Endzone Discussion

Submitted by 2Blue4You on

I know excerpts have been posted here and discussed and it has been discussed in varying capacities over the past few months, but for those of us who received it for Christmas and are slow readers.

I just finished the book and found it infuriating at times, jaw dropping some of the stuff going on behind the scenes, and fascinating.  If anyone cares to discuss:

-The amount of seemingly excellent people that were forced out with the Firing Fridays.  People that worked tirelessly for Michigan and not for the paycheck, necessarily.  People who loved the University and loved what they did.  Seems like a wealth of knowledge, connections, and the like were forced to  move on or into early retirement.  

-With the department growing in size and salary under Brandon, does anyone know what checks and balances are happening now to reign that in?  I assume Hackett and Manuel aren't offing people either, but I could imagine salaries being stagnant for a while in the department and some openings not being replaced.  Some of the obvious high paid and Brandon manufactured positions have already been phased out.

-I definitely felt like the Michigan culture the past 5 years or so was a bit of a circle jerk of how great we were without much to back it up.  Reading the book and hearing about interactions and policies behind the scenes it put it into context for me.  I can imagine we were a pretty obnoxious fanbase to be around (at least locally for the Sparties).  At least today, I feel like we are on our way to backing it up.

-I'm sure Dave Brandon is not a bad person, but an arrogant and very out of touch person at times.  Sounded like he was trying to make amends, but it was already too late.  Not sure if he could ever turn around the damage he had made.  MGoBlog played a critical roll of getting Brandon to resign when he did, which was something that absolutely had to go our way for Harbaugh to fall into place.  I appreciated the Hagerup excerpts to humanize Brandon.  

-Does anyone have an explanation for Brandon resigning and still getting the buyout?  

-Harbaugh stuff was fascinating how that came together and how the groundwork was layed along the way.  The power of all parties working together and on a common goal was critical.  So many things had to go right and at critical times.  Unbelievable how different the feel is a year+ later. 

-Lastly, kudos to Hackett for landing the Unicorn. But how in the hell are you about to land the biggest fish and your computer is on the frizz, cell phone dead, no chargers, no internet on the flight? Glad that worked out, but I was nervous for him and I already know that Harbaugh is our coach!

Sorry for the length. Slow day, snow day. Discuss, or not. Go Blue!

Coach Carr Camp

February 24th, 2016 at 12:02 PM ^

I liked how JUB used Brandon's house as a metaphor for his approach. His house was a massive estate that was created with every aspect (down to the antique bowl he threw change in) done to Brandons exact preference. He thought it was perfect and others would be impressed. 

Michigan football though is the nice cabin on the lake in Northern Michigan. You don't go replacing the pontoon that fits 15 plus a keg with a $200K speedboat that fits 4. You don't replace the open fire pit with a fancy gas fire place that you can't throw your empties in. Its not perfect and it doesn't mean there are not things that need changes, but two houses are not the same.  

BoFan

February 24th, 2016 at 12:23 PM ^

I'm not a Brandon fan but to what extent is this just a hack job because Brandon took away all of JUBs perks. It's a valid question given how one sided it sounds.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

DetroitBlue

February 24th, 2016 at 12:37 PM ^

Actually, I was surprised by how fairly it seemed to treat Brandon. Lots of positive quotes from players, especially Hagerup, and some of the other trustees from when DB was a trustee.
The reason there's a lot more negativity than praise seems to be the fact that DB got a hell of a lot more wrong than right as AD



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

LSAClassOf2000

February 24th, 2016 at 12:30 PM ^

Lastly, kudos to Hackett for landing the Unicorn. But how in the hell are you about to land the biggest fish and your computer is on the frizz, cell phone dead, no chargers, no internet on the flight?

I believe that's where that rather handy but very truthful statement from Spaceballs comes into play: 

"OUT OF ORDER? FUCK! EVEN IN THE FUTURE NOTHING WORKS!"

Alton

February 24th, 2016 at 12:36 PM ^

My favorite part of the book is still the hiring (and salary negotiation) of Brady Hoke.

One of the things that Brandon happened to know about his idol, Bo Schembechler, was that Bo didn't even ask how much the job paid when he agreed to take the Michigan job back in 1969.  So Brandon got the brilliant idea when he offered Brady Hoke the job to ask Hoke not to ask what it paid.  Hoke readily agreed (seeing the trap that Brandon laid for himself, I like to think).

So Brandon announces that they are hiring Hoke, he announces that Hoke didn't even ask how much it paid (Just Like Bo!!) and Hoke's agent now has Brandon over a barrel:  either pay whatever salary they want, or have Brandon admit how badly he screwed up & rescind the job offer--the job offer that probably didn't even have a backup candidate.

Hoke is a few million dollars richer (and Michigan a few million poorer) now because Brandon didn't see how stupid he was being while trying to push this "Brady is Bo II" agenda.

JFW

February 24th, 2016 at 1:31 PM ^

Brandon didn't want to do it because it was true (Hoke hiring without asking $). He wanted to script it because he thought it looked good.

 

He's not an idiot. He had to have known it was going to cost him. But regardless, he went ahead with it because it was stage crafted to look 'Michigan authentic' and made him look good.

 

What BS. I found myself grinding my teeth at times with that book.

I don't dislike Brandon personally, but he represent a philosophy that has almost everything I detest about business nowadays.

 

Back in the early 80's when Chrysler hired Carrol Shelby, we were all suffering from the hangover of things like the Mustang II Cobra. Shelby came in and started to really try to bump up performance (for the day) with the little charger. One of his sayings was 'it ain't just paint'. Kind of a slam at the tarted up 'performance' cars of the late 70's with decals and wings but no guts.

 

Brandon was the just paint guy. 'Put an air dam on it, call it the 'GT' and we can charge another $2000 for it by banking on its names reputation!!!'

Arinix

February 24th, 2016 at 1:24 PM ^

What scared me was until the emails came out, Presidenr Schlissel was going to give Brandon until graduation in May 2015 to turn his job performance around. God knows what would've happened had he stayed on.

M and M Boys

February 24th, 2016 at 2:13 PM ^

It provided colorful back story drama for kids of all ages.

Many of us left Ann Arbor long ago and can't keep up on all the kaleidoscopic rat-tat-tat of the U of M Universe.  The book was helpful on connecting many dots.

Brandon just did not understand the physics of his assignment:

 Michigan Loyalty as an Adhesive:" he did not know how to relate to the molecular force that exists in the area of contact between unlike bodies and the acts that unite them:

Worse, he caused a student army to unite, rise up and instigate new life in Michigan football.

Big Bang--well done Mr. Hackett--and everyone who contributed to the combustion.