Zach Carpenter Commits To Michigan
This one rather came out of nowhere:
Committed. #GoBlue pic.twitter.com/GuYFOH2Lk6
— Zach Carpenter (@CZach23) May 31, 2018
That's 3.5* interior lineman Zach Carpenter, a Cincinnati native who had nine crystal ball picks, all to Clemson, before committing to Michigan fairly out of nowhere. Carpenter gives Michigan a full class of 5 OL as they seek to rebuild their line under Ed Warinner. The ranking may not be great but the peripherals look solid; a full Hello post tomorrow.
(photo via 247)
UVA.
He's a smart kid. I like where they are going with the O line recruiting in terms of getting the quality prospects with a lot of intelligence.
No offense, but I find fault with your reasoning.
I doubt that UMich ever intentionally "went away from Ohio." It doesn't take a genius to acknowledge the strong recruiting pull of Tressel and Meyer. Here's the important question: In the years where there weren't many Ohio players in the class, did the ones from other states (including Michigan) perform well? You seem to think there's something special about Ohio players. Who cares where they live?
Also, MSU got strong for a variety of reasons. They're elite (like it or not) at some combination of player development and identification of talent at the HS level. On this point, you seem to think that 3-star Ohioans specifically are special *and* that Michigan could've tipped the scales in the rivalry if only they'd taken *those* players instead of (say) someone from Wisconsin / Indiana. It's implied that "keeping them away from MSU" would've kept Sparty from unearthing talent in some other geographic area.
Unlike MSU, Michigan does not have to focus on regional recruiting for most of it’s team, and making inroads in places like TX, FL, GA etc. is valuable going forward.
That said, taking a player from M or Ohio does have the advantage of reducing the talent pool for the regional B1G recruiting teams AND there is at least some value to “knowing the rivalries”.
Going forward - unless there is a benefit in addition to the player (I.e. getting an “in” into Grayson HS in GA) - it is probably better to take an equal talent from MI or OH. The caveat is that coaches need to determine what is “equivalent”. I have seen conflicting arguments that kids tend to be overrated in the talent-rich states due to the increased exposure but also that they can be underrated “since you can’t make them all 4-stars”.
Welcome Zach! You made a great choice both academically and for football.
Huge pick up. This kid is a beast, stars dont matter but this kid seems way too underated. Big time offers from Clemson. 5 OL in one class I love it. You win in the trenches, I hope one day they can field a oline like Wisconsin.
Yes they do. This has been proven over and over. If you want proof look at the rosters of the teams that played in the NC game last year.
had nine crystal ball picks, all to Clemson, before committing to Michigan
About time our bagman got off his ass.
GarMoe is on fire!
Like our coaches, Clemson knows what they are doing. So if Clemson wanted him, that's good enough for me to think we want him too.
Welcome aboard Zach!!
Welcome aboard.
Comments