You're right. It is my opinion. This whole thread is one big opinion. There is no clear #1 QB in the conference, which is why we are having this conversation. I just respectfully disagree with your assessment.
I think your last paragraph pretty much sums up my point. I think that the player most responsible for not having the #1 scoring offense in the Big Ten when you are by far the best offense by yardage cannot possibly be a first team Big Ten player.
If you want numbers, Denard robinson averages 8.2 yards by touching the ball and he scores a TD 6.5% of the time he touches the ball. Stanzi averages 7.7 yards when touching the ball and he scores a TD 6.7% of the time he touches the ball. TD:TO ratio? 30:12 and 25:4. How many games has Stanzi thrown multiple interceptions? None. How many has Denard? Three.
The difference between the two? Denard has touched the ball about 100 more times than Stanzi has on the season and Stanzi's doesn't have a consistent drop in production against teams with 7 wins or greater right now.