[Coller]

The Cavalry Comment Count

Brian November 16th, 2020 at 4:28 PM

11/14/2020 – Michigan 8, Arizona State 1 – 1-0
11/15/2020 – Michigan 3, Arizona State 0 – 2-0

Kent Johnson acquired the puck from a chaotic scramble behind the net and flicked a backhand pass onto Nick Blankenburg's tape. Blankenburg slid it over to Owen Power with one touch. Michigan's 6'5" freshman hulk of a defenseman feathered into the right slot and blasted the puck into the top corner of an open net.

Then, nothing.

It took a minute to determine whether my brain had shorted out or BTN+ had. It was BTN+, of course, because it is the magic Pictionary horse of streaming services. Or maybe it was both.

I approached this weekend with trepidation, as any experienced Michigan fan must approach something that seems like it might be good or enjoyable. This particular Michigan fan has been posting on the internet about the various white knights flying in to rescue Michigan hockey for literal years, thus amplifying the nervous feeling. It is rare for something to live up to the hype immediately. When it does not there will be recriminations, and I'm currently eating into the Strategic Recriminations Reserve for football. I do not have spare recriminations. 

Michigan's 2020 class immediately lived up to the massive expectations. The breakouts were crisp, the zone entries controlled, the risks astute. (Uh, except for the 3-on-0 breakaway.) The Power goal put Michigan up 8-0 in a game that felt exactly that lopsided. The Sunday game was even more lopsided, statistically, and featured an Eric Ciccolini goal that came after more than a minute of sustained offensive zone time. This replay does not do this shift justice.

It was a five-on-five power play. Much of the weekend was.

It was as if the Compher/Connor/Motte line had been resurrected and then cloned. Even Michigan's checking line—listed second on the lineup sheet but also the only line that won't be pillaged by the NHL at some point in the near future—got in on the action when Nolan Moyle was possessed by the spirit of TJ Hensick, executing a full lap around the offensive zone before firing a puck across the crease that deflected in.

In the aftermath, of course, everyone is excited but also still nervous. The nervousness has a different tenor as the immediate relief now gives way to the second hurdle: the threat that this was a false dawn. For more, see the "is Arizona State any good?" bullet below.

I don't think it is, because I've seen enough hockey to know that you are usually your own worst enemy when the goal of the game is to corral a skittering puck with a stick while you zip around a sheet of ice at 20 MPH, and that the kind of people who immediately pop out as ninjas almost always continue being ninjas. Michigan just imported a busload of them. Also they still have their .939 goalie.

Let's see where it goes.

[After THE JUMP: evaluating Arizona State's quality]

BULLETS

50608207442_d85ef1d429_k

[Coller]

Let's play "is Arizona State any good?" Many worries about this being the equivalent of the Minnesota football game appeared in my mentions over the weekend. I don't think it is for a couple reasons. One: what Michigan did to Arizona State is closer to 78-0 versus Rutgers than 49-24 versus Minnesota. Two: Arizona State is probably a decent hockey team.

ASU's schedule is somewhat controversial because they've qualified for the past two NCAA tournaments* with weak SOS. It's true that they fall in the rankings if you look at KRACH—an alternative ranking system that IMO places too much emphasis on SOS—but they only fall from 13th in Pairwise to 16th.

Meanwhile the Sun Devils lost five skaters while adding Wisconsin transfer Sean Dhooghe and bringing in a couple of NHL draft picks in their recruiting class. One of those picks is the goalie whose heroics kept Sunday from being a replay of Saturday.

The main argument against ASU is that they were at 47% in Corsi last year with a weak schedule and tended to get badly outshot in games against high-end or even middling opponents. They also lost their top defensive pairing to NHL contracts. (They were going to get one guy back until COVID caused him to sign.) That could mean they're likely to eat it against their all Big Ten schedule. About that, though.

*[or would have if the 2020 tournament happened]

In re: 78-0 assertion. Michigan won Corsi (shot attempts) 65-39 on Saturday and 83-31(!!!) on Sunday. You may remember Brendan Brisson blasting one-timer after one-timer on Sunday power plays. That wasn't a major factor. Even strength Corsi there was 65-25.

