Where users could privately chat with each other would be cool. If not a live chat, then maybe a private message box. I'm not sure how feasible it would be, but it would be cool. If there was an easy way to see how many times a user has posted, created a diary, and created a thread, that would be nice. If you could see the average score of a user's posts, it could give some indication of how respected a user is. Honestly, nothing on this site is that bad. I like the layout and utility of this site much better than Rivals or ESPN.
Peppers at 10, which seems low.