The Unappreciated Devin Funchess Comment Count

Ace


This should be how we remember Devin Funchess. It is not. [Fuller]

Losing isn't conducive to hero worship. This is, perhaps, an obvious point. For every Minnesota-era Kevin Garnett, a beloved star on a bad team, there are many New York Carmelo Anthonys, nitpicked and questioned to an unreasonable degree while surrounded by lesser talents, hampered by poor coaching, or both.

Which brings me to Devin Funchess. In 2013, Funchess could do no wrong as the matchup nightmare foil to Jeremy Gallon's production by precision. Expectations entering last season were so high Brian had to repeatedly clarify that Calvin Johnson comparisons weren't entirely reasonable:

So Devin Funchess probably isn't Calvin Johnson. Michigan should try to prove that assertion wrong. Expect something between first team All Big Ten and an All-American followed by an early entry into the NFL draft. He may even win the Mackey award, because people don't pay attention.

Funchess's 2014 initially met expectations; he looked like a man among boys while scoring a trio of touchdowns in the opener against Appalachian State. Funchess managed 107 yards against Notre Dame as Michigan got whomped, but the seeds of discontent were planted:

We didn't know this, of course, because Brady Hoke didn't talk about injuries. "He's fine," Hoke said, days before he'd hold Funchess out of the Miami (OH) game.

Funchess didn't look the same for the rest of the season. He didn't record another 100-yard game until the season finale at Ohio State; he reached the end zone just once after the opener. With the offense—and the season, and the Hoke era—crumbling around him, the focus turned to his occasional drops and a perceived lack of effort. Save for Devin Gardner and the coaching staff, Funchess drew more ire from fans than any other member of the program.

Never mind that he clearly played hurt. Never mind that his quarterback had the worst year of his career. Never mind that his catch rate actually improved from 53% to 62% despite him being targeted on nearly a third of Michigan's passes—and even more frequently on passing downs, when it became obvious to all that the ball was going his way. Never mind that when Gardner threw his second interception against Northwestern, Funchess blew through two block attempts, chased down Ibraheim Campbell after a 78-yard return, and laid a lick on him for good measure:

This didn't fit the narrative. Funchess wasn't an otherworldly talent gamely battling through injury in a lost season even if it meant hurting his draft stock. He was a prima donna wide receiver who hadn't earned that status, a guy who didn't care about winning, if you interpreted an unfortunate postgame presser soundbite as so many did.

When Funchess declared for the NFL draft, the reaction from many Michigan fans wasn't one of disappointment or sadness; instead, the news was met with indifference or, quite often, a list of all the reasons why he'd fail as a pro. That list got longer when he ran a disappointing 4.7-second 40-yard dash at the NFL combine a month ago. It was only after, when his draft stock and earning potential had taken a serious hit, that we learned he was still recovering from an injury of which we never knew the full extent.

I can't say for certain whether Funchess will succeed in the NFL. If I had to guess, though, I think he will. At his best, his combination of size, speed, and body control is up there with anyone; we just didn't get to see him at his best last year for reasons almost entirely out of his control. If he works through his too-frequent battles with butterfingers, he's got the potential to be a defense-bending number one receiver.

In an alternate universe, Funchess may very well be Braylon Edwards, whose game was eerily similar right down to the frustrating drops. We remember Braylon in a very different light; winning helps quite a lot, as does avoiding injury and being surrounded on all sides by NFL talent. I hope we'll come around on Funchess and similarly celebrate his accomplishments instead of bashing him for failures not of his own doing. If, and hopefully when, he's skying over NFL defenders like so many Mountaineers, we'll be glad we did.

Comments

Indiana Blue

March 24th, 2015 at 8:33 PM ^

was pre-season All-Everything and what resulted was dissappointing for Devin, the coaches and the fans.  However ... this is now about a former player, who was coached by a former coach.  This is all history, period.  NOTHING about this will reflect on anything during the Harbaugh era.  IMO - we gain absolutely nothing reflecting on football or player operations under a past regime.  

I hope Devin finds a successful future and has gained from his Michigan experiences .... it wouldn't surprise me to see Devin be a very successful person out of the football arena entirely.

Go Blue! 

lilpenny1316

March 24th, 2015 at 8:52 PM ^

That's not his fault.  The coaching staff failed him.  I doubt he was ever coached up to a level where he could match the hype.  It's unfortunate, but he has an opportunity at the next level so good luck to him.

JOHNNAVARREISMYHERO

March 25th, 2015 at 1:11 AM ^

Anyone that we needed to be healthy never was for whatever reason.  Something was fundamentally wrong with the way we trained because the amount of injuries was ridiculous.

Maybe down the road, Devin Gardner will admit it, but he was never even close to 100% this season as well.

 

jblaze

March 24th, 2015 at 11:04 PM ^

If your coach would have mentioned your injuries, we fans would have loved that you played with such heart.

