[Bryan Fuller]

A Funeral For Geese Comment Count

Brian September 23rd, 2019 at 12:48 PM

9/21/2019 – Michigan 14, Wisconsin 35 – 2-1, 0-1 Big Ten

The End of the Tour, a movie about Rolling Stone writer David Lipsky glomming on to David Foster Wallace at the end of his Infinite Jest book tour, is immediately good. The first sensory experience the movie gives you is the ultra-deep cut instrumental from REM's Automatic For the People:

This is a song with no oboes in it that sounds like nothing but oboes. It is weird, lilting, and mournful, a funeral for geese. The opening scene of the movie is Lipsky getting a call from someone trying to confirm a rumor that Wallace has committed suicide, because Lipsky once spent a few days on the road with him.

Wallace has. Lipsky goes through his tapes.

[After THE JUMP: marshmallows!]

The rest of the movie is a flashback to those few days on the road. Two highbrow white guys talk to each other about stuff. Mostly about how they are precarious and alone, the guy with the critic-melting novel and the other guy with a novel who also writes for Rolling Stone. Sometimes they bluff. The introduction of a woman, any woman, is cause for a tiff. Jason Segel, the guy who's inserted by default as Affable Stoner in every Judd Apatow movie, plays DFW.

I know, okay? I know. It sat in our Netflix queue for months, looming, more a threat than a promise. But you watch it for a bit and questions surface. Questions like:

  • How did this get made?
  • How is it good?
  • When will my wife stop watching it?

At press time answers were not available for any of these questions, and only the third has even the distant prospect of resolution. I played two seconds of "New Orleans Instrumental No. 1" to confirm it was indeed the song used and she popped her head out of the office. "Ooh," I project she thought.

But anyway because of your living situation this thing has been on a lot. And when you're a guy who writes about Michigan the aftermath-of-spirit-crushing defeat mine has been well and truly depleted. Do you want chipper ha-ha that was weird? Done. Talking people off the ledge? Done. Outright nihilism? Done. Columns about buying a mattress? Done.

So when it's time to write something about a game that Michigan spiritually lost 35-0 after being favored by a touchdown preseason the goose funeral music follows you around. It is my theory that I can get it to stop following me around by loosing it on you, the reader.

-----------------------

In the aftermath of Wallace's demise there are two great unfortunate things. The first is the relegation of Infinite Jest into the category of intellectual bro-novel that sites like The Toast use as a stand-in for a particular sort of bearded quasi-intellectual who is the seething insecurity the End of the Tour protagonists are enduring minus any offsets like having a face-melting novel or writing for Rolling Stone.

I dunno, I wasn't a woman on a train in Brooklyn in 2013. I'm sure if I'd been subject to hordes of slavering women trying to butter me up with copies of Beloved I'd be pretty negative about Beloved. But this would not make Beloved any less of a banger, as the kids say. IJ's status is increasingly as a punchline in an unfunny joke about the patriarchy of hipster dudebros, and that sucks.

This is painful to me for many reasons. Foremost amongst them is that it says a bunch of things I think everyone should take to heart about entertaining themselves to death. The title is literal: the book weaves back and forth in time and ends abruptly, seemingly unfinished. It was only after I'd gone back to the beginning to try to piece together some plot points that I realized I was re-reading the thing. It was a loop, a literally infinite jest.

The second unfortunate thing is the Hallmark-ization of Wallace's commencement speech to Kenyon College. Titled "This Is Water," it became a minor sensation and became the kind of small book you give to someone at a juncture when they are getting all the small books. The way the thing is discussed is the opposite of ASMR. Your skin crawls backwards into the primordial ooze:

This is Water by David Foster Wallace (Full Transcript and Audio)

David Foster Wallace‘s 2005 commencement speech to the graduating class at Kenyon College, is a timeless trove of wisdom — right up there with Hunter Thompson on finding your purpose and living a meaningful life.

I feel like I shouldn't have to explain this? But I have to anyway? Holy hopping death, following up "a timeless trove of wisdom" with a link to "Hunter Thompson," no S, on finding your purpose: both of these people murdered themselves and now I know why. It's you, FS dot blog. You did it. Give Thompson his S back.

