Ezekiels Creatures

April 4th, 2019 at 9:31 PM ^

Joaquin Phoenix is kind of a messed up guy. So I guess he's the perfect one to play Joker. He's a real life joker.

Billy Ray Valentine

April 5th, 2019 at 1:11 PM ^

Fuck You(!!!) Mad Hatter and your use of that term.  As a proud father of a beautiful child born with a cleft lip, I'd elbow you in the face as hard as I could if you used that term in my presence.  Who do you think you are writing crap like that?  I think you're a pathetic coward that hides behind internet anonymity and uses slurs.

 

I dare you to post a real picture of your face so we all can comment on your looks.   Mods, this is BS if this goes unchecked.   

bdneely4

April 5th, 2019 at 1:54 PM ^

I completely agree with this take.  My original comment wasn't to insinuate that the movie would have sucked if Heath Ledger would not have been the Joker but more that he did such an amazing job at that role that I thought the movie could not have been better.  I would watch all the Batman movies again but the Dark Knight is one that I have watched more than the others.

Wolverine In Iowa 68

April 5th, 2019 at 10:09 AM ^

Ah, but there's the problem.....the character of Joker is never supposed to have sympathy, and we're never supposed to know his true origin.  Ledger nailed the role by constantly telling different versions of how he got his scars.  Nobody ever know who Joker really was, where he came from...he was just pure evil.

I watched the trailer, and while Phoenix's acting looks to be outstanding, he's humanizing a character that was never written to be human.  He's always been written to be the embodiment of insanity and evil.  The clown prince of chaos.  He's not supposed to have sympathy.  That's my only problem with the concept of the movie.

RockinLoud

April 5th, 2019 at 10:33 AM ^

This is probably the biggest criticism of the film as it stands right now. A linear origin story really takes away the mystique of the Joker and makes him a much less compelling character. 

What would be incredible is if they're actually pulling a bait-and-switch on us. If the scenes of him with his mom and whatnot are actually just schizophrenic episodes of a madman slowly realizing his true psychoticness and the details of his past actually remain shrouded.

Toasted Yosties

April 5th, 2019 at 1:19 PM ^

Though his murky or unknown origins have now become the accepted take, Joker does indeed have a general origin story (with variations), that of being a criminal, often but not always named Red Hood, who falls into a vat of chemicals, causing his transformation.

The comic The Killing Joke has a particularly memorable take, framing the Joker as a failed comedian who turns to crime, as Red Hood, to support his pregnant wife, before falling into chemicals.

Personally, the unknown is always more scary, and l prefer that take on Joker’s origin, but some of the origins for him that exist do paint him sympathetically and are pretty damn good.

JoeDGoBlue

April 5th, 2019 at 9:58 AM ^

Yeah, it’s interesting what they can do with superheroes (or villains) in a non-superhero movie.  

I felt that way about Logan as well.  If you haven’t seen it, it’s definitely a gritty western with a dash of noir that just happens to have superheroes in it.  Really good movie.  

Qmatic

April 4th, 2019 at 10:01 PM ^

DC ditched the Jared Leto Joker so fast, it’s like they don’t want us to know he existed. 

DC has only succeeded in their EU with Aquaman and Wonder Woman. They’ve really botched Batman and Superman; the quick follow up to the Nolan trilogy was a gamble that has so far failed.

I was skeptical when I heard of a Joker standalone film because the Joker doesn’t have much of an origin backstory, but they enlisted the best guy to get his storyline out there and hopefully gets this extended universe back on track.

umaz1

April 5th, 2019 at 10:56 AM ^

That's what is weird about this. They haven't scrapped the Jared Leto joker. He is shooting his own stand alone joker movie, and rumors of a second suicide squad. 

This is supposed to be a one time origin story movie for this version of the joker.

Skiptoomylou22

April 4th, 2019 at 10:02 PM ^

I'm excited for this. I think Joaquin is one of the best actors out right now. If you haven't seen them, I'd recommend 'You Were Never Really Here' and 'The Sisters Brothers' for more recent examples. I like the more intimate indie approach to this as a look into a fractured mind as opposed to a good vs. bad beat em up movie but I guess that is still TBD and the director comes from a mostly comedy background.

Fun fact also, I'm pretty sure that little kid he makes smile is a young Bruce Wayne and his name Arthur Fleck (A Fleck) is a pretty funny coincidence.

TheCube

April 5th, 2019 at 9:01 AM ^

My least favorite part of the movie. Just ditch the fan service for once. 

The age difference is fucking weird too. 

Other than that it really does seem like Joaquin’s joker could morph into something like Heaths down the road. They even kind of look the same. I know Phoenix and Ledger were really good friends, so I’m sure there’s homage there