Sooner please. [Patrick Barron]

Neck Sharpies: Go Go Linebacker Go Comment Count

Seth September 30th, 2022 at 8:37 AM

In yesterday's defensive UFR I noted the hesitant LBs were a disappointing development. I wanted to get into why I put it on them, and how I thought they changed things up later on to put the onus on the DTs.

We're starting with two plays in a row on Maryland's first drive that could have been emphatic stuffs (or more) versus Inside Zone. We're on the snap after Michigan was going to get off the field but for Jaylen Harrell getting a piece of Tagovailoa's facemask. It's tremendous bad luck, that (a difference of 3.41 expected points), and the defense could really use an emphatic win on the next down. Instead we get this:

It's just five yards on a first down RPO, but might have been so much more.

[After THE JUMP: GO!]

 

Off the snap Maryland is double-teaming the backside DT, Mason Graham, while reading the frontside LB, Mike Barrett, for an RPO slant behind him or a TE in the flat outside of him. Barrett stays back, and for the moment Maryland has a hat for every defender engaging with the run. Two of those guys, however, are on Graham, who's giving up a yard to keep the center attached to him. That leaves Junior Colson free to fly down as soon the ball's in the RB's hands.

image_thumb[1]

The issue here was Colson didn't take it. One beat later the RB is gaining momentum, Graham is starting to lose the engagement of the center, and Colson still hasn't moved.

image

Go!

image_thumb[3]

GO!!!!!!!

image_thumb[4]

Too late. Graham's been "scooped" and the center can release to the linebacker. Note Colson's only moved up one yard from where he started. In a game of inches, setting up your line of defense here is surrendering at least everything in front of you. In the clip above you can see #99 Cam Goode has actually fought his way across the blocker to initiate the tackle. Graham, now freed of the double, is also fighting to close the window. Colson, the guy this was run at, is getting pinched out of the play.

Now watch it again, just looking at the Graham and Colson, and imagine what happens if Colson had fired down faster.

Graham is top DT just above the hash. Colson is the LB behind him.

It's a doubly missed opportunity because the Maryland RB, Roman Hemby, bobbled the handoff. If Hemby met an aggressive linebacker a yard in the backfield, that ball could have popped anywhere, most likely into the hands of a defender facing it. Instead Colson just…watched it.

Contrast his behavior with that of Rod Moore, #19, who's playing nickel on the top hash. Moore hangs out where he needs to be to take away a slant just as long as he has to then scoots forward to take away a much larger gap than the one Colson's responsible for. (Why do I keep clipping safeties doing linebacker things better than the linebackers?)

While this behavior was new from Colson, it's been a persistent thing from Barrett. He did it on the very next play:

#23 the bottom linebacker

This time Michigan's defensive playcall won single blocks across the play, wasting a pair of OL on the backside. Maryland really wanted to hit this flare screen to the F but didn't expect to get Sainristil leaving the backside edge to pursue it, giving Michigan numbers to the field. The backup plan was to get McGregor crashing on the dive and either hit the Y curl or have Tagovailoa run it out himself with the left side of the line in front of him, but McGregor sensed he was the edge defender and formed up to force a handoff.

This is a Rock, Paper, Scissors victory for Jesse Minter. Maryland planned a bunch of options for the defense to bite on and they had them all covered by an alignment that it initially looked pretty good against if you're planning for Sainristil to be blitzing off this edge.

image

All that's left now is to pay it off. Graham has the center single-blocking him and is controlling both sides of the center at the line of scrimmage. He's done his job. Upshaw and Goode are in their gaps as well. The running back has only one lane and still has to shift his momentum downfield to get to it as soon as his quarterback gets his arm out of the basket. This Barrett's moment to take the free lane.

image

 

Take it!

image

Go!

image_thumb[10]

Too late.

image_thumb[9]

Upshaw and Goode managed to fight across their blockers to end this, but they're both engaged with OL so this falls forward for 2 yards. Barrett ends up falling down outside of the pile.

Here's Kalel Mullings taking a shot at it. He's the LB on the top, behind Mazi Smith. At first I was going to put this on Smith for getting scooped but as I tried to break down what the line was doing I saw it differently. The defensive line is slanting to the frontside (top) which should get the linebackers hopping backside. Mullings hops with Smith, so when the C comes off the double he's got the linebacker lined up.

This is not exactly responsible behavior from the defense, since Smith would have to take both sides of that block for this to work. But the gamble pays off—the center is following Smith instead of popping off. An aggressive linebacker could take advantage of that. Mullings instead remains behind his DT.

image

He does take on the center, but head on. You're the smaller and faster player, not some thick neck-roller on Bullough juice. The way to make that work is to scamper into the gap.

image

imageimage

The linebackers got –1s for these events, not big –2s or angry –3s. But this stuff adds up. More importantly, it's wasting good playcalls, gambles, and plays by the other guys that could have paid off.

Last year I kept talking about how Michigan was putting Ross through "Linebacker Hell" by giving him tough reads while the DTs concentrated on single blocks. One of the reasons I tried to be easy on him was he took these opportunities when they were presented. This year Michigan is able to put more on the defensive tackles, which should be paying off in more aggressive play from the linebackers. Somebody just forgot to tell the linebackers.

Comments

GoBlue96

September 30th, 2022 at 8:46 AM ^

Love seeing this in detail.  You know Iowa is going to be challenging these LBs.  Hopefully we see a lot of improvement plus the help of not having to worry about a mobile QB and possibly our starter seeing the field.

AC1997

September 30th, 2022 at 9:13 AM ^

Seth - I'm fairly ignorant about the nuances of LB play and thus I appreciate these breakdowns.  I never thought I'd get this much attention for a few <5-yard runs up the middle.  

