OT- Tigers / Game 2

Submitted by MGoPietrowski on
I have the day off.
I have an 18 pack of Bud Light.
And I have MLB.TV

Living the dream, kids.

Top 1st

Lets go Tigers!

rob f

April 3rd, 2013 at 7:12 PM ^

Dozier punches a soft line single to right-center, then a long fly by Escobar falls between Dirks and Jackson and game over, Tigers lose.

umchicago

April 3rd, 2013 at 7:17 PM ^

you managed the bullpen assbackwards.  he had benoit face lefties like mauer and morneau (luckily no damage) in the eighth.  Then he has coke face two righties in the ninth and loses.  coke should have pitched the eighth and benoit or dotel the ninth.  this one is on leyland.

WMUgoblue

April 3rd, 2013 at 7:19 PM ^

Benoit has the best numbers of any Tigers pitcher against the M&M boys. And Coke should be able to get Dozier and Escobar out, those 2 are Triple A players. It's one game, on fairness Valverde blew a Dave in the opener last year.

umchicago

April 3rd, 2013 at 7:48 PM ^

righties hit almost .400 off coke last year and well over .300 the year before.  he's had decent success against lefties the past two years .260ish and .210ish.

meanwhile lefties hit marginally better of benoit than righties the past two years combined.  and righties have his under .200 off dotel the past two years.

bullpen by committee means making the right decisions concerning matchups.

WMUgoblue

April 3rd, 2013 at 7:58 PM ^

Where was this complaining on Monday? These were basically the same exact matchups that we faced on Monday, and Benoit did fine against the lefties(both games) keep in the mind the guy he walked in the 9th was a righty in Plouffe. Yes Coke was awful in the regular season against righties but he was tremendous in the postseason against both sides of the plate. Leyland played the matchups fine, you might have a point in using Dotel but that's all hindsight now yes? Like I said Dozier and Escobar are triple A players, Phil needs to do his job. If you're complaining today then why weren't you complaining Monday I guess is my overall point.

umchicago

April 3rd, 2013 at 8:25 PM ^

uh, coke came in to face morneau and doumit to end the game monday after benoit pitched to willingham (a righty).  yes, coke had a very good 10 IP in the post season last year.  but i place much more emphasis on the 200+ IP he's had in relief over his career.

leyland actually played the matchups correctly on monday.  he failed today.

jcouz

April 3rd, 2013 at 7:22 PM ^

I can't really watch the Tigers on a daily basis to follow the day-to-day managerial decisions having to do with the batting line-up and bullpen matchups with Leyland.  He pisses me off so often that, with baseball, there are too many games for me to get emotionally worked up over his decisions.  I will follow all season but not by watching every game closely.  I just can't manage the daily ups-and-downs anymore.

BlueInWisconsin

April 3rd, 2013 at 8:02 PM ^

I have a great idea! Let's spend a zillion dollars on our roster but see what happens if we don't have a closer!

I know it's only the second game, and I assume they have a plan, but good grief!!!

JamieH

April 4th, 2013 at 12:12 AM ^

I guess I have to question why Coke would EVER be the choice to close.  He seems like the worst relief pitcher the TIgers have.  Last year righties hit almost .400 against him.  Batters overall hit .324 with an OBP of .375.  How is that closer material?  That's closer to AAA than closer IMO. 

If you won't pony up to go get a closer, why are you running out a guy who has proven than he can't get anyone out?  I get that he had a minimal amount of success in an emergency role during the postseason last year.  But the guy has NEVER been anything close to lights out. 

If we're just going to throw out guys who have never closed, why not Alburquerque?  He's been dominant in the short amount of time that he's been healthy for the Tigers.  That's more dominance than Coke has had in his entire career.  I know he's a bit wild and that is a problem, but no more of a problem than the fact that Coke throws batting practice.