Unverified Voracity Bids Brown Adieu Comment Count

Brian

image

Sponsor thanks. You may have noticed the banner on the left side from Park and Party, which is a local startup that organizes gameday parking. You can reserve a favorite spot, which allows you to get up after 5 AM without ceding your precious swath of green space. Hit their Purdue parking availability to reduce the number of things that can go wrong on gameday.

BONUS: checking them out also opens your Beveled Guilt valve.

Hardly knew ye. Freshman CB Greg Brown has left the football team. Brown was the first commitment of the 2011 class and enrolled early but evidently fell behind Countess and Taylor; with Rodriguez and Tony Gibson no longer on campus he may have felt he was never going to get playing time.

Michigan isn't likely to feel much impact from Brown's departure; they still have the aforementioned freshmen plus Tamani Carter and Delonte Hollowell and are bringing in a couple of corners this year. Best of luck wherever he goes (obviously Pitt).

By my count that brings Michigan up to 25 scholarships in this class. With three players set to enroll early and a couple guys not likely to return for fifth years, they may already be able to take this class to 28. If they aren't, they almost certainly will be by February. With Jeremy Clark losing his grayshirt that leaves Michigan with five slots for two WRs, another OL, a RB, and a wildcard who may or may not be CB Yuri Wright.

In another world. Wolverine Historian has posted a video of the '89 Purdue game that is derived from press box video sans announcers:

As a result there's a bunch of sideline stuff you wouldn't see in a normal game: band jumping around, cheerleaders doing different cheerleader stuff, etc. Also plenty of triple option.

Side note: man, the skill guys in that game. Hoard, Boles, Howard, Alexander, Calloway. Not bad.

Vintage picture pages. MVictors has a shot of the Detroit Times explaining some Mad Magicianry against Pitt:

pitt1947_thumb[1]

Why did newspapers stop doing this? The analysis isn't amazing but surely 60 years later someone at a newspaper should be able to explain an inside zone. (BONUS: there is now a "1947 pitt" tag.)

The Baconing. An excerpt from Three and Out hits the Detroit News, this one about the coaching search. The first one. Prepare your sailboats:

About a week after Carr's announcement, Martin told his hand-picked search committee that Tony Dungy was his favorite candidate. Dungy had played high school football for Jackson Parkside, a half hour from Ann Arbor, but turned down Bo Schembechler to play for Minnesota. His Indianapolis Colts had just won the 2007 Super Bowl the previous winter. Exactly why Martin thought Dungy might be interested in Michigan, however, is a mystery.

The committee then briefly discussed Brian Kelly, who had just finished the 2007 regular season at Cincinnati 9-3 while graduating 75 percent of his players. But Kelly had a well-earned reputation for being unpleasant — even basketball coaches had strong opinions about him — and Martin made it clear he was not a serious candidate.

What was most striking about that first meeting, however, was the number of candidates they barely discussed, if at all: Mike DeBord, Ron English, Jeff Tedford, Rich Rodriguez, and even Les Miles, the committee's first choice. "Bill didn't want him," recalls Ted Spencer, the director of admissions and a committee member. "I have no idea why. He never gave us a reason."

Four years ago Dungy was 52 and therefore plausible if he actually wanted to keep coaching, but he didn't and Bill Martin didn't know this. The guy's a broadcaster and everyone in the world expects Carr to go out with Henne/Hart/etc. Call him?

There's much more at the link. It basically confirms the conventional wisdom that the coaching search was a fiasco run without much of a plan. Strange compared to the Beilein hiring, which had a bunch of plausible candidates and secured its first public option instead of getting turned down by the guy at Rutgers.

Former AnnArbor.com sports guy Jeff Arnold has a review-type substance* at Yahoo that contains one of many WTF moments in regard to the absent Lloyd Carr:

It is Carr who calls Rodriguez to gauge his interest in becoming the Michigan coach. And that call takes place only hours after the conference call with Miles. "Even if you haven't thought about it," Bacon reports Carr saying, "you should think about it now."

Readers are left to infer that Carr had a big role in picking Rodriguez, who took the job days later without setting foot on the campus. But then Carr, whose strong objections to Miles are documented early in the book, holds a team meeting after Rodriguez is introduced as the Wolverines' new coach, informing players he will sign their transfer papers if they want to leave.

Things go downhill from there.

*[Which oddly suggests that Robinson wouldn't have made it as a QB in Bo's offense. Moeller or Carr, sure, but Bo ran the option. He would have installed Robinson at quarterback ten seconds after he arrived on campus and threatened to deport anyone who suggested he move.]

No reason. Facepalm guy thread gem:

6141105800_1700e01759[1]

That is a long torso.

Phew. People are reporting that Jon Merrill is going to stick it out:

@HockeyProspect: FWIW, been told that Jon Merrill is staying at U of M and will not be signing with Plymouth. #Michigan #NCAA #OHL

That comes from the junior side of the aisle so is likely sourced from Plymouth. That is likely to be solid.

In less good hockey news, Shawn Hunwick got ejected from Michigan's game against NMU and his replacement let in a number of softies en route to a loss; the next night Michigan could only manage a tie. (They did win the shootout. That only applies to CCHA standings. For NCAA purposes it's a tie.) Their (wholly ridiculous) time at #1 has come to an end.

The Oversigning Bowl. On the podcast last week I mentioned that if I was athletic director* Michigan would not have signed up to play Alabama at any juncture because it's stupid to take a knife to an oversigning fight. With the LSU-Bama game of the year already in hype mode (both teams have this week off), Ramzy states the obvious:

The storyline that probably won't make it anywhere near the national discussion is that Saban and Miles each play the recruiting game with a stacked deck: For every four players that almost every other program in the country admits to school, Alabama and LSU each take in five.

