OT: MGoHunters Random Questions

Submitted by Teach_Coach_GoBlue on April 14th, 2020 at 10:07 AM

I did a fishing version of this a week or so ago, and really enjoyed hearing the type of fishing everyone enjoys. I don't hunt as much as I used to because of a variety of reasons (coaching being one of them), but still love spending time in the woods back home when I can. So here are the questions:

1. What method do you enjoy the most (archery, shotgun, rifle)?

2. Favorite quarry?

3. Bucket list hunt/location?

 

My answers:

1. Archery; I shoot a compound now, but have a friend who builds traditional bows, and would love to build one and start learning to shoot traditional archery. Not sure that I would hunt with one, but I like the idea of shooting traditional archery. 

2. Toss up between whitetail and turkeys. Not much beats the rut, but a turkey thundering back to you is quite a rush too.

3. I'd love to do a back country elk bow hunt. Fishing is a bigger part of my life now, so I'd rather spend money on a fishing trip than a hunting trip, but if I could ever do a DIY elk hunt on the cheap with a friend who knew what they were doing, I'd love that. 

Commie_High96

April 14th, 2020 at 10:12 AM ^

I do like hunting, but I am more about harvesting than going for trophies.  Most years I shoot does as they generally taste better.

i actually love the Muzzleloading season as it is late, usually snowy and peaceful.  I also prefer to fish for Steel during rifle season as the rivers are less crowded and October archery is often too warm for me to want to go.

i too hope to shoot an elk out west some day as I think elk (with moose as a close second) is the best tasting game.  

duck hunting is fun as it is social, you can talk and drink coffee in the blind between flights.  But it is a real hassle because of all the equipment, deeks, blind building, etc., and we don’t get flights like in the Dakotas or AR.  Then again, they aren’t getting the flights they used to either as climate change is disrupting migrations

Teach_Coach_GoBlue

April 14th, 2020 at 10:24 AM ^

Same here on the trophy hunting. I'm hoping to shoot a nice buck someday, but it is not my end goal. I got into duck hunting for awhile in college and thought it was a riot, but got to the point where it was time to spend some coin to stay in the game and was also getting into fly fishing at the same time. I chose fly fishing as there's more access and opportunity around me. 

DrMantisToboggan

April 14th, 2020 at 10:16 AM ^

I'm more of a fisherman, but get out hunting a few times a year maybe.

1. Shotgun

2. Fowl

3. I have always wanted to hunt boar. I have a couple cousins who do down in Missouri and they've taken some behemoths and seem to have a good time (and get some delicious meat).

Dopamine

April 14th, 2020 at 10:29 AM ^

1. What method do you enjoy the most (archery, shotgun, rifle)?

Can't beat archery hunting - truly nothing better than sitting with your bow in the woods on an early November morning. In the past couple years I've gotten into muzzleloader hunting as well. It's fun to tinker with different bullets/powder combinations to see what fires best from your gun.

2. Favorite quarry?

While it may be sacrilege to deer hunting, I have to say that I enjoy wild turkey hunting the most. I love being in the warming spring woods, being able to watch everything come alive around me. Also, turkeys are just badass animals to see in the wild and especially up close. Contrary to what some people might assume, these animals are incredibly wary and smart and they have some of the best vision in the animal kingdom.

3. Bucket list hunt/location?

Something out west someday

Teach_Coach_GoBlue

April 14th, 2020 at 10:36 AM ^

Turkeys are incredibly smart. If they could smell you'd never kill one. I think they are delicious as well. Overall I think they are great to hunt. The first one I shot was a story I'll always remember with my dad. He was calling and I was sitting in some brush against a tree. The Tom came out from my right and I already had my gun raised, but I put my head down on the stock to aim and he saw me. Couldn't believe it, but as he turned to leave after seeing me, I swung my gun over the brush, dad started whispering, "No, no, no, NO... okay good shot" after I dropped him. Heart pounding hunt and a great memory with my dad. Great turkey too, 11 1/2'' beard and 1 3/4" spurs. Best one to date. 

gobluem

April 14th, 2020 at 11:39 AM ^

I'd say turkeys are really stupid, but they are incredibly wary and  have incredible eyesight

They don't have a ton of brainpower and do a lot of stupid stuff.  Strutting in the face of a 1/2 ton pickup, trying to fight their reflection in a storefront window, trying for an hour to mate with a really fake looking plastic decoy, etc

 

But dang if you move an 1/8th of an inch at the wrong time, kiss em goodbye

RoxyMtnHiM

April 14th, 2020 at 10:40 AM ^

I'm an upland bird hunter. Used to hunt a fair bit of big game, whitetail, mule deer, elk, antelope. After I got my first bird dog, a pointing lab, things shifted. Dogs are a lifestyle.

