-50 pages a day until then.  That's a shitload of reading for me considering I have not read a book through since college which was 8 years ago. 

profitgoblue

November 11th, 2011 at 2:08 PM ^

I put that same kind of ban on reading for pleasure after school.  I think it lasted well over 10 years but now I'm reading more regularly.

I must say that the first portion that covers Lloyd leaving, the search, and Rodriguez's start was entrancing.  I learned so much about the inner-workings of a big-time football program from this book.  Kudos to Bacon for the research and straightforward writing.

 

profitgoblue

November 11th, 2011 at 2:47 PM ^

Not that you care, but I tried the "40 Complex" in the gym earlier this week.  (As a refresher, its 8 upright rows, 8 clean and jerks, 8 jerks, 8 clean and jerks, and 8 bent rows without letting the bar touch the ground.)  I was able to do it with very light weight but it was brutal.  I'm curious as to how much Bacon put on the bar.

 

Moleskyn

November 11th, 2011 at 1:55 PM ^

Man, I'm sure wherever he goes next he'll be great. I feel like Ole could be his best opportunity: they've got tradition, recognition for being in the SEC, access to southern recruits who fit his system the best. Then again, there is the general sleeziness of the SEC, but he could be a positive influencer.

BlockM

November 11th, 2011 at 2:01 PM ^

I want Rodriguez to end up at a national power (outside the B1G obviously...), solely to see how high that offense can go. I have a feeling that if he went to Florida, Alabama, LSU, Texas, Oklahoma, etc. he could continue rewriting how college football is played. Obviously none of those schools have openings right now, but eventually I would love to watch that happen.

Mitch Cumstein

November 11th, 2011 at 2:15 PM ^

One thing I always hated (and still do) about those offenses is when the players lineup without a huddle, get set, and then relax and look at the sideline for direction.  I get the point of it, but for some reason that always bothered me.  I feel like once the line is set, that should be it.  If a defensive linemen went crashing through the line on that relaxation, I wonder how it would be called. 

mtzlblk

November 12th, 2011 at 12:56 PM ^

I will always be a fan of RR and will likely buy a whole second set of gear for whatever team he ends up at. I don't care if people commenting above think that is weird, he was a good man that was treated poorly from day one. He had his chance at UM, that is true, however that chance was undoubtedly diminished by a certain segment of the administration and fanbase that were against him from the start. Given that the margin for him staying/going was fairly close, we will never know if it was a determinant in the equation. Personally, I will always think that given budget for a decent/stellar DC and 1-2 more years, he would have built M into a national powerhouse with a modern scheme that would have been a dynasty. My opinion, you are welcome to yours.

I really would love to see him get another chance to 'do his thing' at a powerhouse program and enjoy the success that he deserves as a major innnovator for the game. I just hope to God he does not end up at OSU, then i would have to hate him, plus we would have to play against him and I really, really, do not want to have to do that.