Development: Leader attempting to prevent showing of American Sniper calls out Harbaugh,

Submitted by Muttley on

as part of "violent rape culture infested football" and associated with "racist militarism".

Soon thereafter the same leader was revealed to have vandalized Omar Mahmood's off-campus apartment door, according to the former Michigan Daily columnist who was fired from the Daily for his satirical article Do the Left Thing that appeared in the Michigan Review.

 

 A Hostile Place for Arab/Muslim Students

 

What's that?

"campus is already a hostile place for Arab/Muslim students"

 

Apparently so, at least for Omar Mahmood as described by Jonathan Chait

 

Around 2 a.m. on December 12, four students approached the apartment of Omar Mahmood, a Muslim student at the University of Michigan, who had recently published a column in a school newspaper about his perspective as a minority on campus. The students, who were recorded on a building surveillance camera wearing baggy hooded sweatshirts to hide their identity, littered Mahmood’s doorway with copies of his column, scrawled with messages like “You scum embarrass us,” “Shut the fuck up,” and “DO YOU EVEN GO HERE?! LEAVE!!” They posted a picture of a demon and splattered eggs.

http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2015/01/not-a-very-pc-thing-to-say.html

 

Mahmood reported that he has known the identity of the vandals all along, but had hoped to reconcile, but said he couldn't hold back any longer in the wake of Khalil’s statements about campus hostility toward Muslims.

Zeinab Khalil, a recent UM graduate, Muslim, and progressive activist who won numerous distinctions during her time on campus, including an award named for Martin Luther King, Jr., thinks it’s the former. A UM group’s decision to screen the film American Sniper offended the sensibilities of some Muslims, including Khalil, who claimed on Twitter that the campus “is already a hostile place for Arab/Muslim students. In one tweet posted on April 9th, she despaired

“Spent 4 yrs at @umich doing anti-oppressive work; admins used me to educate campus. this is what i get in return as exhausted/exploited alum.”

In a sense, she’s right. UM has indeed proven to be a hostile place for at least one Muslim student: Omar Mahmood, whose off-campus apartment was vandalized last December by a trio of women who pelted his door with eggs and left him hateful messages because they didn’t appreciate a satirical column he'd written mocking trigger warnings and microaggressions.

Who perpetrated this act of intimidation against a Muslim student? It was Khalil herself, according to Mahmood, whose account is supported by the testimony of other students, video footage, and emails obtained by Reason.

Khalil was assisted by two others, according to Mahmood, who are also recent graduates and progressive activists in the UM Muslim community.

Mahmood has known this all along—the amateur criminals were caught in the act on the apartment complex’s surveillance video and are identifiable to those who know them—but he says he didn’t report their names to the media in hopes that they would reconcile with him privately. They never did.

In the wake of the controversy over American Sniper and Khalil’s statements about campus hostility toward Muslims, Mahmood says he couldn’t hold back any longer.

  http://reason.com/blog/2015/04/10/at-umich-a-libertarian-muslim-student…

 

MOD EDIT - I know people won't like locking this, but there are a fair number of people who are not handling themselves well and I really don't want to send anyone to Bolivia today. I am in too good a mood for that. -LSA

 

Vengeful Barbarian

April 14th, 2015 at 7:46 PM ^

I thought there was a rule about no politics on mgoblog. Can we fucking go back to that? I dont care about whether or not U of M should screen this movie and I dont care what everyones opinion on this issue is. I like my mgiblog politics free, and this topic is too pilitical.

DetroitBlue

April 14th, 2015 at 7:56 PM ^

The problem is that politics shouldn't be discussed here at all because it brings out the worst in people. If these types of posts/discussions come up frequently, the whole tone of this blog will change. It's also usually a good idea to make your point without adding in childish insults. It makes you come off as petty



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

gbdub

April 14th, 2015 at 8:27 PM ^

So far the posts saying "this is gonna get pulled" or "this won't end well" outnumber the actual number of responses that are even remotely offensive by about 2-1.