I have access to some private land in Boulder/Larimer counties, do usually buy a private land tag, and it can be fairly easy to take a mulie or cow elk. The area is loaded with turkeys these days as well. 

But grouse, quail and pheasants are my thing. Most years I hunt about ~30 days a season in eastern Colorado and western Nebraska. Blue grouse season opens in the mountains on Sept 1 (though I'm usually fishing hard in the fall), then I'll start hunting the Plains in mid-October for prairie grouse once snake weather subsides, and now and then make an end-of-season trip in early February to Arizona to hunt quail.

Shoot a 28ga sxs mainly. Rifle is a Ruger #1B .30-06 with Leopold 40mm.

Bucketlists aren't really what I do. I'm always very gratified just to be in my favorite places in SW Nebraska, some places I've been hunting every season since the mid 90s. In January, it's my favorite place on Earth.

Teach_Coach_GoBlue

April 14th, 2020 at 10:44 AM ^

You've returned. And you've brought your enviable answers with you again! I've never hunted upland birds, but it is something I think I would enjoy. Have friends that go to South Dakota every fall for a long weekend pheasant hunting, and would like to do that someday. 

RoxyMtnHiM

April 14th, 2020 at 11:03 AM ^

Yep. Anytime I look like I'm headed out for anything, she's right on my heels. My previous boat was a custom mod of a jon boat I did myself, fully carpeted, very dog friendly. My current boat is a poling skiff, the deck is not so dog friendly and she she can't ride on the front deck like she likes. Sometimes she jumps in after a hooked fish. Hilarity ensues, especially if it's a carp tearing around in inches of water.

mgobaran

April 14th, 2020 at 10:52 AM ^

Not a hunter. My family just wasn't into it enough to get me involved at a young age. Friends never got me involved any further than a drunken "hey, we need to go hunting THIS fall, for real. I swear I won't forget to ask before I'm already packed and ready to go this year." At this point who knows if I'd pull the trigger on a deer if it's in my sights. 

I'd love to go bird hunting sometime though. My uncles have had some great bird dogs in the past, and there is something much more alluring to me about getting a buzz on with your friends, walking trails, chit chatting, and allowing a dog fulfill it's bred purpose. 

1408

April 14th, 2020 at 1:33 PM ^

You will have a very hard time finding a serious hunter that will drink and hunt.  Nothing like the scotch hitting your mouth after 6 hours in the cold chasing down pheasants but *never* do it before or during (in my view).  

It's hard enough to walk through tall corn, sorghum, etc., sober with dogs and other hunters near you.  Can't fathom doing it while drinking.  I would never entertain it.

RoxyMtnHiM

April 14th, 2020 at 2:13 PM ^

You can't unshoot something.

I used to hunt with some guys, but they were mainly in it for the drinking and we soon parted ways.  They'd show up late to camp, hungover, spend the days drinking. Not my scene. 

hunterjoe

April 14th, 2020 at 10:57 AM ^

1.  Archery

2.  Elk (whitetail is very close and is my normal favorite)

3.  This is tough, archery elk hunt with someone who know's what they're doing is high on the list but so is a moose hunt.  If I had to pick one, it would be a moose hunt.  I can do the archery elk hunt about any year.  Red stag is also another.  That's a bucket list due to the scenery too.  

Yessir

April 14th, 2020 at 10:59 AM ^

Mountain quail here in California.  There are plenty here on my property but I head up I-80 a lil bit and hunt there.  
 

I don’t hunt turkey anymore but just started calling them in. Only 1 Tom so far.  Didn’t shoot it. Same reason. My property. There are 2 hens that come in as soon as I start calling.  There’s a ridge right at my property line that drops off and they are always down the valley.  Love the calling as much as hunting. 
 

same as others on duck hunting. Used to love it but lots of work. Pacific flyway is amazing. 

