OT: G.O.A.T Movies

Submitted by MichiganFan1984 on
So last night my family and I got bored because the basketball game was a blowout so we watched Forrest Gump. This in my opinion is the best movie ever made. It also led to the discussion of what are the best movies ever made. So I’m curious what are your top 3 greatest movies of all time. My top 3 in order are 1. Forrest Gump. 2. Saving Private Ryan. 3. The Dark Knight. Im basing this on the following criteria, the movies should make you think about life, entertain the heck out of you and make you appreciate the characters from a real world perspective. So my questions are.. do you think my 3 are legit or am I crazy? And... what are your top 3 in order. Enjoy the rest of the weekend and hopefully this is the last crap weekend of weather for a while.

Tools Of Ignorance

May 21st, 2018 at 11:44 AM ^

Disagree. Dennis Quaid portrayed John Holliday as a drunken baffoon in Wyatt Earp. While he may not have been the hero that he was portrayed as in Tombstone, he was a highly educated man. He turned to gambling and the life of crime when he could no longer take dental patients due to his tuberculosis.

Sam1863

May 21st, 2018 at 8:20 AM ^

Absolutely. Costner's done some great movies (Bull Durham, Dances with Wolves) and some over-produced crap (Waterworld, The Postman). But this one's definitely on the plus side.

And between this and the Lonesome Dove series, Duvall established himself as one of the best western actors ever.

One of my favorite scenes is just before the gunfight, when they're crouched behind the wagon, eating chocolate bars and learning each other's real name. The classic moment of "calm before the storm."

BlueSpiceIn SEC.hell

May 20th, 2018 at 6:51 PM ^

Movies that get turned on pretty darn often. (AKA guilty pleasures) My Cousin Vinny, Hunt for Red October, 1st 45 minutes of Full Metal Jacket, last 20 minutes of a Few Good Men, Mr. Deeds, Little Nicky, Ratatouille(anyone can cook!), Secret Life of Walter Mitty Edge of Tomorrow Blazing Saddles Shawshank does too. Alltime: Godfather all 3 actually Casablanca It' a Wonderful Life Good Will Hunting

Sam1863

May 21st, 2018 at 2:07 PM ^

I enjoyed Tin Cup until a couple of years ago, when I read how much money Roy McAvoy left on the table by going for green repeatedly. Instead of finishing tied for second and earning over $204,000, he finished seven shots back and made over $33,000.

Yeah, I know - dramatic cinematic moment and all that. But it's a big plot hole. This is a guy who is so strapped for cash that he had to give his driving range to his stripper ex-girlfriend to pay off a loan. And nobody - Cheech Marin, Rene Russo, or any of his hangers-on - had the common sense to say "Hey Roy - what about the money?"

You'd think at least the stripper would have thought of it.

Ron Utah

May 20th, 2018 at 4:19 PM ^

My list:
1) The Godfather
2) Shawshank Redemption
3) The Godfather II
4) Pulp Fiction
I recognize the bias towards movies in my lifetime, but these are all amazing films. Another old favorite that I don’t enjoy as much anymore is The Usual Suspects.

Crash

May 21st, 2018 at 9:13 AM ^

Ohh thank you sir.  I was hoping someone else in this world didn't care for it like me.  I don't understand the love affair with Pulp Fiction.  Also, Fight Club.  Don't get it.

3 of my favorites are:

The Big Lebowski

Cinderella Man

Under Seige

Those aren't necessarily the 3 best movies ever made in my opinion, but they're 3 movies I wll watch all the way through if they are on TV.

Sam1863

May 22nd, 2018 at 11:00 AM ^

I'm the other way - I don't get the love affair that some people have with Lebowski. I've tried watching it, but I always end up thinking "What's the big deal with this?" (Same reaction I have to Fargo.) I'll have to try it again.

Love Cinderella Man except for one thing: Ron Howard's insistence on making Max Baer into a total dick. Yes, he was a loud, gregarious party boy. But being such a cold-hearted prick that he jokes to Mrs. Braddock about comforting her if her husband dies? Bullshit. Yes, Baer killed Frankie Campbell in the ring - but was by all accounts horrified by what had happened, and donated the purse from a subsequent fight to Campbell's widow and children. No way he'd have joked about it.

Also, since this was the time of the violent anti-Semitism going on in Hitler's Germany, Baer wore trunks with a Star of David on the leg in the Braddock fight. But Opie chose to omit that.

Unicycle Firefly

May 20th, 2018 at 4:20 PM ^

Saying this today might induce some eye rolls, but Titanic was an unbelievable experience and cultural phenomenon in the late 90’s. One of the first of the truly modern epic big screen movies in a time before epic was defined as “throwing a bunch of comic book super heroes on a screen together.” I’m not sure a movie has ever so completely dominated the public consciousness before or since. The Oscars were pretty much just a formality the year after it came out.