"You guys are clowns." -Duke, probably (Bill Rapai)

Michigan Hockey Game #29: Michigan 4, Michigan State 2 Comment Count

David February 10th, 2023 at 11:36 PM

**GOING TO BE A LITTLE SHORTER TONIGHT DUE TO THE WATCHALONG**

CLICK HERE for Game Recap from Kristy McNeil and other pertinent information and HERE for current Pairwise Rankings.

 

What just happened (TL;DR): Michigan played two hockey games on Friday night. One: before the refs lost control and fights broke out; Two: after the game went off the rails and players were ejected, DQ’d, and penalties abounded. Michigan dominated Michigan State in the first period and were in control up the “The Incidents.” Afterwards, it was basically just a matter of hanging on and getting to the end. They dragged themselves across the line and beat Michigan State, gaining the three points.

FINAL CORSI NUMBERS (www.collegehockeynews.com)

 

Total Attempts

Even Strength

Power Play

Close (within 1)

Even Strength %

Michigan State

n/a

41

n/a

4

43%

Michigan

n/a

54

n/a

4

57%

Forward Notes.

-Michigan played really well in the first period. They controlled play and created chances scrolling through multiple lines. Michigan scored early and often. TJ Hughes had a deft pass from below the goalline to Mackie Samoskevich who one-timed a shot behind Dylan St. Cyr. Gavin Brindley also one-timed a beautiful cross-ice pass from Mark Estapa (!) to give the Wolverines a 3-0 lead. After that, the offensive chances didn’t fully maintain, but they did their damage when they needed it.

-Frank Nazar made his Michigan debut on Friday night. He didn’t make many overly notable plays, but he made it back on the ice. That’s a big deal. Rutger McGroarty missed the game for an undisclosed reason. After Adam Fantilli was ejected, lines were a bit jumbled. Gavin Brindley had a 3 point night when Michigan really needed it.

Defense Notes.

-Luke Hughes was a monster. He had a few mishaps at times, but with no Seamus Casey or Jacob Truscott to start, Michigan was already down two of their top four defensemen. Once Ethan Edwards was given an early shower, Hughes seemed to be on the ice every other shift. I’ve been down on his first half of the season, but he’s really turned a corner across the board. His defense has improved so much. And his offensive pressure hasn’t seemed to suffer, either. He’s entering that Must Watch territory, now.

-We talked about this on the HockeyCast a bunch, but Ethan Edwards needs to adjust his play. He got thrown out for another hit to the head (five and a game). Now, I’m not sure I agree with the call, but in this case, there is no reason to go for that hit…clean as it may be. He’s such a valuable defenseman for Michigan (especially sans Casey and Truscott) that he just needs to be in the game and on the ice.

 

Yeah. (Bill Rapai)

 

SPECIAL TEAMS CHART

 

PP Opportunities

PP Corsi For

PP Shots/Minute

Michigan State

1/8

Not Worth

Counting

Michigan

1/5

Not Worth

Counting

Power Play. Trying to add up the corsi attempts/shots for a game like this is a Fool’s Errand. Michigan scored an early power play goal on a beautiful shot from Adam Fantilli. Gavin Brindley teed him up very nicely, and Fantilli walked into the slot and sniped a goal inside the post. That was the most notable play and advantage of the game. The rest of the power plays were…there.

 

Penalty Kill. Michigan did a great job on the Kill on Friday night, finishing off a major to top it off. They also had a couple kills early and late to preserve their lead. However, this game went off the rails in the second period due to lack of control from referees who let the players go…and go they did. It ended with too many post-whistle fights/skirmishes. Finally, Adam Fantilli had enough and went after a couple Spartans. He ended up getting a game misconduct and DQ that will mean he will not skate tomorrow night. Adam cannot let that happen. He’s way too important to this team…a team that has a chance to go a long way and win multiple banners. He needs to be on the ice…not fighting a bunch of punks. That being said, maybe if the referees controlled the game the players would not have overreacted. I already talked about the Ethan Edwards major…college hockey is broken.

