Count all the prayers [Bryan Fuller]

Punt/Counterpunt: Indiana 2020 Comment Count

Seth November 7th, 2020 at 8:28 AM

IU links: Preview, FFFF Offense (chart), FFFF Defense (chart), Podcast

Something's been missing from Michigan gamedays since the free programs ceased being economically viable: scientific gameday predictions that are not at all preordained by the strictures of a column in which one writer takes a positive tack and the other a negative one… something like Punt-Counterpunt.

image

PUNT

By Bryan MacKenzie
@Bry_Mac

You’ve gotta write something.

C’mon, man. You’ve done this 57 times. Just write something.

Words. On the page.

/flips back to Twitter

NO. Bad writer. VERY BAD WRITER. Focus.

Uh…

/sigh

-------------------

[After THE JUMP: Words?]

The blessing and the curse of Punt/Counterpunt is that it requires no facts. Truth be told, facts often get in the way. Oliver Wendell Holmes famously once instructed lawyers that, “If you’re weak on the facts and strong on the law, pound the law. If you’re weak on the law and strong on the facts, pound the facts. If you’re weak on both, pound the table.” So for those of us looking to pound the table, the facts can be an obstacle. Now, did Holmes actually say that? Probably not. But that’s irrelevant. Because that’s the point.

Some people—often visitors from that week’s opposing fan bases—mistake this column as a representation of what we *think* will happen. Like, in the football game, with points and plays and tactics and strategies.

That has never been the point of this column.

This column has always been about how it the game feels. The idea is to give voice—silly, stupid voice—to the conflicting thoughts in your head as you ponder a football game. The optimist and the pessimist. The angel and the devil perched on your shoulders. The yin and yang. The Team Edward and Team Jacob.

clip_image002

The goal has never been to predict whether Michigan will win or lose. The goal has been to say, if you win, how will that have felt? The first time something good or bad happens in the game, what will your brain brew up for you? The way a smell can evoke a memory of your high school girlfriend, or a few bars of an old song can remind you of the time when it was a hot one, like seven inches from the midday sun. Sports form part of our lived experience, both individually and as a group. This column attempts to tie those threads together.

But now we have arrived at the issue: I don’t feel anything.

I don’t mean that in the super-depressing way it sounds. But when I think of this game, for the first time in a long time, it doesn’t evoke any emotions. Not excitement or anticipation or anxiety or dread.

Maybe it’s because the chaos of pandemics and elections has left football feeling unimportant. Surely losing to a bitter rival in week two, and the corresponding prospect of yet another mediocre season, doesn’t help. But I think the biggest piece is the growing understanding that this season does not, and will not, make any damn sense. It’s a random number generator.

clip_image004

The Indiana game used to be a celebration of chaos, but it was a different kind of chaos. It was funhouse mirror version of an ordinary college football game. A standard deviation away from normal. Maybe two in a particularly crazy year. A three hour divergence from the primary storyline.

This season does not have a storyline. It just has a weekly game of “who can stay healthy enough to play.” The context of 2020 has put too much of a dent in the suspension of disbelief. And as such, this column has no power.

Don’t worry. It’ll come back. Michigan 27, Indiana 23

----------------------------

image

COUNTERPUNT

By Internet Raj
@internetraj

 

My first car was a used 1995 green Ford Taurus. Actually, describing it simply as “green” would be charitable – it was more of a “mold green”, the exact shade of gag-inducing emerald that you find spreading its tentacled spores across a long-expired loaf of bread.

clip_image002[4]

The only car whose value would probably rise if it was spray-painted “STAEE”

But it was the best car my parents could afford and as a high school junior, I was just grateful to have one. It got me from point A to point B, even if it did so just barely. The speedometer did not work once the car was driving faster than 25 mph, at which point the needle would swing wildly from 0 to 60. “That’s good,” my dad said. “It will build some great instinctual driving skills.” The steering wheel, meanwhile, was so misaligned that I had to hold it at a 45-degree angle just to go straight. “Look at the bright side,” my dad would say. “At least it’s reliably unreliable.” The air conditioner worked sporadically, the “check engine” light was never not illuminated, and the muffler had a disturbing proclivity to just fall off while driving.

It was at this point of the ever-growing list of mechanical failures that my dad would eschew optimistic spin for a blunt dose of grounding candor: “At least you have a car” And that was that. I’d nod and always come around. My Taurus was far from flashy, it was magnitudes shittier than the cars my friends drove, and I’m convinced it almost killed me a handful of times. But, on balance, he was right.

At least I had a car.

