OT: What's your favorite baseball card?

Submitted by Hensons Mobile… on April 16th, 2020 at 1:09 PM

What is your favorite baseball card in your collection?

I suppose if you want to talk about football or basketball cards or something you can. Baseball cards are the only ones that count, though. Everybody knows this.

Here's my #1:

Commie_High96

April 16th, 2020 at 1:13 PM ^

Ricky Henderson Topps rookie card.  He was my favorite player, for his combo of speed and power, his determination and longevity and the hilarious stories (eg john olerud)

Lou MacAdoo

April 16th, 2020 at 1:24 PM ^

Probably my Ken Griffey Jr. rookie card. Although when we were kids my brother and I would play this baseball game with a deck of cards. We would choose a team from our baseball cards and they were a mix of cool names and favorite players. I was always fond of the Oil Can Boyd card I owned. I know I liked to have Mickey Tettleton, Rob Deer, and Pete Incaviglia on my squad. I wish I could remember some more, but I'm too old and haven't looked at them in years. 

Eat Your Wheatlies

April 16th, 2020 at 1:36 PM ^

Mine is definitely my Ken Griffey Jr. Upper Deck graded rookie card. 

Man, I sure wish card collecting was as fun/affordable for kids these days like it was for me. I doubt my infant son will ever get into because of how much the industry has changed over the last 10-15 years.

UMfan21

April 16th, 2020 at 1:56 PM ^

And then Stadium Club the next year.  I think they were like $4 a pack and you couldn't find them ANYWHERE.  My friend's dad worked at a pharmacy and would buy a box when they were in stock.  My friend and I would save up our allowance to buy the packs from him.   I had about 90% of the complete set.   A few years ago I looked to see what it was worth and if I should buy the remaining cards I needed.  The whole set was like $30 (I had probably spend hundreds back in 1990)

BLUEinRockford

April 16th, 2020 at 1:52 PM ^

My niece's T-ball card. Only year she played. She was missing a front tooth, so my brother and I nicknamed her Probert that summer. Around 1986-87.

Do kids still get their own card anymore?

Sam1863

April 16th, 2020 at 2:17 PM ^

This 1969 card of Aurelio Rodriguez, then with the California Angels. It's actually a photo of the Angels bat boy, Leonard Garcia, and is famous in baseball-card-collecting circles.

I actually had it, in a dog-eared stack of other cards in a dresser drawer. After I moved out, it got thrown away in one of my mother's spring cleaning tirades. I don't want to know what it would be worth today.

Zoltanrules

April 16th, 2020 at 3:00 PM ^

1955 Hank Aaron...but not the late Don Mossi.

The entire 1969 tall boy set of the NBA cards are my favorite cards of any sport. The story behind them is very interesting. Pretty much all oversized rookie cards with no front of the jersey, if they wore the jersey.

https://www.sportscollectorsdaily.com/1969-70-topps-basketball-set-info-checklist/

 

Don Mossi's Baseball Card

I collected all four major sports cards and probably had all my fillings due to the sugar coated gum that was hard as a rock.

 

Seth

April 16th, 2020 at 3:12 PM ^

I've got that Abbott. I pulled a Topps Gold Nolan Ryan the first year they had that. My first-ever baseball card was a 1988 Tom Glavine. I thought his 5.35 ERA was a batting average so I held onto it when someone wanted to trade me a Harold Baines. 

tspoon

April 16th, 2020 at 3:56 PM ^

Definitely have an unknown quantity of that Abbott downstairs in the basement.  My wife wondered if I wanted to sell the boxes and boxes of cards at some point -- I laughed, and explained to her that the local card store here in Charlotte has told me that they wouldn't even take the core of my collection ('86-early 90s, mostly Topps) for free.

Favorites:

1) my Dad's '55 Ted Williams, even though it's in terrible shape

2) my Jose Canseco '86 Donruss rookies ... because they were the bee's knees when they had their moment in the sun. And if there's any player -- and card of that player -- that typifies that whole era, to me that is the one.  The ultimate fall from awesome to nothing.

3) related long story (and ties #1 and #2 together): I went to a card show in the summer of '87 and my little brother had a friend whose dad had bought a table at the show.  He wasn't a card dealer, but he had enough cards that he thought it worthwhile.  I was going to the show anyway, and gave him like $5 to have a small part of his table. So I set out my stuff, and among the items I had was a box of commons from my dad's cards in the attic.  All dog-eared, really beat up.  I had already found and pulled the Williams, a '54 (IIRC) Roy Campanella, a few other stars.  Threw the rest in a box and let people pick through them for a buck a piece.  So the guy who has the table I'm at takes a moment to paw through my stuff, including the box of oldies.  He finds one he's interested in and asks if he can have it for a dollar.  I say sure, and then he proceeds to prance around proclaiming victory because it's a '53 Eddie Matthews, and I had (at the time) never even heard of that guy (HOFer).  Beckett said it was worth maybe $35 (and it was pretty beat up), but he's laughing at me in a way that brings to mind Harry and Lloyd in the hot pepper scene of Dumb and Dumber. Just being a jackass about it. So once he's done preening, I start back at him ... nice job, taking advantage of a kid. A kid who's supposedly a family friend, etc etc.  Eventually I guilt him into giving me one (just one) pack of the super-special '87 Fleer box of unopened wax packs he had just triumphantly bought.  Well ... a few moments later, guess who got the ONLY Barry Bonds rookie out of that whole box.  Yup, sweet justice.

And now that Bonds card is (fittingly) worth approximately jack squat.

 

BahamaMama

April 16th, 2020 at 4:00 PM ^

I had an Ernie Banks rookie card from my uncle. That got glued to a scrapbook page. My son has it now but it's obviously not in mint condition. What was I thinking? 

Boner Stabone

April 16th, 2020 at 4:38 PM ^

My favorite site to go to was Joesportsfan.com and they would have made up funny stories about the pictures on baseball cards.  They were absolutely hilarious.  Sadly, the site is gone and I cannot find it anywhere.  I was trying to find it a couple of weeks ago and had no luck.

Michifornia

April 16th, 2020 at 5:12 PM ^

I grew up and LOVED collecting cards in grade school back in the 70s and ate every stick of gum.  Had hundreds of baseball and football cards.  When I was an undergrad at U of M, my parents moved and they threw away my drawer full of cards...Le sigh...

oldblue

April 16th, 2020 at 6:50 PM ^

"Tiger Big Bats" Kaline and Kuenn. From around 1960 or so. I'd show it here if my mother hadn't thrown it out with my Lionel Train and the rest of my stuff.

truferblue22

April 17th, 2020 at 3:14 PM ^

I never liked baseball. But I did have a pretty sweet hockey card collection. 

 

My best card was an Upper Deck Sergei Fedorov card that at one point was worth about $50, which was a SHIT TON of money to me back then.