coaches say you can't, so don't sign a loi
Previously on MGoBlog: Seth's review of the same.
NCAA 14 hits the shelves today, and EA Sports was kind enough to give us an advance copy to review — for the last four days, I've dutifully ignored the lure of sunlight, company, and basic hygiene in order to cram in as many hours as possible with the game. The things I do for you people.
My review of last year's edition eschewed the normal overview of gameplay and the various modes, instead focusing on how to make another underwhelming, mostly-redundant NCAA an enjoyable gaming experience. For the last several years, the basic debate surrounding NCAA has been whether to drop $60 for a couple gameplay tweaks (and, inevitably, a few new gameplay bugs) or save the money and hope for a good roster update.
This year, EA finally made enough changes that it truly feels like a new game in most aspects. Dynasty Mode got a much-needed overhaul, the gameplay adjustments are mostly positive, and the game as a whole feels more realistic. There are gripes, to be sure, but overall I think this is the strongest NCAA in a while.
There have been enough changes to the gameplay (I know, right?) that even experienced players will want some time to learn the new features and hone their skills. Before doing anything else, I'd highly recommend going through the "Nike Skills Trainer"* — a series of tutorials/drills that covers all aspects of the game. Doing those not only helps you get used to some new controls, especially with the overhauled option (more on that later), but the drills are fun on their own — I found myself hitting "try again" several times to see if I could earn a gold medal in each drill, which unlocks a player for the online-only Ultimate Team mode. The skills trainer replaced the mini-games (option dash, tug of war, etc.), which I miss dearly — while the skills trainer is fun, you can't play against anyone else, and the mini-games were great for quick round-robins with a few friends — but it's certainly a worthy addition.
The biggest change once you're ready to hit the field is in the running game, where EA has implemented the physics engine that made last year's Madden so enjoyable. Running looks and feels much more like real life than in the past — setting up blocks is paramount, size matters in collisions, and there's a bevy of new animations that mostly look great (there are still kinks — a few tackles I've seen defied physics). With a good offensive line, running between the tackles can actually be effective.
More importantly, the option — and spread option — has been completely revamped, and I'd guess most players will find that running it in some form is their favorite way to play on offense. The game now helpfully points out the defender to read at the mesh point (for the read option or triple-option dive) or for the pitch (traditional option) before the snap, and variations like the mid-line option and inverted veer are now in the playbook. Backs maintain proper pitch relationship — an issue in years past — and quarterbacks can take hits without consistently getting injured or fumbling (this varies depending on ratings, of course, but QBs used to be outrageously brittle). The CPU can finally run an effective option, as well, with no more inexplicable pitches landing three yards behind the back; defending the option is hard, as it should be.
The passing game is mostly unchanged. Ill-advised throws are going to get picked off more often than not, which is realistic but also tough for gamers who don't know how to read defenses. There are still a few money routes — thank me later for recommending TE Trail in short- to mid-yardage situations — but I've found I can't predetermine where I'm throwing the ball unless the defense is completely misaligned given my playcall. Linebackers no longer are supermen, which helps; I wish receivers would do a better job on their own of adjusting to the ball in the air, though.
Defense is, one again, pretty damn difficult, especially if you want to play in the back seven. CPU quarterbacks are ruthlessly accurate; on All-American difficulty, my best hope of stopping a pass was to blitz and hope for a sack or throwaway, which along with the occasional drop appear to be the only ways to force incompletions. There are little-to-no mistimed routes, passes just out of a receiver's reach, or panicked chucks under pressure; even with a stellar secondary, interceptions and incompletions were very hard to come by, and instead I had to sell out with the pass rush or play conservative zones to keep YAC to a minimum.
Run defense is largely about calling the right play; from there, unless you're quite adept at linebacker or safety, the way your CPU teammates react is the biggest determining factor in a run play's success — this isn't unrealistic, but it doesn't make for a particularly enjoyable defensive experience. I've mostly lined up as a DT and focused on getting a big push into the backfield, which is more fun than it sounds (at least for me) and can have a big effect on both the pass and run games — collapsing the pocket on a QB is by far the most effective way to stop a passing play, as they often slide right into an awaiting DE.
