Perspective on Don Brown Firing

Submitted by scfanblue on December 24th, 2020 at 4:50 PM

No doubt this signals that Harbaugh will be returning to Ann Arbor. Josh Gattis should also be going home for Christmas with Brown but it appears he may be retained. Does Brown leaving really change that much headed into next year? If Harbaugh is really committed to Michigan for the long haul then he has got to make this his most important hire since his arrival. Hire a PROVEN DC and not just a friend or a young co coordinator who has not performed on their own. I say hire Muschamp or Leavitt and let them recruit the hell out of SEC country and Ohio. They are both proven DC's. I also hope there is truth to the rumor that Jay Harbaugh is only going to coach special teams and that Jim is going to coach QB's personally again. I think Michigan should take their lumps with JJ McCarthy and stick with this kid as a starter next year as Joe and Cade are just not good enough to take Michigan to the next level. 

Broken Brilliance

December 24th, 2020 at 4:52 PM ^

I am skeptical of Leavitt's recruiting skills, can anyone convince me otherwise?

Edit: I just realized that I was confusing him with Jim Haslett, the old Saints coach who comes off like discount Jack Del Rio...off to learn more about Leavitt now.

Phaedrus

December 24th, 2020 at 10:26 PM ^

I could see him being a pretty terrible recruiter. "If you want to come play for me, you're going to have to accept the fact that you're unimportant."

I just could not picture him groveling to teenagers and inflating their egos. He almost never yells at his players. Instead, he's just sarcastic and mocks them for their failures. His players put up with it because they're paid millions and he's developed a reputation for being the best, but he would crush the spirit of college students.

username03

December 24th, 2020 at 5:05 PM ^

We managed to lose at least 3 games a year with the top 5 defenses Don Brown had here, I don't know what one expects the new DC to do to raise that ceiling.

kehnonymous

December 24th, 2020 at 5:12 PM ^

I mean yes I disagree with this take but not because of specifically Muschamp, as much as I'd prefer to pass on him.  There are any number of serviceable DC candidates out there, but exactly who isn't the most important thing.  The number one issue is that the players play not to lose and curl up into a shell vs anything with a pulse.  We seem to be more worried about not making game losing mistakes then we are about making game winning plays. That can be sourced to the playcalling philosophy, the culture and buy-in and all that shit is the primary responsibility of the *head* coach.

JacquesStrappe

December 24th, 2020 at 6:00 PM ^

This Is spot on. Brown didn't come up with great game plans against top notch competition but then again when has the offense ever bailed out the defense. It can be said that Brown's defenses preserved quite a few victories with little to no help from the offense. Perhaps that's why it always felt like the D was playing not to lose. Because they had no confidence that the offense would bail them out and decided not to take too many chances.

Until we have a culture change that facilitates playing aggressively and not stepping off the gas, I think we will see more self-conscious avoidance of trying to make game winning plays so as to also avoid making mistakes. The irony is that this very "conservative" philosophy is why we lose so many games in the first place. Understanding when and how to take risk is the hallmark of good game management.

DonAZ

December 24th, 2020 at 6:23 PM ^

I read it as the "conservative" nature was on the offensive side of the ball.

There's truth in that.  The offense had some spark in the second half of 2015, and into 2016, but it's not really been much to write home about since.  Had Harbaugh been able to maintain the 2016 offensive pace into 2017 - 2020, we'd be having a totally different conversation right now.

JacquesStrappe

December 24th, 2020 at 9:10 PM ^

I guess the best way to say it is that we always play like we are walking on eggshells, not that the calls are necessarily conservative. Too much thinking instead of just going hard and playing. Thr defensive play calls were not conservative given the high proportion of blitzes, but, you would think that with such an aggressive scheme our defenders would be bigger ball hawks intent on directly affecting the outcome of the game with a big play at a critical juncture. But mostly it seemed like they were content to dominate downs 1 and 2 while 3rd down looked discombobulated with too much of a rush to keep plays in front of them and not enough of a rush to to cause a momentum-changing havoc play like OSU and the SEC teams frequently exhibit.

You can see it in our net turnover margin ranking and our defensive scores frequency. You can even see it in what our defenders did on the rare occasions that they cause a turnover. Our first impulse is to fall on the ball and secure it. Other teams try to advance it as far as possible. 

I don't think that this is intentional. However, I believe that subconsciously Michigan's guys have that slight hesitance, the impulse to stand on the brakes for fear that something bad is likely to happen and not to get too greedy.

Actually, this isn't so terrible. It's smart. It just is not indicative of a team that really believes in itself and has that intangible swagger that the best programs have that seems to shout that they know deep down that victory is inevitable.

Other great programs seem to have a much deeper-seated sense of confidence. This is why we can't seem to win as underdogs and why every Michigan coach from Bo until now has had pretty abysmal records as underdogs and in bowls. I believe that our less-than-dynamic and mistake-prone offenses over the years feeds that fear-of-failure pathology. 

Mich04-08

December 24th, 2020 at 5:24 PM ^

Don Brown = Scapegoat to cover up Harbaugh's failure on offense for 6 years.

I agree with these guys:

https://wolverineswire.usatoday.com/2020/12/24/rivals-fact-or-fiction-michigan-football-don-brown-defense-problems/

If Brown should be fired for his defensive failures over 2 years, then the "QB Whisperer" should be fired for his QB and overall offensive failures for 6 years. 10 win seasons beating up on unranked teams and losing to ranked teams does not impress.

NYC Fan3

December 24th, 2020 at 5:32 PM ^

100% this.  Jim is supposed to be the QB whisperer, but our offense continues to get worse. 

Jim could hire Venables from Clemson as our DC and I still wouldn’t want Jim as the head coach.  

He needs to go as we need him as far away from our offensive players as possible.  His low risk philosophy is not a fit with modern day college football.