Yeah, I'm still bitter about Hoke.

JOHNNAVARREISMYHERO

March 25th, 2015 at 1:09 AM ^

One of his first pass and catches against Utah, one Utah guy went low at the leg and another guy went high.

Moments later, Funchess was limping again.  

You don't want to say too much about injuries imo - puts targets on guys.  Even though there was nothing specific said, Utah knew where to hit him.

 

bleed_trueblue17

March 25th, 2015 at 1:49 AM ^

That ppl are willing to trash a kid basically for not meeting hype he never asked for. Most ppl are mad about things out of his control. He was a terrible blocker. Guess what some ppl just can't block just like some ppl just won't run a 4.4 as a line backer (Morgan) that doesn't make them bad.

Now add on to this that he's playing under a clearly incompetent staff... As an athlete I've faced similar situations and that is emotionally draining. It can affect your play as it did to multiple guys not just Funchess.

Now add on the fact that his coaches got him injured in garbage time, now your trust for the coaching wavers. This affects you in the sense that maybe they did try to teach Funchess to care about blocking but if he doesn't fully trust or respect the coaches they can't get 100% out of him

Now add that he clearly wasn't utilized correctly by either OC. He's getting blasted over the middle while he's already injured and that's not his game. You can be all mad about him
Not being physical but I don't think that warrants bashing him non stop.

So after all this he plays almost every game, makes plays like the gif above, gets no help from his team or QB, the coaches continue to prove they are overwhelmed and he's still making plays(the psu catch) with broken toes. So he knows all this and ppl continue to bash him.. Ya my morale would drop real quick too. I don't think he was the next Braylon Edwards but denying that this kid had talent and saying he had zero effort is just ignorant to me at least. This kid worked his whole life to make the NFL I think he knows it takes more than pure skill. He faced adversity and it got to him and because of this we criticize his character? Everybody makes mistakes. Funchess was in a horrible situation with staff and team and it got him down. Big deal. I'm glad he was at UM for three years and hope he makes it at the NFL. I wish we coulda seen the potential but I won't hate him simply cuz he wasn't Braylon like so many ppl on this board

BradP

March 25th, 2015 at 9:58 AM ^

It is really hard for me to believe that the toe injury was that hindering to the guy running down an all-conference safety in that gif, or that it had much of anything to do with his dropsies.  I also wonder if his catch percentage had much more to do with the complete abandonment of downfield passing (Gardner's completion percentage increased and YPA cratered last year).

Funchess may or may not excel in the pros, but his departure was met with a chorus of "meh" because he had problem maintaining any consistency of focus and effort that was indicative of the team as a whole.

Webber's Pimp

March 25th, 2015 at 10:18 AM ^

I appreciate the fact that he played hurt. But let's not make him out to be a hero. Over the course of the season there were numerous instances of DF alligator arming some very catcheable passes...

RoxyMtnHiM

March 25th, 2015 at 10:26 AM ^

Carmelo Anthony is a certified turd. There are no useful comparisons involving him except more turdier or less turdier.

Mo Better Blues

March 25th, 2015 at 11:01 AM ^

Not to continue to dredge up the hurtful past, but I'm of the mind that Funchess' lacklustre production--injuries aside--might also be partly attributed to the fact that he had a QB (I know, I know, we all thank him for his service, he's a great guy, hope my daughter marries someone just like him, etc., etc., etc.) that was totally inconsistent, prone to inaccuracy/hideous interceptions, and was constantly setting him up to get hammered over the middle--which can be intimidating even for a potential superstar. I mean, I remember watching those games and wondering if Funchess wasn't legitimately surprised a few times by balls that would actually make it to him. (Of course, then you gotta, like, catch those, man.)

It may be an unpopular opinion, but with DG at the helm, I don't think there was any way Devin Funchess--healthy or no--was *ever* gonna live up to his potential at Michigan. I have a feeling he'll be a big (or at least, reasonably bankable) name in the NFL, and while I really, REALLY hate over-praising young players that haven't "done anything yet", Funchess had all the necessary tools and talent to wear the #1 unquestionably and put up big numbers on a different team. Hoke & Co. misused and abused him--just like they did with any number of other great, young prospects.

Roc Blue in the Lou

March 26th, 2015 at 11:45 PM ^

Funny, i thought i had read on many occasions that Gardner really was hampered by a poor receiving corps and that included the lackluster efforts of Funchess.  Now, suddenly, his foot makes all his effort issues meaningless and puts the blame squarely back on DG.  Look, i hope the best for both DG and DF, but i'm not sure either would be starting for long under Sir James.  Looking forward to discussing more than a player's NFL stock...i want to WIN and i want men who will do whatever it takes to match the intensity of JH and bring UM back to winning.  Frankly, NFL be damned.