[photo via SI via MGoFish]

Exit Casey Phinney Comment Count

Seth September 21st, 2020 at 9:27 AM

We missed the news because I had a holiday this weekend. On Saturday afternoon 3* LB commit Casey Phinney decommitted from Michigan and quickly flipped to hometown Boston College.

Phinney was one of three low-ranked Northeastern players, along with TJ Guy and Dominic Giudice, who joined Michigan's class in the early weeks of the lockdown. While Guy appears to be a Kwity Paye-level discovery, and Giudice is an already-275-lb DT who's still being evaluated as an outside pass-rusher, the sites continue to rank Phinney barely inside top-1200, which would put him behind eleven current Michigan State commits. Even when he committed we were tactfully wondering if Phinney would get moved to fullback, a position that's being phased out of the program. Phinney probably wondered as well. Since Phinney pledged, Michigan has added three 4* linebackers, the NCAA gave everyone—notably the four LBs in Michigan's 2020 class—an extra year of eligibility, and recently the Wolverines secured another Massachusetts linebacker for 2022 who's basically a four-star version of Phinney. Both parties should be fine.

The timing leads to speculation that Phinney was dropped when he didn't help reel in high-4* teammate Drew Kendall, but that's been largely debunked; if Kendall chose Michigan for a friend it would have been TE commit Louis Hansen, not anyone at Nobles, and Michigan was well aware. There were some rumblings that BC was trying to poach Hansen, but these appear to be all from BC's side.

There is no content after the jump.

Comments

lsjtre

September 21st, 2020 at 9:45 AM ^

Was admittedly overreacting a bit when I first saw this a few days ago but then realized that he was the most head scratchingly low commit in the class and the comparison to MSU's class just put things into even more perspective.

blueheron

September 21st, 2020 at 10:31 AM ^

On HS highlight clips it's hilarious to see the difference between the crowd sizes and playing fields of New England and the Deep South (and Texas). The Upper Midwest is somewhere between them in both measures.