The good news here is that EA now allows you to set separate difficulties for offense and defense. If you find yourself turning the ball over on half your possessions, you can knock the offensive difficulty down a notch; same goes for defense if you can't get a stop. This is an imperfect solution to a major problem — defensive gameplay is still quite frustrating — but it's still appreciated.
Now here's where things get really fun. Dynasty Mode finally got an overhaul, and it's a good one. First and foremost is the addition of "Coach Skills" — as you progress through your dynasty, you'll earn points for both on-field and recruiting accomplishments, and those points earn upgrades (the details of which can be found here). This adds a RPG-like angle to dynasty that makes it feel like you're really building towards something, not just running through the same season over and over again. You'll have to decide early on if you want to focus on earning in-game boosts (like Coachstradamus, which at its highest level gives you a 25% chance of identifying the opponent's play type before the snap) or an edge in recruiting (Kitchen Sink, for example, raises the cap on points you can spend recruiting individual players). Other coaches earn these same boosts, so you don't just lap the field as your dynasty wears on.
The second major change is the streamlined recruiting process. You get a certain number of points each week to spend on scouting, offering scholarships, and pitching players — those points aren't separate, so you have to find the right balance of scouting and recruiting early on. The critical change is that you don't have to unlock pitches or reset the number of points spent on a recruit each week — you know from day one which pitches a recruit likes and how many bonus points you'll get each week from them, then choose how many additional points to add from your pool. Those points don't change from week to week unless you change them; if you want, you can set your board in Week 1 and then forget about it (though I wouldn't recommend it). Even if you decide to spend time recruiting each week, the process goes much faster — including in the offseason, where the recruiting process has been cut down from a bloated five-week ordeal into a one-shot bidding war (you get a pool of 10,000 points and all caps for individual player spending go away).
The points system adds much more clarity to recruiting; you know exactly how far ahead or behind you are with a recruit, the bonus points your competition is getting each week, and the baseline number of points you'll earn on a given visit. This allows you to be much more strategic when it comes to targeting recruits, especially the longshots. With the roster cap still at 75 (ugh) and yearly scholarship caps at 25, I've found that narrowing down my recruiting board early and bringing in classes of 15-20 recruits gives me the best chance at landing a top class. Other recruiting tips:
Other than recruiting and coach skills, dynasty mode is mostly the same, which is good — that's always been my go-to mode. My biggest gripe is that there is no playoff starting in 2014 — you're stuck with the BCS in perpetuity, which is especially unfortunate since the game occasionally produces some wonky title games. Exempli gratia:
Even worse: Stanford beat Washington by 30 in their simulated matchup.
EA is probably waiting to unveil the playoff (sorry: cofopoff) as a new "feature" in next year's game. This is pretty lame, EA.
Overall, though, the changes to dynasty mode are a big step in the right direction, making an already enjoyable game mode even better. My only gripe with the coach skills is they can sometimes make things too easy — if Coachstradamus tells me the defense is in a Cover 2, I know enough to audible to a play that will gain 15 yards at worst — but you can set how difficult it is to level up, which helps mitigate that issue. The RPG aspect is something I very much enjoy; I found myself tempted to race through seasons so I could pick up more bonuses and build a true juggernaut.
Road To Glory — in which you take a player from high school recruit through his college career — is still in the game and, as EA admitted, is essentially untouched. If you liked the mode in years past, you'll still enjoy it. If you didn't — or found it less compelling than Dynasty Mode — then it's not worth trying again.
EA imported their popular Ultimate Team feature — in which you unlock players through in-game accomplishments, then use them in games against online opponents — to NCAA. You can use these players, which include several all-time greats and (until yesterday) one "oh shit, get him out of here", in head-to-head online seasons or solo challenges. I haven't had the chance to delve into this mode in depth, so I won't comment on its merits except to say that it'd be nice if there was an offline option.
If you're the type who just wants to play the game but still want to play for something, there's a new "2013 Season" mode, which is exactly what it sounds like — you play (or sim, though that seems to defeat the purpose) your way through the 2013 season without having to worry about recruiting and the like. This won't be a feature I use but I'm sure some of you will appreciate it.
