Spring Stuff: Offense Comment Count

Brian

WELP. In a word, Michigan's offense was ominous. It was ominous—worse than that—in Hoke's first year, though, and that worked out okay as long as Al Borges wasn't trying to make Denard Robinson into a pocket passer. Standard disclaimer about information value of spring.

That stated, yeesh. We knew the situation at tackle was going to be iffy, especially with Magnuson out. Having Mason Cole as the first option at the most important spot on the line was beyond those expectations. Meanwhile, Michigan is prepping the only remaining guy who started every game last year (Graham Glasgow) at right tackle, which they'll say is just precautionary but speaks of some trepidation about Ben Braden. I do not want there to be trepidation about Ben Braden.

Hoke did not mince words when asked if they thought they'd found their best five:

"I don't know if we can say that, honestly," Hoke said. "I know I can't.

"So, I guess the answer is no."

Are the Wolverines even close, really, to identifying the best five?

"No," Hoke said. "Not yet."

That was apparent on the field, where runs generally got to the line of scrimmage (hooray!) and no further (mutter). Pass protection was close to nonexistent. It was what everyone expected, which was bad. They've got five months to figure it out, whereupon they probably won't figure it out. Digging out of a hole as big as Michigan dug last year is a two-year operation.

13655101344_d90b6f4f0e_z
Nussmeier and new protégé [Bryan Fuller]

Quarterbacking. Gardner was just two of ten, but Morris was hardly better. Gardner's interception was at least at his receiver; Morris threw one directly into Lewis's chest. In the aftermath there were the usual quotes about how it's an open competition, but, yeah, when the Big Ten Network's main Morris highlight is a pass thrown behind the line of scrimmage that guy isn't displacing a quarterback who averaged 8.6 YPA last year and can run.

Neither quarterback was helped by the pass protection, which forced them to move around and let Michigan's secondary recover. Gardner's move and re-set on one throw allowed Jarrod Wilson to get over to Canteen on a corner route, for example. We have a ton of Gardner data from a year and a half as the starting quarterback. One spring outing isn't going to move the needle.

Speight didn't do much; Bellomy didn't look better than he did against Nebraska.

13651411044_85a1211257_z

Hayes should be a legit option. [Fuller]

Tailbacking. On the few runs on which tailbacks had an opportunity to do something notable it was usually Justice Hayes doing the notable thing. He had a couple of quality cuts in tight areas that got him a nice chunk. Derrick Green had one bounce outside on which he seemed quicker than last year but still not particularly quick; De'Veon Smith also turned in a leg-churning run.

They're all about even, it seems. Michigan will cycle through them looking for one to break out. That's a tough ask given the line. It's platoon time. Michigan still seems to insist that anyone who does not resemble a moose must be relegated to third downs:

"Right now, if we're not in a third down situation, it's De'Veon and Derrick. And then Justice if we get into third down."

There's no reason that Hayes shouldn't be given a look as the feature back after last year's lack of production all around and his evident ability. He was no slouch as a recruit, and being able to pick through traffic is a nice skill to have. You get the impression that Hoke would ride David Underwood for years before even considering Mike Hart. Size isn't everything. Ask the Kansas State team that just eviscerated you with a 5'8" tailback and 5'11" wide receiver.

It's also time for Fred Jackson to preach the simplicity line and throw shade on Al Borges:

"Guys are more consistent now with their reads, going from point A to point B with protections," Michigan running backs coach Fred Jackson said last week on WTKA-AM in Ann Arbor. "By not having a ton of protections and a ton of different runs, it allows the guys to be more consistent in what they're doing."

/waves tiny flag

Of course, the main problem with the blitz pickups last year was not so much the tailback going to the wrong spot but what happened when he met the blitzer. That's on Jackson, not Borges. The thing about not doing every possible thing is great—I've heard that Michigan had 13 different protection schemes last year. 13!

13651032853_b3044cec51_z

MOS EISLEY FTW [Eric Upchurch]

Something about a wretched hive of scum and villainy I can't quite figure out. Freddy Canteen went from freshman to Manningham in the space of 15 practices, starting the day opposite Devin Funchess, making the one deep catch of the scrimmage session, and smoking Blake Countess over the top on another pass that Gardner threw short. Countess caught up; it was still reminiscent of 86.

13651064535_3383b8446d_z

Almost. [Upchurch]

Also reminiscent of 86, at least as a freshman: people screaming at Canteen about where to line up pre-snap. There was one memorable play in Manningham's freshman year where Fred Jackson was having a conniption fit on the sideline trying to get Manningham to relocate himself; Manningham did not and scored a touchdown anyway. Canteen dredged that memory up on Saturday.