No politics is generally good, but I think you ought to have more faith in the commentariat here by now. Plus, this is "local news" for Ann Arbor as much as politics.

An Angelo's Addict

April 14th, 2015 at 7:51 PM ^

Mannnn it's a fantastic movie about an American hero. Pretty sure there are lots of other things done/shown on campus that could be considered "worse". This whole thing is just absurd.

MichiganMAN47

April 14th, 2015 at 7:57 PM ^

People like that don't get very far. Yeah Khalil called out Harbaugh, but there's no real threat here. No one can take Zeinabs perspective seriously because of the vandalism. You can't claim to be tolerant and go vandalize someone's apartment.

Time to let this issue go. Harbaugh said what he said and he's not going to take it back.

Monkey House

April 14th, 2015 at 8:02 PM ^

its a fucking movie. don't like it, don't watch it. this clown acts like they are holding a rally to make a law to end Islam. if he hates the culture of this movie, go fight Isis.

KRK

April 14th, 2015 at 8:04 PM ^

I guess I get both sides of your point and BAMs. If you hate it here so much and hate the people and government then I don't really understand why you stay. I would leave a terrible country if I hated it and had the capability. However just saying that as the be all end all of conversations tends to be narrow minded so I see why some roll their eyes at that. Yes, nothing's perfect but if there's one country you can freely leave its here.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

glewe

April 14th, 2015 at 8:33 PM ^

If anyone wants to deny the sociological reality that we still live in a racist culture, and one that vilifies Arabic and Muslim students, then you are kidding yourself.

You can remark on the wisdom of Khalil's tactics, and the hypocrisy, but to invalidate sociological reality is both political and inhumane.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

Undefined

April 14th, 2015 at 8:47 PM ^

I think my major issue with this is that people go to university to learn to become the person they are, they find their own views. If we start banning things because people are discomforted by them, it's a slippery slope to only having one accepted viewpoint. I haven't seen the movie, but I highly doubt it's "The Birth of a Nation: Part Two". I think if you don't like something, by all means speak out against it and say why you find it wrong. I draw the line when it comes to surpressing what you dislike. As far as the safety issue goes, I find it to be overblown. Racist assholes are going to be racist assholes, this movie is not going to change that for better or worse. Especially on a progressive campus like U of M.

Lancer

April 14th, 2015 at 9:21 PM ^

Though I agree with you, you have had this political bone to pick with the same type of posts two threads in a row, which is quite realving of your own political views.

2011 Western Michigan game at the Big House, my older sister took me to my first game. She wears the head scarf and some punk something along "look at these muslims". Obviously that's one person out 100,000+, but it didn't feel nice. Just because the girl said and did something really dumb, it does not automically discount what she stood for. Obviously, she isn't doing Arabs any favours.

enlightenedbum

April 14th, 2015 at 8:50 PM ^

So is say, Birth of a Nation.  Which is suuuuuper racist and harmful for a whole variety of history of the Lost Cause movement reasons.  Though it is a revolutionary film and a useful thing to use to talk about the Lost Cause movement, which is why it's still used academically..  It just being a movie is not a good dismissal.

That said, I haven't seen American Sniper so won't make direct compasions.  Though this sounds like the kind of liberal activism that is super annoying to me, a pretty lefty type.

sadeto

April 14th, 2015 at 8:37 PM ^

I don't mind people posting topics like this, even though they border on the "political" (doesn't everything?), but can we not give this pathetic person the attention she so desperately seeks? If it weren't for Twitter, she wouldn't even be on our radar, because she appears to have amounted to exactly nothing but a small time petty criminal. 

FauxMichBro

April 14th, 2015 at 9:20 PM ^

censorship at a PUBLIC university should not be tolerated. if viewing this movie was mandatory, that'd be one thing. i'm sure muslim students aren't too keen on the pre marital sex and binge drinking that goes on at umich, but that doesn't give them a right to put an end to it.

Pinky

April 14th, 2015 at 9:25 PM ^

If only young people could put this kind of passion and anger into real activism instead of wasting time protesting the movies choices at UMix Late Night.