RoxyMtnHiM

April 14th, 2020 at 11:12 AM ^

Mountain quail is the bird that has eluded me so far. I've had only limited opportunities, in SoCal, and wasn't at all sure about what I was doing. I've never even seen one. Bobwhites, blues, Gambel's and Cali's those I've hunted.  Quail with a pointing dog and double gun, that's my favorite hunting thing.

I love to eat wild duck, it's up there among my favorites, which are blue grouse, ruffed grouse, any quail. But shooting over decoys is not much my thing, so I do a bit of jumpshooting in places line North Park. Illinois and Michigan Rivers, North Platte (have to be alert for moose always) and sometimes load non-tox while hunting quail in the South Platte riverbottom in case we jump ducks in a slough.

Satansnutsack

April 14th, 2020 at 11:16 AM ^

I hunt pheasants because I have an awesome German Shorthaired Pointer that is an excellent hunter.  If it wasn't for him, I wouldn't hunt.  

RoxyMtnHiM

April 14th, 2020 at 11:21 AM ^

I know what you mean. It's not the same sport, with or without dogs. I've had a season here and there without a field-ready dog and I just didn't hunt. I missed it, went out for the obligatory/token day, but it was just not the same.

tspoon

April 14th, 2020 at 11:28 AM ^

1. Archery - because I can do it off my deck into my back yard, which backs up to 30+ acres of woods ... and I live in a rapidly expanding suburb of Charlotte, so every deer I whack is a public service (out town opts into an extended archery season to maximize the chance of filling your limit)

2. White tail ... though the squirrels around me who think they have a right to my family's bird feeder might file a formal protest

3. Helo hog hunting ... if I get a deal done I'm working on right now, it may actually become a near-term reality!

 

 

TSimpson77

April 14th, 2020 at 11:30 AM ^

1. Archery, I love the challenge of it. I shoot an Elite right now, because I tore my bicep a few years ago and the back tension is light light light. I prefer to shoot a Matthews though. 

2. I actually prefer coonhunting, I hunt with treeing walker coonhounds. I really don't kill a lot, it's more about the world of competition coonhunting for me and the time alone in the woods listening to a hound move a track and come treed. 

3. I am planning on an elk hunt in the next couple years out to Montana, I have actually started to condition myself for this adventure already because Montana air and mountains are definitely not the same as Indiana air and hills. 

RoxyMtnHiM

April 14th, 2020 at 11:53 AM ^

No, they are not, and then you drop your first bull elk, if you're in the 20% or so of elk hunters who fill a tag, and the size of the beast makes you think o shit what have I done... As they say, the real work starts when you pull the trigger. But, man, good groceries.

Booted Blue in PA

April 14th, 2020 at 11:36 AM ^

1.  I love archery hunting for whitetails.... late Oct early Nov the weather is decent, no bugs and the deer aren't overly pressured....   Great stuff!

2. Grouse over a good pointer.  My last GSP, Mr. Fritz, had to be put down a month ago, he was 13 years old and had cancer.....  Within a year I'm getting a German Wirehaired Pointer pup. Looking forward to training another pointer and spending a lot of time in the field lookin' for birds.

3.  Archery moose hunt.  in '03 I took myself on a rifle moose hunt in Ontario, as a divorce gift to me.  I was fortunate enough to take a young bull (36" wide rack).  Since then I've gone on several train in fishing trips with a great outfitter north of Sudbury who has peaked my interest in going after moose with my compound.   One day.

gobluem

April 14th, 2020 at 11:44 AM ^

1) archery by far. It's quiet, longer deer season, a lot more peaceful

 

2) deer is the most frequent and I do love it, especially for the food aspect, but if I had to pick forever and all else (season, availability, etc) equal I'd pick spring turkey hunting. Love to be out in the woods that time of year, and it's so active with calling. 

 

3) As i get older it's not so much of a "where" or "what" but a "who with" thing. Even though I don't love gun hunting deer, I pine for the days of rifle opener for the social side of things. Or going on a 2 week road trip with a family member out to the prairie to bird hunt. Can't really do those things any more due to time and money obligations. 

 

That said, I'd love an extended camping and cast and blast out in the Dakotas or Montana.Turkeys and trout, upland and trout, ducks and pike... whatever!

mrkid

April 14th, 2020 at 12:03 PM ^

I want to get into compound bow hunting. My boys (7 and 6) love their beginner bows we got them for Christmas last year, so I want to make sure Dad is able to teach and hunt with them as their strength develops and the time comes.