These are enormous gaps. Last year's Corsi leader was Minnesota State at 59.4%. Michigan's Corsi on the weekend was 68%. That is unsustainable, but if Michigan's anywhere near the Minnesota State number against a Wisconsin team that swept ND to open their season look out.

Beecher is supposed to be fine. He left after taking a big hit on the blue line:

Pearson said he seemed fine and was removed as a precaution. Also that they'll re-evaluate him next week. If he has a concussion the turnaround here is quick enough that he might miss the Wisconsin series.

I'm torn about that hit, BTW, which garnered a two-minute charging call. That's about as clean of a hit as you can make, but since Beecher's reaching for the puck his head is down. I understand why that's a penalty now but it seems like they've legislated much of the hitting out of the game.

Obligatory BTN+ bitching. BTN+ is the worst streaming service I've ever encountered. This game featured:

  • No clock
  • No score
  • No indication of penalty time
  • No replays
  • At least 15 minutes of muted audio
  • Repeated 60-second+ cut-aways from live action so we could see scoreboard graphics instead
  • The aforementioned failure after the Power goal, which caused viewers to entirely miss Arizona State's goal

I have to pay for it because of my job, but several different people in my twitter mentions mentioned balking at the price, especially since the product on offer is so woeful. You'd get money if you fix it! It's 2020! Fix it.

Comments

LewisBullox

November 16th, 2020 at 4:55 PM ^

Let's cut to the core issue. How was Pearson's mask usage? Judging by the scores I'm guessing taped to his face.

matty blue

November 16th, 2020 at 5:10 PM ^

i also felt strongly both ways re: the hit on beecher.  a clean hit, but also worthy of two minutes, if that makes sense.  there were also a couple of boarding / charging calls on sunday that seemed borderline but were probably valid in the interest of player safety.  head shots are not long for this world.

i'm also a fan of some of the non-revenue sports that show up on btn+, and i've practically given up entirely.  women's volleyball is actually more interesting on their twitter feed than the btn+ feed, which seems completely insane but is also completely true.  i'd gladly pay for a better service.  right now it feels like i'm getting totally robbed.  it's infuriating.  pay for one less talking head idiot in the studio on football saturdays and spend it on production.

zlionsfan

November 16th, 2020 at 6:02 PM ^

re: non-revenue sports, same. If the conference is just going through the motions when they air other sports, then at least put them on Twitch or some other place not behind a paywall - volleyball, for one, is the deepest and arguably strongest conference in the country, put it someplace where it can draw the fans it deserves, or at least pay for a real broadcast. Not sure why the biggest contract in the country has only enough money in what seems like half of those matches to pay for an 18-year-old moving a camera back and forth between the court and the scoreboard. (Can't imagine that's much of a marketable skill for the poor intern either.)

mgobaran

November 17th, 2020 at 10:02 AM ^

IMO, charging needs to be called way more often in hockey. Especially at the NHL level. If you care about player safety, you'll stop players from taking 3-4 strides, gliding for a second and smoking a dude after having him lined up for 40 feet. 

But this hit wasn't that at all. He also didn't leave his feet. The Sun Devil is skating backwards, and applying a hip check at the blue line to deny a clean zone entry. Beecher is the one who loses the puck at the more inopportune time and doesn't get his head up.  

matty blue

November 19th, 2020 at 8:28 AM ^

i think we agree, honestly.  it wasn't a cheap shot, by any stretch, and if beecher had had his head up he would've at least braced for the blow.

the first boarding penalty (it might've been called a cross) was totally correct, imo.  you had a defenseless player facing the boards, and even though the arizona state player let up on it, it could've been really bad.

ppudge

November 16th, 2020 at 5:29 PM ^

I decided to do the monthly single school only subscription of $9.95 per month, solely for the hockey team. Very disappointed by the quality of the feed (although I did like that they linked the audio to the UM radio team - whenever the audio worked).