It's pretty clear at this stage that EA has maxed out what they can do on the PS3 (oh, hey, just in time for the PS4!). There are some minor graphics improvements — players' muscles are more defined, for one — but the atmosphere falls flat at times; players on the sideline look like they're imported from a PS2, the field and crowd often look flat and dull. This isn't a big deal for me as much as the actual gameplay, especially since it's clear that EA has to hold back on minute details to ensure the game runs smoothy (and I'll take that over picture-perfect fieldturf).
In a long-overdue move, NCAA has new in-game camera angles, including a wide-angle view that allows you to see all 22 players on the field. I haven't toyed around with them much — on the first try, I found the wide angle to be a little too zoomed out — but at least there are options now.
As for the sound, you're still getting the same generic commentary in games, and the same repetitive marching band music in the menus (my first move is always to turn off the menu music and sound FX so I can listen to whatever I want while moving through my dynasty). EA has tried to add to the atmosphere by including piped-in music — yes, "Seven Nation Army" is in the game — which you'll either slightly appreciate or hate with the fury of a thousand suns. (Hi, Brian.)
Aside from the BCS tomfoolery, I've found the game pleasantly devoid of glitches or major issues with simulation. The only real glitch I noticed occurred once, when my CPU opponent went into the hurry-up and, with the rest of the offense set, the center stood over the ball until the play clock ran out. That hasn't happened since and the CPU loves to run the hurry-up, so that's hopefully an easy fix when EA releases the inevitable patch.
This isn't a bug, but a new recruiting feature is "complimentary" visits — no, this doesn't mean your coach heaps an excessive amount of flattery on a recruit, but instead that the player is visiting along with recruits of compatible positions (e.g. having a QB and WR visit in the same week). As a writer, or at least a person with a decent command of the English language, this drives me nuts.
This is my favorite edition of NCAA since they moved to the PS3. The run game is a lot of fun, especially the option, and unlike many I think the passing game is enjoyably challenging. Defense still needs plenty of work, especially in defending CPU quarterbacks, but I'm holding out hope that messing with the sliders — or perhaps a major patch — will alleviate some of the issues. (I didn't touch the sliders for this review so I could give a fair impression of the game right out of the box; if you're a serious gamer, I highly recommend checking the Operation Sports forums for tips on setting sliders.) With the improvements to Dynasty Mode, this is the first time in a while I've felt confident in saying a new edition of NCAA is worth the price tag.
Now if EA could just add the playoff and bring back the mini-games, baby, we'd really have a stew goin'.
*Product placement and ads for in-game extras are both quite prevalent. I found this fairly annoying — and I'm sure Ed O'Bannon does, too — especially when it comes to EA suggesting you purchase booster packs for a game that already costs $60. Long live capitalism, I guess.
I would like to complement you on this review.
Buying this tonight - and as recommended looks like I will hit up the Skills Trainer...
Great review and looking forward to my first investment into the NCAA Franchise since about '05!!!
for the Michigan vs. ohio game
for the Michigan vs. ohio game
It looks like EA has not updated Michigan's away jersey yet, which irks an equipment junkie like myself. I said I was going to pass on this after playing the demo but maybe I will rent it and see if it can win me over.
I bought it today and since I am cool, I will start tweaking all of the rosters of Michigan's opponents for 2013. I know I could just download the rosters, but that takes the fun out of it.
Regarding recruiting, while it's very realistic and detailed, it's not for me. I just put recruiting assistance on and let the computer do it for me. I just don't find it fun spending all that time on recruiting.
Dammit Ace. I was going to skip it this year but you've talked me into buying it. The blood is on your hands.
What's the deal with the 75 roster cap that you mentioned? Why is it different than actual NCAA rules? I'm not as familiar with the game in recent years.
IIRC, it is because if they were to go to the 85 scholarship limit for each team, there wouldn't be enough space on one disc for the game. EA really doesn't want to go to two discs. But hopefully in the next gen consoles, the discs will allow for more space (since they will be BluRay) and EA will push the limit up to the 85 it is in real life.
Really? This seems like a strange reason. After all, the data for a "player" is nothing more than a name and about 20 2-digit numbers - it would seem like the data for an extra 10 players for each of the 120 teams would be a few KB at most.
While I agree with you, that is the reason I read / heard last year.