Despite this, the Kenyon college speech is also good. Its key passage is Wallace envisioning a dreary trip to a mausoleum of a supermarket as part of another routinely long day. There are traffic and lines. This doesn't resonate with my personal experience of shopping, in which I take DRC to Busch's and people there recognize us and he attempts to push the cart at supersonic velocities while cleaning the place out of marshmallows. There one specific domain, however, in which the mental state he describes does apply:

… the traffic jams and crowded aisles and long checkout lines give me time to think, and if I don’t make a conscious decision about how to think and what to pay attention to, I’m gonna be pissed and miserable every time I have to shop. Because my natural default setting is the certainty that situations like this are really all about me. About MY hungriness and MY fatigue and MY desire to just get home, and it’s going to seem for all the world like everybody else is just in my way. And who are all these people in my way? And look at how repulsive most of them are, and how stupid and cow-like and dead-eyed and nonhuman they seem in the checkout line, or at how annoying and rude it is that people are talking loudly on cell phones in the middle of the line. And look at how deeply and personally unfair this is.

I can't tell you I'm any good at shaping my attention in this regard. Offseason projects to walk more and drink less have been drilled between the eyes just three games in. But if there is a way out it's probably through that door.

----------------------------

48778632052_30cc666141_k

[Patrick Barron]

The nice thing about a game like Saturday's is that you blaze through the Kubler-Ross stages in a half and are left at acceptance. (Maybe you're still in depression.) This is probably it for the foreseeable future. It's not what we hoped for when Michigan hired Jim Harbaugh and his astonishing track record.

Instead: this. Michigan's SP+ rankings under Harbaugh: 10, 6, 13, 10. Michigan's currently 26 and sinking like a brick. Prior to this year that's remarkably consistent in the face of some difficulties like not having any quarterbacks. It's not what it needs to be for Michigan to be a consistent challenger to Ohio State. It's good enough to make the idea of trying to hire someone else absurd. OSU just hired a short-term coordinator with no head coaching experience; all coach hires except Urban Meyer are crapshoots.

So this is it: pretty good, sabotaged by an instability inherent in the head coach. It is not Infinite Jest's Entertainment, so appealing as to be lethal. Maybe at some point we'll turn a game on and it'll be a nice time. If it's not, oh well. It's time to adapt to the temperature of the water.

BRIC-A-BRAC

is cancelled this week; UFR will address the actual game parts. To be perfectly frank I wasn't paying the usual level of attention.

Comments

Ecky Pting

September 24th, 2019 at 8:46 AM ^

I had the displeasure of exiting Camp-Randall Stadium on Saturday after witnessing the most thorough beat-down I'd ever seen in person in 40+ years of being a dedicated fan. It was a very disappointing experience and a rather rude awakening to the reality that is Team 140.

That said, I also had the displeasure of exiting "The Birthplace of Football" on October 4, 2014 and that experience was still - by a long shot - far more disappointing and disconcerting. Seeing Rutgers fans flood the field and tear down the goal posts said it all. Wisconsin fans did no such thing, because their victory wasn't such a big deal. Wisconsin was, and is, a 700-pound gorilla with a chainsaw for a penis and Michigan somehow never saw it coming. Jonathan Taylor is the best back I've seen since I watched Leonard Fournette carry a football at a track meet in the Carrier Dome at Syracuse in 2015.

Despite being rather hostile in the stadium - particularly following the two ejections for targeting - afterwards many of the fans were sympathetic toward the loss. One of the nice things about Madison is that while two pints in Der Stiftskellar in the Memorial Union will set you back $12.50, a pitcher is only $14.50. And so while waiting in the exceedingly long line, your thoughts eventually turn to selecting the beer with which to fill your pitcher. You strike up a conversion with the Sconnie in front of you who happens to be familiar with the offerings of the local breweries. He remarks his appreciation of the Bell's Two Hearted that's listed, and anything else brewed in Kalamazoo for that matter, but you eventually settle on New Glarus Spotted Cow, since he pointed out it's only available in Wisconsin and is highly recommended. You thank the guy for the recommendation and he thanks you for coming and tells you to enjoy the rest of your stay in Madison. Needless to say, the tables and floors were littered with empty pitchers.

CLord

September 24th, 2019 at 1:05 PM ^

All good.  Let's all remember Brian is not a machine, and what got him into doing this blog in the first place was a passion for Michigan.  Anyone with passion would struggle mightily to flip an objective switch to trudge through the misery that was Saturday.

