Elvis Lives

February 22nd, 2014 at 9:24 PM ^

I just can't see Heitzman being used as a tight end outside of a goal line situation. Even when he was a d-lineman, I thought he would be a better run stopper than a quick reaction-type player. But if Craig Roh can go from 230 to 280 in 4 years, let's see if Heitz can prove me wrong.

m1jjb00

February 22nd, 2014 at 10:11 PM ^

And I don't feel entitled to information.  But, I mostly ignore what's said about injuries unless Brady says someone won't play.  In Butt's case, I now believe that there is some unspecified chance, greater than zero, but otherwise unknown that he plays early in the season.

I dumped the Dope

February 22nd, 2014 at 10:12 PM ^

I like the info but consider the deeper story here.  If Heitzmann works out (meaning positive contributor on offense, able to hold the depth chart, etc) then my couch coach vote is to redshirt Butt and let him get the full opportunity to rehab.

Jake Ryan did an impressive job of getting back on the field in record time, but IMHO he picked up steam with each game.  So it wasn't like he was making an immediate difference when he got back.  In Ryan's case obviously a redshirt wasn't an option so it made sense to get him back.

So the conundrum would then seemingly be, Butt seems like a nice route runner able to get open against LBs regularly, hence an extra receiver.  However a little lighter than we might like on run blocking.  Heitzmann would seem to have the strength and mass part nailed down, the questionmark being his ability to get open as a receiver....or maybe Nuss uses a TE sort of like a FB catching a pass....its a receiver you sorta forgot to cover since they rarely catch passes and thus rarely need any downfield coverage.

Overall its very positive to have the depth to be able to do this!  Hope Taco can hold down a slot on the Dline with regularity, as someone else stated, he's an NFL body waiting for a player to fill it out... 8-)

Reader71

February 23rd, 2014 at 12:37 PM ^

This isn't a video game where you can just click A to red shirt a guy. If Butt comes back strong through the grueling rehab process and is ready to play, he won't want to red shirt. Every day, he will bust his ass in an effort to get on the field as soon as possible. If you tell him he is redshirting, his motivation will be lacking during rehab. If you don't tell him, and just not play him after he gets healthy, he will have a problem. He only redshirts if his rehab doesn't go well and he can't get back in time for any significant portion of the season

93Grad

February 23rd, 2014 at 9:52 AM ^

All position changes are good! Actually I've been advocating this move for awhile. More depth on DL and Heitz never stood out to me on D

getsome

February 23rd, 2014 at 1:47 PM ^

smart move.  been hoping theyd move someone like heitzman or beyer to TE for blocking purposes and addl depth if nothing else.  hed just be another guy on DL, buried on depth chart and unlikely to make many impact plays and even if hes just another guy at TE, they need the depth there much more than DE.  heitzman had close to 12 months to prove he could impact the game at DE and did not really produce....they need athletic difference makers on the edge and while the younger guys on the chart may not ultimately provide that impact, i think its safe to say heitzman likely would not have either.  so looks like smart move.  hopefully he can offer some stout blocking at LOS and maybe few catches