The Silver Lining: I Have Found It

Submitted by Jon06 on

I thought for a while that Brady Hoke's treatment of Shane Morris was without parallel, and then I remembered Lane Kiffin's treatment of Robert Woods against Utah in 2012. And here is the silver lining: there is no record, at least so far as I can find on the internet, of USC fans demanding Kiffin's head for the dangerously poor judgment.

The Michigan Difference is just this: this community actually cares. We care about the safety of our players and the integrity of our coaches. When a coach does not live up to the standard of integrity at Michigan, we demand change. When an athletic director runs a program that does not put the well-being of student-athletes first, we demand change. And when a football player's future is endangered by the incompetence or callousness of a coaching staff entrusted with his development and protection but blinded to the realities of medical science by the mantra of toughness, we demand change. Let there be change. Ensuring that the job not only gets done, but gets done right--that's the Michigan Difference. This time, at least, it has to be.

Sub-snowflake addendum: the main reason I don't like Dave Brandon is that he is the only person I have ever met in the administration at Michigan--and maybe Brady Hoke will turn out to be this kind of person, too--who does not respond to criticism from their Wolverine brethren with an honest attempt to learn from the feedback to do the job at a level that reflects well on an institution that's bigger than all of us. Dave Brandon is the only one who reacts to criticism with sarcastic dismissal, the only one who won't listen to his fellow Wolverine, and the only one who does not do everything he can to do the job at a level Michigan deserves.

King Douche Ornery

September 29th, 2014 at 5:23 AM ^

OP, your premise is really fucked up.  AND the real Michigan Difference is searching and finding yet another way to be the most self-righteous, self-flattering fan base in the history of sport.

moredamnsound

September 29th, 2014 at 5:25 AM ^

Yeah. But at the same time, it is a little overblown because we've been losing a lot. People would be concerned about this incident if we were winning, but nobody would be calling for his head. Go ahead and act like this is the worst thing that's ever happened and use a bunch of words like 'unconscionable'. If you point to the handling of Shane as the main reason he should be fired, you're lying to yourself. You were waiting for something like this to happen so you could feel less bad about wanting him fired.

All I'm saying is that we should be clear (and honest). Hoke needs to be fired for the team's poor performance and regression. His management of Shane is simply the event that made us lose any sort of sympathy we had left for him.


Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

CarrIsMyHomeboy

September 29th, 2014 at 8:50 AM ^

Yours is the most honest post yet in this thread. And something too seldom said. Michigan fans have simply wanted an excuse and now they have it.

It's not that the Shane thing is strictly not fireable...it's that connecting it to fan piety is obnoxiously and transparently self-aggrandizing and therefore one of the most "Michigan man" things ever.

michmaiku

September 29th, 2014 at 7:39 AM ^

... is the lawyered up response of "Hoke" and the University. Not much in that to distinguish M ethically.

As for fan reaction, I'm of the mind that the reason it stands out so prominently is because it's the latest, most egregious lapse etched in sharp relief to chronic, general incompetence and cluelessness. 

As a one-off event, however -- minus all the attendant "real fans don't boo", 10-man(ball) punt formations, Bran-drones, Have a Hoke and a Smile, etc. -- this would maybe have registered as a horrible, puzzling lapse, but would not have registered so broadly among the fan base and almost certainly have slid.

 

ziggolfer

September 29th, 2014 at 7:42 AM ^

Thanks for your post. I really wish I had been more open when we met at potbelly's my senior year. Sorry to hear that your dog died. I'm still around AA if you read this post. Hopefully we will run into each other again before I graduate in 2017. 

This outlook is the best I've seen all year. Thank you for your contribution again. 

Jon06

September 30th, 2014 at 4:46 PM ^

Thanks. And no hard feelings--as I recall the meeting, you were polite and humored me well.

I mean, I have a t-shirt with you on it (Sports!) but it's not like I have a claim on your friendship.

But anyway thanks again for your comments. I finished my third Michigan degree in August and teach at a college in (gulp) Ohio now, although I'm back on campus for a few football and basketball games each year. (During basketball games on January weekends, you can probably find me behind Michigan's bench, three or four rows behind the Maize Rage, equipped with a large beard and maybe a toddler.)

Cold War

September 29th, 2014 at 9:41 AM ^

It's easy to clamor for your medicine when in fact that medicine is candy.

The Morris incident is just red meat for the Fire Hoke crowd. There's no moral high ground here.