Your unpopular music opinions

Submitted by Monkey House on

Since the sports thread was really fun and interesting I thought a music one might be as well. There seems to be a wide age range on there so it should be pretty fun.

Larry Appleton

February 13th, 2015 at 10:27 PM ^

Springsteen's studio work is overrated, especially "Born To Run." Two of the best albums of the last half of the 90s were Days of the New's first two albums. Revolver is at best the 6th or 7th best Beatles album. "The Message" is the greatest rap song ever.

Michigan House '75

February 13th, 2015 at 10:57 PM ^

Don't get the love of the Doors so much.  Love Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young - "Suite Judy Eyes," especially. WOODSTOCK.  Of course Janice Joplin singing, "Me and Bobby McGee," there too.  Amazing memories. Thanks for this post. 

CJRockford

February 14th, 2015 at 1:16 AM ^

I've been kicking around this unique idea about putting together a new fight song for Michigan. Something like Eminem, Kid Rock, Madonna, Bob Seger, Jack White and Ted Nugent produced by Timberland and Missy Elliot. Thoughts?



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

eastbayblue

February 14th, 2015 at 1:47 AM ^

seriously who categorically dismisses any genre of music. I'm hip hop head but can get down with with good music, period. You rock with EDM or punk or indie rock? Cool. Let me share some Killer Mike or AZ or Termanology or Black Milk and we'll kick it.

laus102

February 14th, 2015 at 2:04 AM ^

Queen is the greatest rock band of all time, without any doubt in my mind.  

Beatles are great, but a bit overrated.  

Lou Reed / VU > Bob Dylan & most other bands / artists

Jack White fucking blows, along with the Black Keys.  Boring, trite, inconsequential bullshit

Troutmask Replica is a great album

I could list all the good bands on Domino Records on one hand, mostly just Ulrich Schnauss, John Cale, Four Tet, Jon Hopkins, and The Kills. 

Radiohead is fucking phenomenal, every album.  They get better with every album.  A matter of evolution, really.  

Guns N' Roses were absolutely great, even though Axl Rose is one bigotted, racist, piece of shit motherfucker.

One of the best rock bands of the early 21st century was Girls.  Like combining Beatles with Beach Boys, Lou Reed, Neil Young, and Procol Harum.  

Fugazi was probably the best punk band of all time, and their best album was either The Argument or Red Medicine.

laus102

February 14th, 2015 at 2:10 AM ^

one of the single handedly greatest and most profoundly american songs i've ever heard is "Ashes of American Flags" by Wilco.  Insanely perfect lyrically, and sonically, well...

Wilco is one of the all time American greats.  I'm not usually very patriotic or nationalistic (i'm a big Noam Chomsky reader), but Wilco makes me feel all fuzzy and proud inside.  

Louie C

February 14th, 2015 at 2:38 AM ^

Uptown Funk is a flaming piece of dog shit. It's some reject Morris Day and The Time/Was Not Was shit. And Daft Punk fell off for working with Pharrell's wack ass.

JayMo4

February 14th, 2015 at 9:14 AM ^

1.  Every musician that died before their time is overrated, even the ones that were genuinely great (you can be both!)

2.  Steven Wilson is one of the greatest songwriters in the history of rock, and too few people even know who he is.  It's very rare to find someone that can do melodic/catchy and progressive/technical and alternative/experimental all so well at the same time.  

3.  Dredg's El Cielo is the best album of the milennium.

4.  Extreme metal is one of the most intellectually rewarding genres of music to be explored.  Of course not everyone is going to enjoy it on a sonic level, but the stereotype of it being mindless noise could not be further from the truth.  While most other genres are suffering a severe bout of stagnation, metal just keeps expanding and evolving.

4b.  I am less frustrated by people that dismiss metal altogether than I am by people that claim to like metal and heavy music but don't seem to be familiar with anything outside of the mainstream.  They hear you like metal and immediately bring up Rob Zombie or some shit.  There's this whole internet thing out there, guys!  You have no idea what you're missing.