Spring depth etc., but passing Jehu Chesson after a promising freshman year from him is a real thing. The tea leaves here suggest Canteen is the real deal—Michigan does not need a WR savior and has a veritable avalanche of bodies they can put on the outside. Canteen rocketed past last year's WR class and Chesson in 15 practices. It would be easy for Michigan to talk him up and throw him in the slot; instead they appear to be prepping him for a major role on the outside.

"I've been at slot and outside receiver, (I'm comfortable) at both, but I'll play probably more outside," Canteen said. "(I want to be a playmaker), to be honest. I just want to make plays."

Darboh and Chesson will also figure in; with Funchess that gives Michigan four guys with production or hype or both to their name. They're suddenly flush. With York and Dukes—who made a nice diving catch—also available, it seems like Drake Harris and Moe Ways should redshirt.

Let's think about the guy like a football player instead of a traveling circus. I can only assume the light deployment of Dennis Norfleet was for cackling-about-your-mad-plan-in-your-underground-lair reasons. It was encouraging to see them throw an actual route his way, a wheel on which Jourdan Lewis took an unnecessary pass interference flag on an overthrown ball. I support the integration of Dennis Norfleet into the base offense instead of having a completely separate Norfleet offense that always results in him getting the ball going laterally.

Hooray for efficiency. One of the most disconcerting things about Michigan's spring activity is how much standing around there is. For many, they're setting a countable hour on fire. This is apparently not how it works behind closed doors:

"Practices are really fast, we get a lot of reps," Gardner said. "This was probably the fastest practice I've ever been a part of."

There's been plenty of talk about the overall pace Nussmeier -- Michigan's first-year offensive coordinator -- works with in practice, and the overall level of tempo he chooses to play with during games.

Practices are quick. When a play ends, the next group -- according to players -- is expected to be out of the huddle and ready to snap the ball for the next rep. That concept is a simple one: It creates more reps, and for a young team, the more reps the better.

For any team, really. And that should serve Michigan well when they want to change the tempo, something Borges teams were mind-bendingly awful at. Here's a manna from heaven quote:

"I think the biggest thing, you always want to be able to control the tempo on offense -- whether that's to speed the game up or slow the game down," Nussmeier said during an interview with WTKA-AM 1050 in Ann Arbor on Thursday. "We practice at a fast tempo for a lot of reasons. One, it forces our guys to play fast and focus and always concentrate.

"And it also allows us to pick the tempo of the game up (if we need to)."

Hallelujah.

Random Mone quote I missed yesterday. This is an epic nonquote.

"I'm just having fun, being blessed," he said. "Just having fun playing the game is what I think my teammates have noticed. My enthusiasm is the main thing I bring to the field."

Our THREE weapons are having fun, being blessed, and having enthusiasm!

Complaining Section

yankeestad-9[1]

WE MUST MAN THE BARRICADES OR OUR FATE IS SEALED

The experience of being at the spring game was not a pleasant one. Brandon further pushed the limits of his promise not to put advertising in Michigan Stadium (a promise he's already broken in a dozen different ways) with large videoboard ads for Comcast and Allstate. There was also some dude kicking a field goal sponsored by PNC. Dude is just itching to turn Michigan's gameday experience into OSU or MSU where the scoreboard looks like a NASCAR driver's jumpsuit and each play is brought to you by Depends Adult Undergarments.

More maddening was the constant—and I mean constant—wedding DJ music, which only dropped out for brief periods in which the band was suffered to play. By the end of the day it appeared like the band just said "screw it, we're playing" and went about fifteen minutes straight. This was a merciful relief.

The music combined with the punting drill section of the day was typical Michigan at this point: we'll be shitty to you, fans, but here is this awesome guitar riff! Hunter Lochmann apparently believes that any deficit can be obscured by music. If things go poorly this season expect them to try two songs at once for the entirety of the Penn State game. One of them will be Phil Collins, because that's the soul of football.

The contrast between the NCAA tournament regional the week before and the spring game could not have been greater. The tournament is a great event the NCAA gets out of the way of. Michigan has a crappy event they try to dress up. Hoke's disregard for the fanbase hurts their ability to make it a non-crappy event, of course. Michigan remain focused on one thing and one thing only: strip-mining revenue from the banks of fan loyalty like it is an infinite resource.

Any things they do that are actually fan-friendly, like bringing in a slightly less rank standard of nonconference opponent, are because they have reached the limit of their ability to strip-mine. Michigan reminded fans in attendance to renew their season tickets—an announcement that never needed to be made before.

