BlueWolverine02

July 21st, 2020 at 3:53 PM ^

Not sure what is actually accomplished by not allowing students in the stands, but since i'm not a student I'm not going to lose any sleep over it.

They will just have to get their covid from the party on Friday night as opposed to the game on Saturday.

NittanyFan

July 21st, 2020 at 3:59 PM ^

Governmental officials will typically prefer doing something as opposed to nothing.

It's probably as simple as that.  The illusion of action.

I agree with you, there's not a huge incremental risk of allowing students to attend, say, a University of Buffalo football game where attendance is capped at 25% capacity.

lhglrkwg

July 21st, 2020 at 4:04 PM ^

In my experience, it seems like UB games have been capped at 25% attendance for years (ba dum tiss).

But on a serious note, students obviously wouldn't social distance in the student section at UB or Syracuse so this ban will just force them to not social distance at house parties instead. I suppose the difference is whether the inevitable non-social distancing occurs at university sanctioned events or not

Mongo

July 21st, 2020 at 3:57 PM ^

Will be interesting to see how he deals with the travel restrictions certain states are under and how that applies to incoming college athletes.  The current 14 day quarantine can't work.

NittanyFan

July 21st, 2020 at 4:04 PM ^

I'd guess they'd give college athletes an exemption (like they have done for pro athletes). 

Besides, I would guess the percentage of people following that directive right now is about 0.001%. 

As for the NY Governor was in Georgia just yesterday, and was photographed hugging people while not wearing a mask.  The event he was at, it could fairly be said that his presence at that event was not essential.  NY delivered some PPE equipment to Savannah but it's not like the NY Governor had to be there himself.

Now, he says "I don't have to quarantine on my return" because he was in Georgia for less than 24 hours.  And that is technically true, per the letter of his directive.  

The hug and non-mask wearing, though, are worthy of a few eye rolls.

NittanyFan

July 21st, 2020 at 4:21 PM ^

I get it - many of us have cabin fever to a degree.  It's a nice diversion to leave NYC/Albany for a day.  So I don't completely begrudge him the trip. 

But he had to know the cameras are there and the hug/non-mask would be noticed!!!  Frankly, that was just dumb (on his part)!

Anyway, with a mask and no hug, his trip did follow my general philosophy (and what I wish would be consistent messaging among all governmental folks): "moderate but don't completely eliminate your social interactions, while wearing a mask when inside indoor businesses.  Businesses will all be allowed to open, but we encourage them to take all prudent precautions.  Capacity caps will be enforced in places where social distancing would be impossible at 100% capacity."

lhglrkwg

July 21st, 2020 at 4:36 PM ^

I guess I view it from a managerial perspective more than politics. I work in a union environment (so it can have the same sort of political feel sometimes) and you just gotta know that if you tell everyone something is important and do a, b, and c and then you get caught not appearing to follow your own rules, you're gonna hear about it. Not a smart move from a leadership perspective for the governor

Hotel Putingrad

July 21st, 2020 at 5:35 PM ^

Case in point. Yesterday POTUS tweets picture of himself wearing mask and claiming it's patriotic, then walks across the street to his hotel and starts shaking hands and backslapping everyone in the lobby, while, you guessed it, not wearing a mask.

Weird, I know. It's like all politicians play by their own rules.

Princetonwolverine

July 21st, 2020 at 4:42 PM ^

"Cuomo did a good job with NY"? The families of 32,000+ dead relatives might disagree. Rather than put sick covid patients in the facilities the Feds set up he put the older ones back into nursing homes. 6,000+ dead. Some only ask him about his dating life. Great guy.  

lhglrkwg

July 21st, 2020 at 5:17 PM ^

The nursing home thing sure looks like a mistake, but New York is currently one of the only ones still holding the line nationally and that's with our nation's largest and most densely populated city anchoring it. Many governors have shown they would've handled the same situation far worse than Cuomo did

Bo Harbaugh

July 21st, 2020 at 7:00 PM ^

User name checks out. DeSantis tempted the gods when he was pounding his chest in self-congratulations a month back specifically citing how great they were doing vs. the New York like predictions for an outbreak in his state.  Now they are the epicenter in the US. In times of a seemingly uncontrollable crisis, hubris is not your friend.