5.  Some of the most beautiful songs I've heard have come out of the bluegrass/folk/Americana genre, and it's a real bummer everyone gets caught up in the "I hate country" mindset to listen.  I hate radio country too.  But this is nothing like that.

6.  Everyone is allowed guilty pleasures.  As an 80's kid, I will always have a soft spot for those cheesy power ballads.  I will unashamedly howl along"I wanna know what love is!" every time that song is playing.

7.  Soundgarden's Badmotorfinger was the best grunge album of all, and this is coming from someone that thinks Jar of Flies is a gift from heaven and listened to Ten until the cd melted.

8.  Led Zeppelin deserves every ounce of praise and every ounce of criticism.  It's all warranted.  Both sides are correct.  They're the musical equivalent of a person that steals money to pay for medicine to save someone's life.  Rock doesn't exist in its present form without LZ doing what they did.  They may be theives, but some crimes are noble.

9.  The Moody Blues in their prime were everything that The Beatles or Pink Floyd were:  Creative, progressive, evocative, redefining.  I don't care that they had less mainstream success or started playing 80's synth pop later in their career followed by watered down soft rock after that.  Days of Future Passed was groundbreaking, and each of the next six albums were tremendous as well.

10.  Chuck Schuldiner is God.  I don't care what I said in my first point.

11.  *Controversial opinion of the day*  Sometimes, there is a lot to be said just for accomplishing exactly what you set out to do.  Judging solely on that critierion, Call Me Maybe is one of the greatest songs ever.  Look, it's not for our demographic.  It's for teenage girls using their parents' credit card to download iTunes songs that they'll listen to over and over for a month and then never again.  But it's a fun song, it's catchy, it got people talking, what more do you want?  For what it is, for what it was trying to be, there aren't too many songs that hit the bullseye better.  *Disclaimer*  It could just be that I thought it was really cute to watch my daughter dance to it on the playstation, but still...

Fencerdude

February 14th, 2015 at 3:19 PM ^

In response to 4b - I think it's ok to use the mainstream to get hooked onto the genre like I did, but yes, absolutely you have to go out and explore.  If I never explored past Disturbed and Tool I wouldn't have found Pelican, Isis, Crowbar, Mastodon (even though they are kinda mainstream these days), Baroness, Fozzy, or The Sword. And that would tragic.

 

Larry Appleton

February 14th, 2015 at 9:23 AM ^

Charlie Patton, Son House, and Skip James are all better than Robert Johnson. The Notorious BIG wasn't good at all. Plus he sold crack so screw him. U2's Pop wasn't a bad album. Limp Bizkit's first album was pretty damn good. Until "How You Remind Me" came out, it was OK to be a Nickelback fan. "Loser" by 3 Doors Down was and is a kickass rock song, "Mean" by Taylor Swift is a great song.

MoJo Rising

February 14th, 2015 at 11:10 AM ^

Mats fan since 85 when I heard "FUCK SCHOOL" and fell in love with "Kids Don't Follow" from the STINK album. What a magical band with the greatest collection of anthem songs there are.

West German Judge

February 14th, 2015 at 11:53 AM ^

I will legitimately pull a Costanza and not date a girl if she has "poor" taste in music.  I was talking to this girl at work and had been texting back and forth for a couple weeks...until she told me the best concert she ever attended was Imagine Dragons and she loved them before they were cool!!!11!

No.

Imagine Dragons sucks.
They were never cool.
This girl is now Radioactive, as far as I'm concerned.

Mr. Yost

February 15th, 2015 at 11:53 PM ^

2 outta 3 if she puts out.

Kidding!

If she's got awful taste in music, I don't need to have the same taste in music, I just need her to respect my taste and not play her horrid shit around me.

Music is personal for me, I wouldn't share it with a girlfriend anyway. At least not on a level that requires them to like/understand what I'm into.

Sports on the other hand...she needs to like/understand sports. Simply because that is both private and non-private. If she doesn't like sports we're probably not going to see each other or talk much, which could be an issue.