Even getting through UFRs over the last 6 miserable games has been heroic imo.

Our program is enduring another failed attempt to "join them" after concluding it couldn't "beat them." 
First the Lloyd to the RR spread transition after the Horror and Oregon.
Now the Manball to whatever this is supposed to be transition after the Ohio State hamblasting last year.

My personal conclusion is that JH overestimated the D Brown defense after seeing it obliterated by OSU last year.  That led him to drive for changes on offense that have gone haywire, and to also not pay more attention to the inherent problems with the DBrown defense that have now been exploited repeatedly over 6 games.  As such, both offense and defense have suffered.  DBrown's schemes worked first couple of years, but are now thoroughly solved.  His schemes have also been found to crumble against good competition without top end DTs simply by applying focus on the DEs.

JH is clearly no messiah.  He is a great coach who runs a great program, just not an elite one.  He will get much of this straightened out, but hopes of holding on to that wins advantage over OSU before my life ends in likely 25-35 years are now mostly gone.

Mongo

September 24th, 2019 at 2:40 PM ^

We have personnel issues - we don't even have enough DTs to provide a true goal line stand ?  That picture above tells the whole dang story.  Where are the big-bodied freshman or the German who can at least plug that hole instead of a 220lb Glasgow.

Edit - That is a big time RPS miss.  Then we add Ben Mason as the  RB in read option spread ?  What are we doing ?

scottiek65

September 25th, 2019 at 4:10 PM ^

i was raised in the town of Niles (MI not IL) to a dad who graduated in 1961 and indoctrinated me into all things Michigan. We listened to Michigan games in the 70s on the radio in a time where M was not on TV every week. Maybe 2 or 3 games a year?  I bled Maize and Blue. in 76 i moved to LA as dads job transferred him west. We watched from afar. 

When Wisconsin happened to us Saturday I stared at the screen numbly. saying only to myself. FML.  Where to go from here?  When Jim Harbaugh was hired. i looked at his track record at Stanford ( they routinely beat USC!) and the 49ers ( they routinely went to the NFC championship games!)  Now i am in purgatory. 

i hated the Hoke hire, i loved the Rodriguez hire.  

Can we be wrong about Harbaugh? 

i honestly dont know.

these are college kids. sometimes your talent graduates or leaves early for the NFL and the kids who replace them are not as good. at least for a year. sometimes two.  

Shea Patterson was supposed to be our savior when he transferred. Clearly he is not.

the OL is troubling. it has not gotten good. not in 3 years? 4? i have lost track 

Preseason we heard from pundits Michigan is a top ten team. they are a playoff contender. ESPN's own FPI predicted based on their computer simulations said Michigan will go 12-0!  we thought then that Patterson would thrive under the new Gattis offense. The OL returned 4 starters or 5 and would be better!! the receivers are the best in the nation or in the top 5 in the nation! the defense was young but Don Brown is a great coach and the Defense would be stout.  We have Sparty Iowa Notre Dame and Ohio at home!  this is the national contender season! 

Patterson has not looked sharp or moved the team consisitently. The turnovers are a huge problem. The OL was a disaster vs their first really good opponent on the road. The DL looks small and ineffective vs Wisconsin. the LBs looked terrible vs Wisconsin. The receivers are not a huge factor. Charbonnet was great vs  middle Tennessee State and Army. but got hurt and was no factor in Madison. 

In the liveblog on game day Saturday we went from expecting a 11-1 or 10-2 season to 6-6 or 7-5. Games vs Ohio St, Notre Dame, Michigan State, look daunting. Iowa looks much much harder now. and the trip to Happy Valley to face the Nittany Lions looks almost as scary as the trip we just made. 

I dont expect a loss at home to Rutgers this weekend but can we actually finish 6-6?  I dont see a strength on this team yet. cept for maybe our punter as someone on the liveblog said.

my guess is to try Dylan McCaffery at QB i mean once he is properly healed from his concussion. Thank you dirty Wisconsin DB's!  hope Zach is healthy soon.

i dont know why our OL never gets good. we need a good OL 

Michigan was boring under Lloyd Carr but we could block on the OL and we could run the ball. Let us start somewhere.