While it won't happen, the discussion of oversigning should be one of the storylines for this particular game. LSU and Alabama should be ranked at or near the top of the polls, and every year - not just in 2011.

Both programs have top-tier head coaches and both schools - unlike the one in Columbus - are at or above the Southeastern Conference's pay grade for proven assistant coaches and coordinators. Baton Rouge and Tuscaloosa are practically required to be on every elite high school recruit's list of possibilities.

But what ensures that LSU and Alabama should be among the elite of the elite is that both have installed a system that gives them significantly less recruiting risk than most of their competitors in recruiting.

Oversigning recruits every year has given both schools built-in second and third-chances where talent acquisition is concerned. They get refunds on their bad bets, and their depth charts are proof that it works.

It's stupid to play a team that gets to look at 25% more players than you do over the course of a recruiting cycle. If you have to in a bowl game you have to but if I'm looking for an opponent it's not going to be one with an inbuilt advantage due to skeeziness. That goes double when you're coming off the attrition/recruiting problems Rodriguez left Michigan.

*[hoo boy, that's an alternate universe right there.]

Etc.: Create your own periodic-table-themed Denard Robinson tshirt.

Comments

JL

October 24th, 2011 at 9:03 PM ^

Brian, can you write a post ( or series of posts) of what you would do if you were AD? It would be fun to read when we're grasping for straws in the slow parts of the offseason.

JudgeMart

October 24th, 2011 at 9:22 PM ^

In my mind, Bill Martin is the biggest culprit as to who is most responsible for the bungled coaching search. Coach Carr had stated at the end of the 2006 regular season that he wanted to retire, and Martin basically had to talk him into coming back for one more season. So Martin had at least a year to conduct a thorough and credible coaching search; instead we got the kindergarten level search as outlined in the book.

Go Blue Eyes

October 24th, 2011 at 10:50 PM ^

If Carr wanted to retire in 2006 that, to me, would have been a much more ideal time to bring in a new coach. That new coach would come in knowing that he had some highly talented players coming back and could have started the recruiting process much sooner. More and more I believe Martin is going to look pretty bad but, hey, there's always the Bill Martin Concourse!

jaws4141

October 25th, 2011 at 8:43 AM ^

The last time I checked over signing is within the NCAA rule books.  Alabama and LSU aren't the only two schools that do this.  If it's such a bad thing then why doesn't the NCAA make it illegal?  Scott Van Pelt said people shouldn't criticize Saban for over signing, but instead the NCAA should be criticized.  The NCAA is basically the presidents of all the universities.  Mary Sue Coleman is more responsible for over signing than Nick Saban or Les Miles.  If the presidents at all the major universities wanted over signing banned then it would be.  Just like the BCS.  The presidents of the universities are responsible for the current BCS structure and don't want a playoff.  Football coaches at major programs are always looking for an edge.  If it's legal then I don't blame them.  It's their right to use whatever tactics they want as long as it's legal.  If a particular coach doesn't like over signing then he doesn't have to do it.  It's no different than lawyers.  Lawyers conduct smear campaigns against good people all the time.  They'll do whatever it takes to help their client.  Defense lawyers and divorce lawyers are the devil compared to over signing.  Hoke should over sign and I hope he does.

 

Blue Durham

October 25th, 2011 at 10:38 AM ^

loaded 1989 team Vada Murray Greg Skrepnak - one of the biggest linemen we have had Tripp Wellborne - one of the best safeties I have ever seen at Michigan Mallory - can't tell which one though (I think Mike) J.D. Carlson (K) - 13/14 in FGs that year (still the M record in %). BACK WHEN WE HAZ KICKERZ! Eric Anderson (LB) - yeah, we had pretty good linebackers back then too.

bronxblue

October 25th, 2011 at 10:46 AM ^

Regarding the oversigning bowl, I agree that it is a competitive disadvantage to play those teams in a non-bowl situation, but at the same time teams need to adapt and find ways to compete. People always complain about the Yankees and Red Sox dominating baseball because of their payrolls (where they can make mistakes and just buy better players), but they've won, what, 3 titles since 2000 (and those last 90's Yankee teams were actually constructed from the farm system). The same should apply here. Yes, LSU and Alabama oversign, but so does Ole Miss and Miss. St., ad both of them are pretty bleh. So clearly just having more guys doesn't immediately give you an advantage against all teams. UM is a top destination and as strong a school in CFB as there is; they should be able to recruit at or near the level of Alabama and LSU regardless of who else they take, and should be competitive regardless. And as we've always seen, teams that break small rules rarely stop there; I fully expect most of the SEC to be caught in various scandals as media and watchdog groups have greater access (and incentive) to take swings at them. I guess the long and short of it is that UM should be wary of playing big-name teams, but they still need to play them; that is the "burden" of being a prominent team. Teams like Alabama and LSU will have good talent regardless of oversigning (they are a legit team, plus we all know about the various infractions and hostess-related activities throughout the years), and so UM should be willing to play them and at least compete.

M-Wolverine

October 25th, 2011 at 6:37 PM ^

He would have been a legit candidate. He was highly thought of by more than Martin, and would have probably kept a lot of the staff to transition to the college game.

ManuelP

October 26th, 2011 at 11:56 AM ^

This sounds like a great little business that may just be the wave of the future. I think that parking companies like this will do rather well at sporting events and other events where tons of people gather.

It is never a good idea while at an online casino to play slot machine bonus rounds while drinking because you will probably bet more than what you really want.