Coming into this season—one set against the backdrop of a global pandemic, unprecedented political turmoil, and a general feeling of existential unease and uncertainty—I didn’t have my usual lofty expectations and preseason delusions of grandeur. A brand new, raw quarterback, plenty of roster turnover and critical departures, and the persistent disappointment that has become a hallmark of the Harbaugh Era all conspired in shaping my sober outlook. When it came to the 2020 Michigan football team, the parts were rickety, any boldly optimistic prediction would likely be just as wrong as my speedometer, and even the slightest nudge of the steering wheel could send the entire season careening off the road.

But hey, at least we have a season!

I experienced something relatively new after MSU decisively throttled Michigan last week. Instead of spiraling into the familiar bowels of disenchantment of the BPONE, I instead was comforted by the warm, cathartic embrace of a new sensation: the Liberating Panacea of No Expectations, or “LPONE.” In the LPONE, I could take a step back and accurately judge Michigan football for what it has become: a washed-up lemon of a car full of familiar warts, defects, and flaws. One that I’ll always love and cherish, but one whose status is so far from reach of the suped up sports cars zooming by it that I would truly be foolhardy to let its deficiencies bring me down. Just take a deep breath, a long exhale, and let the soothing waves of the LPONE lap over your soul.

clip_image004[4]

Michigan vs. Minnesota

I’ll never forget one particular time when my Taurus’s engine died on the middle of Telegraph Rd. Using the dwindling momentum of the car, I quickly cut across three lanes and pulled into the first available parking lot. It was a BMW dealership. My stalled Taurus, waiting for a tow truck and sitting alone in a thick of sparkly German-engineered luxury, is an apt metaphor for the Michigan football program of 2020. We’re not Ohio State, we’re not Alabama, we’re not Clemson. Hell, over the last decade, we’re not even MSU.

But I loved my Taurus and I do love my Wolverines. And I’ll be there even when we pull out of the parking lot after the Indiana game with a few new dents and a missing muffler.

At least we have a season.

Michigan 17, Indiana 21

 

Comments

ih8losing

November 7th, 2020 at 9:16 AM ^

The Michigan v. Minnesota image is spot on. At first I thought it was going to be "Michigan under Harbaugh" but yeah...

That both Raj and Bryan think Michigan will hold Indiana to 23 or less points is rather surprising and hopeful. 

Blue Vet

November 7th, 2020 at 9:35 AM ^

Gentleman (not /s):

So in this week's Punt / CPunt, based on legal reasoning and automotive engineering, Raj haz feelingz, while Mac haz none (in his haz not suit?).

Feeling my way between those alternative feelingz ... I agree.

Blue Vet Gent (maybe /s)

 

 

fatpete

November 7th, 2020 at 9:56 AM ^

I too was a dad who provided rust-buckets (that worked) for kids to drive in HS. It was actually fun when my kids complained about certain components that lacked functionality.....  I would not so silently laugh and just say "yup". 

So, Raj, I gladly enjoy fraternity with your dad.

.....oh, and great thoughts too.

AlbanyBlue

November 7th, 2020 at 10:14 AM ^

Today will consist of A LOT of blowing leaves out to the street!

PUNT: I have a lot of leaves, but it's kind of fun getting them out to the street. The lawn looks great when I'm done. I don't have to bag them. I get to use power tools. Making a giant pile is pretty cool, evoking memories of childhood and Michigan footb.......no wait, leaves, leaves. Yes, focusing on leaves. Oh, and there will be a cold beer at the end.

AlbanyBlue's Saturday 38, Leaves 24.

COUNTERPUNT: It really stinks that I seem to get more leaves than the neighbors. I mean, my pile is larger than pretty much anyone else's on the street. But I've done it for a couple years now, so it's all right.

But at least I have a leaf blower!

Leaves 17, AlbanyBlue's Saturday 13.

mgobaran

November 7th, 2020 at 10:34 AM ^

I'm just proud of myself for not letting the MSU result ruin my weekend last week. That's a big step for me. Now let's go out and enjoy what on paper looks like will be a competitive matchup between two long time foes. 

Anthony Carter start dancing, and Bob Ufer honk that horn! We're going down to Indiana to play a football game! 

Amaznbluedoc

November 7th, 2020 at 12:44 PM ^

While I embrace the Raj narrative it is an unfair analogy of the state of M football.  First, your dad didn’t spend Lamborghini money for a Taurus nor did he try to pass it off as a Veneno.  Sorry we’re stuck with an Edsel, up on blocks, and with no engine. Love the story though bro.