Then EA actually raised the number of scholarship players. It was 70 for the last 4 or 5 years.
I was thinking the same thing. Storing all of that extra data would be measured in the single MBs I imagine, but whatever I guess.
That is one(!) win against an opponent above .500 and I (Michigan) was ranked #2 despite also being undefeated and destroying USC for their only loss and shutting out a ranked Ohio State. Also, this was the 2016 season, so WATCH OUT FOR TULSA, EH??
We rolled Tulsa, fyi.
Alright, if Ace is in then I am in.
I can't wait for 2018, when I finally buy this game.
Will this be out for the Wii? My boys would love that, but I am too cheap to go buy an X-box.
#4 in the country!
I got this a day early. I've played about ten games vs. CPU so far and this is the best NCAA I have played right out of the box. I can't wait to find a slider set that works for me.
Denard is on the cover. That was the only reason I bought this years version but so far the game isn't bad.
Was that a shot at Seth?
I'm not sure why anyone is outraged by no playoff. 1. Do you expect them to have a different post-season game engine for season 2 on? 2. Are we even sure that they've completely finalized the format of the real playoff yet?
I'm pretty sure there's licensing involved with the BCS (otherwise, they likely couldn't use the bowl names). Also pretty sure the BCS isn't licensing a product that does away with it, even if it's on life support and Dr. Kevorkian has been paged.
a typical last four days, Ace?
"for the last four days, I've dutifully ignored the lure of sunlight, company, and basic hygiene"
probably won't until fall when the price drops a bit and I actually have time to play.
Did anyone really expect the playoff to be in this game? Not only would it be a completely new thing to be added relatively late in the development of this game, but I'm sure EA has some contract language with the BCS that forces them to use the BCS in perpetuity as long as it's valid in the current year. They might have told EA they won't license the name/bowl games/everything else if they only had it in the game for one year in dynasty mode.
game play Dilithium as that's all I want to know!?
But I liked the game better when the teams from the better FCS leagues (CAA, Southern, Big Sky, etc.) were in the game. The generic "FCS-[Region]" teams are way less fun- though it does encourage you to schedule a MAC or Sun Belt team instead.
Carl Weathers!!!!!! Arrested Development!!!! That automatically made it a great review... Actually would have been great either way.
Any idea when downloadable rosters will be available?
Also for those with a 360 I would be interested in doing an ONline dynasty. I've never been in one before but always thought it would be fun.
My gamer tag is the same as my name on here Litt1e Rhino
Sounds like the PS3 version is a little different than the XBOX one. On XBOX, there is an offline mode for ultimate team AND I still managed to earn my Aaron Hernandez card last night.
Same with PS3, he did say he didn't play Ultimate Team so he's probably just assuming it's all online.
I did like some aspects of the demo, mainly the improvement in the physics. However, I have been reading on a couple of other sites about how defense is pretty much non-existant this year, which is also mentioned in the review here. That is what I was concerned about after playing the demo, as it seemed like the option and inside run game were pretty much unstoppable, regardless of difficulty or what I set the run blocking/run defense sliders to. Even playing as VT Tech against Alabama on Heisman with CPU run defense on 100, I was getting 6+ yards a pop on most runs. I think I may just wait and see how things shake out before picking it up, because I can't see myself enjoying the game if slider adjustments can't make good to great defenses more potent.
For anybody with the game or planning on picking it up, if you want rosters with additional corrections besides the players being named, check out the community rosters at operationsports.com. Michigan's default roster seems to be one of the rosters that is pretty much jacked up, at least judging by the demo.
I had convinced myself not to buy this game this year. I had almost convinced myself that at my age, it was time to let the video games go and find some better use of my time. Then I saw this and figured "reading the review won't hurt...it's EA sports, nothing will have chaged".
Ace, you convinced me and I'll be sure to pass along your contact info to my wife when she starts complaining that I'm playing video games again kthxbye.
I didn't have high expectations when I traded in '13 for this, but it's not bad at all. Ultimate Team is pretty fun, and the XP in dynasty is pretty cool. The physics look nice, and the info at the end of each game about other games that took place is pretty cool.
I still can't run the option properly, I'll have to do more practice on that.