 

 

This is a creative shot (Bill Rapai)

GOALTENDING CHART

 

Michigan Shots Faced (House)

Michigan State Shots Faced (House)

First Period

8

14

Second Period

12

7

Third Period

10

10

Overtime

n/a

n/a

TOTAL

32

31

Notes. If you thought Erik Portillo’s trip to Munn last time was crazy, I don’t know what to tell you about Friday night. I’m not sure what is going on, but he’s having the worst time hanging on to his goal stick. It hasn’t specifically cost him yet, but there were 4-5 times that he just could not hang on to his stick. He also got lost/stuck on one side of the crease to often. That happened on the second goal, when he couldn’t get back across his crease (maybe he didn’t see the pass?) and Nicolas Muller hit the open net. Open nets were a bit too constant on Friday night. Portillo and the Wolverines that Michigan State couldn’t find them. Despite all of that, Erik Portillo was there when he needed to be, though. He made a number of saves down the stretch, including an awesome one on a 3v2 that he got all the way across to envelop the save. Portillo is going to need a big night on Saturday in Detroit.

 

ODD MAN RUSH CHART

Defense

Rushes

Advs

Escape%

Offense

Rushes

Advs

Scoring%

1st Period

2

2v1, 3v2

100%

 

1

2v1

0%

2nd Period

1

3v2

100%

 

1

3v2

0%

3rd Period

n/a

n/a

n/a

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

OT

n/a

n/a

n/a

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

Total

3

2v1, 3v2 x2

n/a

 

2

2v1, 3v2

0%

Notes. Michigan gave up a few OMRs on Friday. Luke Hughes made a great play on a 2v1 to break up the cross pass. Erik Portillo made the save of the evening on the 3v2 to keep the puck out of the net.
The Wolverines had a great opportunity early on a 2v1. Adam Fantilli made a sweet pass to an open Brindley in front of the net, but the puck jumped his stick.

FINAL THOUGHTS

The story is getting old. Team gets plowed by Michigan; team decides to fight Michigan instead of play hockey. Refs allow enough that Michigan gets annoyed and fights back. Penalties, injuries ensue. The game is ruined and it’s just a knife and rock fight until the end. Michigan needs to stay out of these brawls and just skate away…but that’s probably not going to happen.

The bottom line is that Michigan survived Munn and now has a tough game sans Fantilli at LCA Saturday night at 8pm on ESPNU.

Comments

stephenrjking

February 10th, 2023 at 11:46 PM ^

Barring a playoff rematch, Adam Fantilli will play two of 12 available periods of hockey against our arch-rivals this season.

He's the national per-game and outright scoring leader anyway. Still, he won't win the Hobey, because an upperclassman from Harvard has a good scoring line too. 

Good to have Nazar back. Basically a true freshman playing his first game; give him a couple weeks and he could be huge when the stakes ramp up. At least, I'd like to think so.

Michigan has, at least temporarily, jumped BU in the pairwise and now sits third. 

ppudge

February 11th, 2023 at 12:35 AM ^

The hit by Sparty late on Hughes (I think it was Jagger Joshua) was a much dirtier hit than Edwards hit that got him DQ’d and there wasn’t even a penalty.  He left his feet and definitely hit Luke high.  If there’s any justice, he’d be suspended for tomorrow’s game.

lhglrkwg

February 11th, 2023 at 10:57 AM ^

MSU football at least attempts to act like a real program here and there. MSU hockey has just been a goon program for yeeeeears now. Every game against these schmucks turns into a circus because they can never skate with us and they get goon-y and inevitably we get hurt more by it because we have something to play for

SF Wolverine

February 11th, 2023 at 2:08 AM ^

Guys have got to be more disciplined.  This is as good a team as any in the country when they can play their game.  Less-talented teams are going to try and drag them down to a lower level, and Sparty put on a clinic on that today.  Took the loss, but get to play us tomorrow down a couple of key players.  I get the bitching about the way games are officiated, but that is what it is, and all we did this evening was get dragged down by something we cannot control.