The games were reminiscent of those 1990s teams when I was a student.  We’d frequently light the opposition on fire much in the same way we took it to ASU.  It was so frequent a thing back then that we would be disappointed in a weekend series if we didn’t have at least one game where we’d get free pizza (I believe the promotion was free pizza if we scored 8 goals or more and won).  I counted on that pizza for sustenance, since I was just a poor college student who spent his money on hockey tickets.

lhglrkwg

November 16th, 2020 at 7:03 PM ^

I still wont get too excited till we’re a few series in but if we look great against Wisconsin this week its gonna be hard. As noted, it didnt look flukey. It was crisp. The talent was evident. They played really great hockey with very few mistakes. Seems translatable even if I think ASU is probably going to be near the bottom of the Big Ten. Its rare you dominate anyone like that in D1 hockey. Even Red better teams of the 2000s would only blast UNO or Western like that every once in a while

gobluenyc

November 17th, 2020 at 10:36 AM ^

It also looked as though with time they will get better. The talent level was evident, but with more practice and playing time together, more passes will connect, more intuitive understanding of where the guys will be to pass to and where a pass is coming from will be ingrained. Then, we are talking about a scary-good team.

Packer487

November 17th, 2020 at 1:51 PM ^

I made that comment to someone as well. Even when Michigan just nuked Dave Poulin's last Notre Dame team over and over and over (I think at one point we were up something insane like 49-7 for the season series) I don't remember them just playing keep away the whole time.

ASU probably isn't great, but I also don't think they're awful. Michigan legitimately made them look like a club team. 

stephenrjking

November 16th, 2020 at 7:35 PM ^

Hope.

It's a dangerous thing. But it can also be wonderful. I hope we get to see a full season of this. 

I never record sporting events, but I recorded the sunday night game. It's the sort of thing that may be worth savoring.

We'll see how the season plays out. The postseason, if it happens, will be both very normal (empty arenas! Just like always!) and very weird with zero non-conference exposure. But it seems to be worth watching.

re: The BTN + feed: I'm not saying that the livestream I cobbled together for my church in exactly one week using off-the-shelf stuff on a tight budget with no staff when our governor ordered all public meetings shut down in March was better than what BTN-plus produced, but I'm not saying it was worse, either. How can it be that bad when they're actually charging money to produce it? They have the stock equipment and software already in hand!

bronxblue

November 16th, 2020 at 9:33 PM ^

I nearly bit the bullet on the BTN+ subscription for just UM and then caught the game on Sunday on BTN.  It looked like those 90's teams, almost like an NHL team decided to play a pretty good college team.  ASU looked fine out there; I don't think this is a Minnesota situation at all in terms of a mirage.

As with any sport now I feel weird watching them play at a time when most of the country is still shut down, but it was still nice to see a full weaponized Michigan hockey team for the first time in a while.

orbob

November 16th, 2020 at 9:56 PM ^

I believe BTN+ is mostly student run. That being said, in the years it has been in existence, that probably was the worst I have seen especially since it did not improve one little bit in two hours. 

Dean Pelton

November 16th, 2020 at 10:41 PM ^

Watched a lot of the Sunday game. The ASU goaltender did everything he could to keep it at just 3 goals. Michigan was living in the ASU zone all game. It was beautiful. I really, really hope this team looks just as good against Wisconsin. 

Hab

November 17th, 2020 at 9:15 AM ^

Re: BTN+, I thought the final was 6-1 because at one point, the announcer stated that the score was 4-0 in the third period, we scored twice and ASU scored once.  I thought I was being trolled by reports of 8-1 until I remembered my initial source.  Woeful doesn't begin to scratch the surface of BTN+'s woes.

Craig

November 17th, 2020 at 1:07 PM ^

One thing that really stands out to me between college teams and NHL teams is their passing. College teams often have poor passing that either is off the mark (totally misses the target) or the target player miss-handles the puck and it bounces off their stick destroying their momentum. I noticed that this team passes really well and doesn't miss-handle the puck on their stick. Also, it was nice to see the opponent resort to "dump and chase" instead of Michigan. I remember some of those late Red teams couldn't move the puck up the ice at all.