It would be one thing if the people making these decisions did anything but ape whoever their counterparts are in the ECHL. They have no concept of forming an identity to rally around. They just have spreadsheets.

Comments

skurnie

April 8th, 2014 at 3:53 PM ^

I asked this on an earlier thread...is the music normal? This was my first in-person Spring game and I couldn't believe they just played music for the first hour and fifteen minutes. They also didn't bleep out the N word during a Jay Z song, which, uh, I found weird.

I took my three year old daughter and she slept through the first 45 minutes so the music didn't bother her but it annoyed me. 

aplatypus

April 8th, 2014 at 4:36 PM ^

lots of colleges do it in practices and players like it because it helps pump them up and stuff like that. But it's the worst idea ever at Michigan because Michigan is Michigan. 

It's a lot like "uniformz" that around the nation are usually universally loved by players and it's a big deal to get new or special ones. But to Michigan fans they are largely an abomination, even if they look halfway decent or the players like them. 

Same goes for ads at the stadium, if Brandon put in advertising and used it to directly reduce ticket prices, people here would still complain because it's Michigan fergodsakes. 

Profwoot

April 8th, 2014 at 3:53 PM ^

Contrary to Brian's statement that LT is the most important spot on the line, it seems to me that C is the clear leader in that regard. LT is a big deal in the NFL where it's assumed all 5 are competent. In college, the guy making the line calls and who is always play-side seems more important to me than a guy just down-blocking half the time. Even the guards seem more important to me, born out by the various number-crunching from last season where guard experience was more highly correlated with success.

I remain dumbfounded at Brian's obsession with Norfleet. I still haven't seen anything from him.

Pit2047

April 8th, 2014 at 7:38 PM ^

Is that you see him do AMAZING things in the return game but he has never been used that way in the regular offense.  Borges never really attempted to on game day expect to throw him in the game and run a jet sweep, which is a criminal under utilization of his skills.  Imagine never putting Peppers on offense or special teams and then imagine your anger, that is how Brian feels.  One of the biggest critics of Borges was he apparently didn't know what a slot receiver was.

Don

April 8th, 2014 at 10:21 PM ^

Norfleet? When? If he was doing AMAZING things on kickoff returns, I think his longest return wouldn't be 44 yards. If he was doing AMAZING things, he'd have a TD.

I'll grant that he's been consistent in getting 20-25 yds per return, but consistent isn't the same thing as AMAZING.

maize-blue

April 9th, 2014 at 9:33 AM ^

I've always thought that maybe the coaches think Norfleet is a ball security liability in the normal offense. But at the same time he is returning kicks and punts, so I don't really know.

bronxblue

April 8th, 2014 at 4:15 PM ^

I know a couple of people will hate this for whatever reason, but here's my take on the whole "fan experience" vs. "money" argument we've seen with Michigan and its fans, as told with an analogy.

This past week Wrestlemania XXX featured two matches with Daniel Bryan, an "internet darling" who was always thought of as too small, too vanilla to compete for a championship despite being one of the best professional wrestlers in the world.  The WWE didn't get behind him because, at least early on, it didn't seem like he could sell tickets or move merchandise like guys who have the "look" of a Rock, a John Cena, a Randy Orton.  So even though he had a large following of hardcore wrestling fans and was extremely proficient in the ring, they dicked him around and didn't do much to promote his character.  The nadir saw him losing his world title in 18 seconds to a red-haired Irishman to open Wrestlemania 28.

Well, the next day the fans at Raw just kept chanting his name, telling the powers-that-be at the WWE they were sick of seeing this extremely talented wrestler get pushed around and ignored for the sake of promoting guys who look good on t-shirts.  And though there have been bumps along the way, Bryan not only beat the kayfabe COO/real-world future leader of the WWE AND won the world heavyweight title over two guys who "look the part."  

Now, the WWE doesn't like to be told what to do.  It treats the hardcore fans like addicts; they are going to keep coming back regardless, so there is no need to attend to their needs or play much attention to their whims.  So what did these fans do?  They made it so crystal clear that they were unhappy with the current product and wanted to see change by chanting during matches, filing up message boards, buying the Bryan merchandise, and generally annoying the right people.  Now, I know the cynic in me says that the WWE doesn't care who is at the top provided they make money, but it was also clear that left to their own devices, Bryan would have languished in the mid-card for his whole career.  But the fans made it clear they weren't going to stand for it, so it changed.