With that being said, are you sure the LB weren't coaches to "slow-play" the mesh point and not attack until MD makes their decision to give/pull?  Perhaps we were worried about RPOs and were more content to play conservative with short runs rather than big passes?  

I'm just curious since the RPO can be death to LB and you are asking them to attack aggressively and I wonder if that sets them up for being burned over the top.  Maybe MD was doing that in previous games?  

michengin87

September 30th, 2022 at 9:27 AM ^

I think you may be right.  I'm not so sure that Seth is correct that someone forgot to tell the LBs.  I think it is more likely that our staff doesn't trust the LBs to get more aggressive and then potentially be totally out of position.  I could see our staff making the decision with this group that it is better to hold a play to 4-5 yards as they learn rather than give up big first downs.

kejamder

September 30th, 2022 at 9:34 AM ^

But then the rest of the defensive playcall doesn't really make sense, does it? If you design the line scheme to keep LBs clean for run fits, why would you then tell them not to make run fits?

It also doesn't make sense to me in general. By playing for 4-5 yards, you actually open yourself up to big gains if the OL is able to release to the LB level and really open up holes. 

I think we're violating occam's razor by suggesting this is deliberate. I think it's much more likely that young LBs are still unsure that they're looking at the right gap, hesitant to make a mistake, and therefore waiting. It was frustrating to watch in real-time (without being able to diagnose it like this) because MD had a lot of sustained drives, but it seems like the defense could be close to stopping that if they can clean this up.

Seth

September 30th, 2022 at 9:58 AM ^

Michigan is in Quarters looks for most of these. The LBs can still drop in coverage if they see high hat. None of those I called out are being read by the RPOs, and you can actually see the behavior of other defenders who are being read by the RPOs. Once the ball is in the RB's hands, you want to see the LBs attacking. There are multiple beats before they do in these cases.

4th phase

September 30th, 2022 at 12:46 PM ^

I think its both things. The LBs were coached to hang back to induce the give on RPOs. I think Michigan probably felt 3-5 yard runs from RBs were preferable to Rakim Jarret in space over the middle. Making them march down the field on 12 play drives, limit Taulia runs, trust your DTs to take on doubles, etc.

However, Seth is correct and it's obvious from the still images. After the give, you have to move. I can imagine the coaches emphasized this week and said "hang back" with the unsaid and implied direction being "hang back until the give, then charge."

rc90

September 30th, 2022 at 10:03 AM ^

I'm not an expert either, and I'm inclined to give some benefit of the doubt, but that last clip is pretty clearly the "Goofus" panel and not the "Gallant" panel. I start from there, and then what I'm getting from Seth is that Colson's hesitation on that TD dive looks to have been a common problem for the LBs. Linebacking is hard and TaTa makes decisionmaking even tougher, but they do need to be quicker with their reads.

dragonchild

September 30th, 2022 at 9:35 AM ^

I think it was mentioned that Maryland prepped for this game and were a bunch of tricksy hobbitses, messing with Michigan's young linebackers.  Amoeba is said to be very much read-and-react hell for the LBs, so our lack of depth is a glaring weakness right now.

Mentally, confusion can easily snowball into paralysis.  Once you've got brain overload, something simple can be happening right in front of you and you won't react to it quickly.  Except all that stuff Seth wrote, that took us minutes to read?  An read-and-react linebacker is expected to process all that in less than a second.  Sometimes it's just too much.

So IF it's too much for these padawans right now, I'd almost rather have a walk-on out there if they're able to make the reads and go.  Even a Guy who runs a 5.2-40 is preferable to a 4.5 that just stands there.  But this was their first "real" game, so I don't think this hesitation was showing up in practice.

The Homie J

September 30th, 2022 at 11:10 AM ^

I think we're missing Nikhai Hill-Green realllll bad right now.  He was the safer, smarter linebacker last year vs Colson who has more raw athleticism.  However, Colson's raw talent is a bit wasted if he's sitting back and being hesitant.  Last year, he could rush to the ball carrier because if he messed up, Josh Ross or Dax Hill or the safety would fix it.  Now HE is the Josh Ross at the linebacker level with Barrett and especially Mullings on the field.  I think our run defense should perk up A LOT once we get Hill-Green back on the field

dragonchild

September 30th, 2022 at 9:40 AM ^

Question:

Is there such a thing as a defensive (read: linebacker) checkdown?  Like if the offense is doing stuff that wasn't on tape, rather than have read-and-react linebackers stand still in confusion and eat blocks all day, the DC says, "Look, if what you see is weird, just blitz the B-gap," or something.

I mean, QBs have checkdowns, and the MLB is often called the QB of the defense.  If he doesn't know what he's looking at, doesn't it makes sense to give him something to do?

jsquigg

September 30th, 2022 at 12:59 PM ^

Somebody already stole my question (which was how much the RPO was affecting LB aggressiveness) but phenomenal write up as usual. Seth, do you see Hill-Green as an upgrade just in terms of aggressiveness in filling gaps? We know Colson is more athletically gifted, but as Brian has pointed out in the past when highlighting "slow" LBs, sometimes decisiveness is a more valued attribute than physical skills.

DelhiWolverine

September 30th, 2022 at 1:46 PM ^

On the last panel (the MD Touchdown), watch the TE (#84) motioning across the formation as the ball is snapped. His body actually screens the mesh point from Colson's view for a split second and I wonder if this prevented Colson from seeing whether Taulia gave to the RB or was keeping it himself. If Colson couldn't tell who had the ball because the TE was in the way, it would also help explain his hesitation.