BlueTimesTwo

February 11th, 2023 at 11:20 AM ^

It's easy to say that we just need to turn the other cheek, but it's not easy to do when you see some hack make a dangerous play against a teammate, or see someone endanger your pro career because they are unable to skate with you.  The point is that we shouldn't have to suffer cheapshots without consequence when the refs don't feel like doing their jobs.  If they are going to go that route, might as well lessen the sanctions fighting and let cheapshot artists get taken to task the next time they hit the ice.

But maybe let someone like Estapa even the score rather than Fantilli?

matty blue

February 11th, 2023 at 5:55 AM ^

what is it about college officiating in general?  i mean, we know - there’s no money for the conferences in finding and developing quality officials - but jeez.  there are times when the games we love become completely unwatchable, and it sucks.

bronxblue

February 11th, 2023 at 7:13 AM ^

I despise playing MSU in hockey.  There was that brief time in the mid 2000s when they were semi competent for decades otherwise they've been this salty, cheap team that just goes for the knees against Michigan.  I know people say "oh, you have to ride above it" but when the refs are calling a shit game expecting a bunch of teenagers and young 20-somethings to be bigger men about it all is a bit unreasonable.  I only caught the highlights and a bit of the Livestream but MSU couldn't skate with UM and so they just started to get mad and fight.  And while teams that are losing predictably get chippy that's on the refs to step in and cool it off.  Instead they let stuff boil over and then put all the heaviest punishment on UM.

Honestly, if UM could drop MSU from football and hockey for a year or two that would be a net positive for everyone involved.

Ferg0dsakes

February 11th, 2023 at 8:16 AM ^

I was at the Wisco game last Friday with my 1997 college roommates.  Like the MgoBoys wrote in the wrap-up, it felt like the late 90’s dominance.  This MSU game looked like the other side of the “late 90’s coin”; the out-skilled and out-played team gooned the game up.  Remember late 90’s ND?  That program gooned it up for years until they had the talent to grow out of it.

A2Photonut

February 11th, 2023 at 9:49 AM ^

What exactly do you want Edwards to do in that situation? The opponent is skating straight towards him, it even looks like he's looking at him, he's not coming at him from the side or behind. Should he bearhug him, or try for a steal instead, or turn it into a hip check so only his butt is hitting him? Wave politely as he skates by? I would think any coach seeing that situation would tell his player to hit him, and the other players coach would tell him he needs to keep his head up.

He needs to protect his own body somewhat with his arms when he goes in for the hit, can he try to keep them lower? Would it have been better to let him skate by and then give him a good BC 2-hander ? I'm assuming the fact that the guy ended up with a cut on his head, most likely from the impact on the ice after the hit, swayed the refs. I just don't see what the alternative is to hitting him, if you don't you're not doing your job. I'm open to suggestions.

MaineGoBlue

February 11th, 2023 at 1:56 PM ^

I agree.  That’s a hard hit that jarred his head back because of the impact.  There was no CONCLUSIVE evidence he hit his head, yet because it flung backwards they called it.

The Jagger call they missed at the end of the game should have been called ice, he launched with high hands.  Regardless of that, when the next whistle blew Nurato had a chance to seal the game with a challenge but didn’t.  Not sure why he didn’t challenge that….

lhglrkwg

February 11th, 2023 at 10:53 AM ^

"Like, they can’t play with us. They can’t play with us unless they goon it up," Michigan head coach Brandon Naurato said.

This has been the summary of MSU's trash program for at least 15 years. Going right back Tropp and Conboy. I still think football is more toxic, but that's also probably because it has more eyes on it. And college hockey officiating is completely broken so it's never handled properly. I hate playing these clowns

MaineGoBlue

February 11th, 2023 at 1:47 PM ^

Nothing besides an opinion here.  I’ll speculate that Casey has a broken collarbone (or something similar) based on the way he was hit and how he skated off the ice after it happened, if so he’s out until the NCAAs, and that would be the best case IMO.  Hopefully I’m wrong and he returns sooner rather than later.  I did not see the Truscott injury so won’t even try to speculate on that one.

Don

February 11th, 2023 at 3:14 PM ^

Seems like the basic approach of MSU athletics—or at least football and hockey—is to lose on the field or the ice and then goon it up after play stops as revenge.