****

How does this apply to UM?  I'm not calling for a massive fan boycott because (a) whenever people try they always seem disjointed and unsuccessful, and (b) you are only going to "hurt", if you will, the kids who play the game, because Hoke and Brandon certainly don't care if a bunch of people come and watch the practices or not.  Instead, fans should contact the AD's office and complain, loudly, that they thought the event was crap and Fort Schembechler needs to be left in the 70's and 80's along with the Pet Rock and Glam Bands.  People have so many avenues for entertainment, so many ways of consuming information, that if you make it hard to enjoy something they'll just stop paying attention.  And maybe that message is already being heard, as noted by Brian hearing a call to renew season memberships.  If there were 15k at this year's practice I'd be amazed based on the photos I saw, but next year maybe on 5k show up.  Really drive home the point that fans aren't going to consume your overpriced water and food, pay your parking fees, and basically patron your product until it is more desirable and conducive to what the consumer wants.  And as has been the shift recently, more and more people are going to be watching from home, and TV rights aren't necessarily going to make up this drop in gate revenue, at least not initially.  That doesn't mean fans should be able to call plays or turn the event into a 3-ring circus, but when OSU and Alabama are kicking your butt both on and off the field, something needs to change.  Maybe Brandon won't care, but at least make him have to listen for a while.

AlwaysBlue

April 8th, 2014 at 8:43 PM ^

the thing that matters most is "win the game(s)." This incessant back and forth to do one thing because this isn't the 70s anymore and don't do this other thing because this is Michigan and we don't progress that way, is restlessness with a stalled program. At one moment the AD is a money grubbing soulless capitalist and at the next he's a damn fool for failing to engineer an event that puts 50,000+ at spring practice. I personally don't care about anything but "win the game(s)." When you win a good deal of this stuff that's driving people nuts become objects of affection.

aplatypus

April 8th, 2014 at 4:40 PM ^

I have never seen a player get so much hype for almost breaking a few 26 yard kick returns into 40 yard returns and getting tackled by random blades of grass drifting with the wind. 

I know it's part of football, but Norfleet has done nothing of note to warrant the attention he gets on here. Freddy Canteen is already 5x the slot receiver Norfleet is, and I'm willing to bet Peppers is a superior kick returner as well. 

gbdub

April 8th, 2014 at 5:03 PM ^

At this point I'm reasonably convinced Brian talks up Norfleet at least in part to provoke a response. He is trolling.

Plus 1) Brian loved Norfleet before we recruited him, and the fact that he finally got an offer was probably validating. 2) the sort of things Norfleet is / should be good at are the things Borges de emphasized for no apparent benefit (e.g. Bubble screens). Even the coaches seem to recognize some potential - they did build a "package" for him, after all, even though it was so predictable as to be mostly doomed.

Wheatley

April 8th, 2014 at 5:11 PM ^

"Michigan reminded fans in attendance to renew their season tickets—an announcement that never needed to be made before." Brian you complete me... :'o)

victorsvaliant01

April 8th, 2014 at 5:52 PM ^

Reason I'm renewing mine are because the seats have been in my family since the 70's, and because I'm sentimental about the experiences I had in them growing up. That joy in Michigan Stadium seems like it was two lifetimes ago--I'm 31.

Don

April 8th, 2014 at 6:40 PM ^

over why Norfleet continues to be regarded by some as the reincarnation of Steve Breaston combined with Derrick Alexander when it comes to kick returning.

pfholland

April 8th, 2014 at 8:31 PM ^

Sitting here reading this column and these comments I realize that for the first time in my life I feel like throwing in the towel on Michigan football. The combination of an inept on field product and Dave Brandon's apparent insistence on turning the game day experience into a generic pro sports experience has me feeling hollow. I never thought that this could happen.

What really concerns me is another thought I had. If the university leadership can allow the football program to be run this poorly why should I trust that they'll properly run the academic side of the university? And if I'm having thoughts like that why would I continue to donate to the university?

Maybe I'm just having a bad day.

gwkrlghl

April 8th, 2014 at 8:36 PM ^

I'm convinced the O-line will be worse this year until proven otherwise.

I still think that (2013 OL) - (2 NFL linemen) = Bad...very bad

I mean, if you try to step back and look at this objectively, the offense looks great except that the O-line is going to be an absolute disaster. We have elite players everywhere on offense except on the line

Soulfire21

April 8th, 2014 at 9:33 PM ^

The offensive line stuff really bothers me.  Shouldn't we at least be able to look servicable given superior talent relative to almost everyone in the Big Ten, or is our coaching that bad?  Or is it a coincidence that a slew of 4 and 5 star O-linemen collectively aren't as good as the recruiting services had pegged them?

I don't know man.