Not a fan of any politician at this point given the lack of leadership at all levels of government (from both parties) dealing with the pandemic. Those, however, that at least attempt to discuss the issue scientifically as we learn more about the disease, get a bit more leeway from me than those just hoping/waiting for it to disappear or the vaccine to show up.

Bo Harbaugh

July 21st, 2020 at 8:45 PM ^

I believe the discussion was about cases. 

Deaths are indeed down as the average age of the infected is lower and we have much better knowledge and a multitude of treatment options for the disease now.

Still, deaths are a lagging metric which means the latest outbreak related deaths in these new states will be weighted toward future statistics, and Florida and other states that started spiking 2-4 weeks ago are now having hospitals hit full capacity which will make it more difficult to treat cases going forward - probably the most dangerous indicator of things going sideways.

ESNY

July 21st, 2020 at 10:59 PM ^

 It’s hard to compare NY to the rest of the US as NY was hit first and early being a main point of entry to the US, the economic hub and the sheer density. 

Florida also had 3 months to prepare and did.... nothing. Considering their attempts to manipulate numbers, I’m doubtful we know the full story on the totality of the issue but I know many of the hospitals in FL, at least in Southern Florida where I have family that are surgeons, are at full capacity and have cancelled all elective surgeries due to lack of space. That does not lead me to believe things are going to get better in the next few weeks. 

lhglrkwg

July 21st, 2020 at 8:19 PM ^

Lemme know what other state has gotten this under control. New York's had their new cases steady for a few weeks now while most of the rest of the country is going up and up as guys like Kemp and Desantis try to pretend like nothings wrong. After getting hit hard early, we've recovered pretty well up here

Rickett88

July 21st, 2020 at 6:42 PM ^

Look I get that the numbers now show NY is leveling off... but one could argue the reason things are leveling off is the most vulnerable are, um, well, already dead. 

Also, starting to do a deep clean on the subways in May isn’t a good look either. There are some things where I agree that he can say his hands were tied, but you can’t pick and choose when you want to listen to the President and when you don’t. Either you are always going to do what’s best for your people,  rules be damned, or you are going to follow the rules.

People tend to get themselves into trouble when you pick and choose and that’s exactly what BOTH sides are doing right now and why the US is such a cluster F. 

TrueBlue2003

July 21st, 2020 at 6:28 PM ^

I agree that he gets way more credit than he deserves because he communicated well, I guess is what people liked.

His was a misguided policy, for sure.  It was well-intentioned (meant to prevent a home from disallowing someone to return to their literal home), but not smart of course given the high risk population.

Still all 6,000 nursing home deaths can't be attributed to that policy.  Only a fraction of them.

He also badly misinterpreted survey data about where people were living when they were hospitalized (which he interpreted as where they were infected/how well they were sheltering which wasn't the survey question).

He didn't do a great job.

lhglrkwg

July 21st, 2020 at 8:27 PM ^

Of course the nursing home thing looks bad, but the NYC metro got hit hard in the early days of this when lots of people were still insisting it was a hoax. New York and a few states around us are the only handful of states that actually seem to be getting this under control

lilpenny1316

July 21st, 2020 at 4:43 PM ^

I don't see the point in going to states if they have a 14-day quarantine restriction. Florida has a 14-day directive for a few states and state troopers are checking people on I-95 as they enter the state. If I'm staying with family, maybe I would go. But if you're staying anywhere that checks ID, I could imagine the hotel can refuse you if you're not there for two weeks. 

I'll just stay home and enjoy the beautiful state of Michigan.

lilpenny1316

July 21st, 2020 at 4:39 PM ^

If there is a season, I wonder if there will be bowl games. What's the point in two teams traveling to play in an empty stadium when you can't go out and see the sights. 

 

TrueBlue2003

July 21st, 2020 at 6:53 PM ^

Good question.  Doubt there would be fans allowed and if there is, it would have to be like fight island in the Bahamas or something.  And I don't think many fans would attend even if allowed.

So the question will be whether bowls will want to pay to fly teams somewhere for the TV revenues.  Probably the smallest half of them wouldn't do that.  Maybe the bigger ones.  The new years day bowls and a few others.