Question for the board: What is the best entry level bow?

I don't want to break the bank until I know this will be a passion for me and the boys. Just something that will get the job done until the picture becomes more clear.

Teach_Coach_GoBlue

April 14th, 2020 at 12:08 PM ^

I know these are fewer and far-er between now, but if you have an archery shop nearby sometimes they have pretty good trade ins. I've never bought a brand new bow, always used. There are a lot of people I know who want the newest baddest compound every couple years, so lots of times you can find a good bow for a decent price. As far as brands, I like Matthews; they're not cheap brand new, but like I've said, I find them used. I have heard good things about PSE, and really, most compounds on the market now are pretty good. The really expensive ones have gizmos and doohangers that are a bit overkill for me and how I hunt, but I won't take a long shot at a deer with my bow like some will. 

RoxyMtnHiM

April 14th, 2020 at 12:25 PM ^

Tough ticket here. Colorado issued fewer than 300 bighorn licenses last year, only 27 to non-residents. I know a guy who helped his aunt on a mountain goat hunt a couple years ago, after she spent years accumulating the necessary preference points. Dall sheep in AK might be the most accessible (ie you might be able to get a license) goat hunting in North America.

fassettbd

April 14th, 2020 at 3:16 PM ^

Dall sheep are accessible-that was my first sheep. They are not cheap, but they can be had essentially whenever you want in Alaska and Canada. 

There are many varieties of sheep (and goats) overseas that are generally available and all are cheaper than the other three NA sheep. I have taken a Koryak snow sheep in Kamchatka, Marco Polo on Tajikistan, Kuban Tur in the Caucasus mountains etc. Spain is a great destination for mountain game that you can make a couples trip out of. 

I drew my mountain goat tag in Colorado after 12 years, still waiting to draw my bighorn here though. I will refrain from commenting on our CPW and their bending over to agricultural interests at the expense of wildlife meaning our sheep population is much smaller than it could be...and that is before the wolf initiative that is on the ballot this fall. 

Dantana

April 14th, 2020 at 12:16 PM ^

1. What method do you enjoy the most (archery, shotgun, rifle)?

Rifle hunting up north at our property is the favorite. My family eats nearly only venison for red meat, we rarely buy any beef, so I like to get at least 2 deer a year.

2. Favorite quarry?

Whitetails.

3. Bucket list hunt/location?

Elk hunt out west. Or some type of Alaska hunt. I also have 10 bear points that I would like to finally use here in Michigan.

uminks

April 14th, 2020 at 12:25 PM ^

I use to hunt a lot between ages 8 - 18. Pheasants were quite plentiful in southern MI back in the 60s and 70s and that was my favorite game to hunt. I would go deer hunting as well. Never got into rabbit or squirrel hunting. I use to do a lot of bass fishing that would usually turn into catfish fishing after dark.  Now I hunt with my camera, I'll take a lot of nature shots. 

RoxyMtnHiM

April 14th, 2020 at 12:29 PM ^

Pheasants WERE plentiful in southern Michigan back then. We had them in our backyard on the south edge of Lansing all the time. I used to hunt them around Charlotte and Eaton Rapids.

I had some lean years when I ate a lot of bunnies. Good eats, as is squirrel. I had a roommate who liked my rabbit cacciatore above all else.

1VaBlue1

April 14th, 2020 at 12:39 PM ^

1) Shotgun, because upland birds and ducks are fairly tough shot with a rifle...

2) Upland birds, especially pheasant, quail, and dove.  But ducks are ring-necked close!  Duck hunting is a more social sport than upland because you have some time between flights.

3) A South African upland bird hunt would be so much fun!

I grew up pheasant hunting with Ufer on the radio between fields.  Great times!  And I spent the better part of 25 years training retrievers for both upland and waterfowl hunts.  I both ran dogs in, and judged, non-competitive hunt tests (NAHRA, some AKC), and dabbled with the Super Retriever Series (judged several qualifiers, and two of the Outdoor Games events - the first in Lake Placid, and one in Reno).  My life has since turned in a different direction, but of all the things I've done in my life, it's that part of it that I would go back to in a heartbeat.