Bordeleau went early second [James Coller]

Let's Talk About Some NHL Drafts Comment Count

Brian October 8th, 2020 at 2:07 PM

HEY FOLKS. Our Mr. Spots t-shirt fundraiser closes tonight. Support a local institution and purchase one. 

The 2020 NHL draft has come and gone, spurring takes both about this year and, inevitably, the 2021 draft. Let's survey the results and projections.

2020

Michigan players and commits who went in the recently completed NHL draft:

Bonus: 18 minute scouting video by a guy with an outrageous French accent

Brendan Brisson: #29 overall, Las Vegas. Vegas's GM is Kelly McCrimmon, who played for Red in the 1980s. (Apparently back then you could play in major junior and then go to college. Weird.) Hopefully that means the Knights will be inclined to leave him in college for a while.

There were a few rankings that had Brisson about ten spots in front of where he actually went. Scott Wheeler of the Athletic had him #35 but still thought that he was a good pick for Vegas. From his lips to Michigan Hockey Summer's ears:

My big worry with Brisson has less to do with his talent and more to do with his timeline. He’s an excellent shooter, both from a standstill through his one-timer and wrister but also in motion through his snapshot. He was the best player on the USHL’s best team, playing the style the Steel are built for: crafty, careful, poised. But I think it could take him three or four years to find that next level against bigger, stronger competition in college — and eventually in pro. I don’t think his talent grades out so highly that he’s the one-and-done type at Michigan.

That would be amazing. One asset Michigan has: Brisson's agent isn't worried he'll sign with someone else if he stays in college, because it'll be his dad.

[After the JUMP: third round alpaca out of nowhere]

Thomas Bordeleau: #38 overall, San Jose. Everyone said early second round for Bordeleau and that's where he went. Wheeler has an extensive profile of him that went up yesterday. Bordeleau is an odd duck because most of his early development happened in Switzerland:

“(Switzerland is) doing a really good job with development. They’ve got something good going on there with forcing kids at a young age to play small area games all the time. There was never any full ice games, we always had tournaments where there were two games going on at the same time on the same ice. I think it helped me a lot for my hockey IQ and my visual skills,” Bordeleau said. “It was a different way of learning the game. Just growing up and learning how to find sweet spots on the ice, learning young how to do give and gos to get open into smaller areas, I think it really helped me. I’m really, really grateful for the way they taught me how to play. I still have a lot of that in me.”

Fohr quickly noticed that Bordeleau takes faceoffs differently than is typically taught in North America, too. Sébastien, who was known as a faceoff specialist in his time in the NHL, taught his son how to take draws with both hands.

“(Bordeleau) was our best faceoff guy hands down,” Fohr said. “He actually flips his stick over to the opposite side and pulls both sides of draws back like he’s on his strong side. You don’t see that very often. He’s a lefty but he’ll take faceoffs as a righty and pull it straight back.”

Michigan plans to keep him at center and put him on a power play. As a result of the profile Wheeler says he "love[s]" the Sharks picking him at the spot he did since he "became the clear driver of the NTDP’s offence over the last two seasons."

Also here's an unusual take:

To date I haven't seen any other takes talking up Bordeleau's two-way game as a prime asset. Wheeler's profile has quotes from NTDP coaches noting that he had no interest in that side of the game upon arrival but improved a lot. Meanwhile Peca won the Selke award twice and operated as a second or third line defensive ace for much of his career.

Jackson Hallum: #91 overall, Las Vegas. Hallum was a deep sleeper unranked by the CSB and the super in-depth guys who have top 200 lists, and he went in the third round. This was a test of how draftnik you are. McKeen's: failed.

Steve Kournianos: passed.

Hallum is currently scheduled to come in for 2022 after two years in the USHL. I wouldn't be surprised if he gets bumped up due to attrition or if Adam Fantilli decides to take another route.

Hallum was the only real surprise of the draft from a Michigan perspective. Everyone else went more or less where they were projected to. I was not even aware that Hallum was eligible for this draft (failed), because no one had said word one about him.

Ethan Edwards: #120 overall, New Jersey. The Devils' SB Nation site has a comprehensive collection of everything said about Edwards. Wheeler gave the Devils a thumbs up:

Edwards is one of the best skaters on his edges in the draft, plays one of the more aggressive gaps in the draft, and uses his feet to open up lanes for himself in the offensive zone.

His production wasn't great this year but it sounds like that might be puck luck. Scouting on him is really positive:

Fair chance that he has a breakout USHL season and makes that draft slot look like a steal.

Edwards was on the ice with the Sioux City Musketeers when he found out, and got mobbed in the locker room:

He'll play in the USHL next year and come in for 2021.

Jacob Truscott: #144 overall, Vancouver. Vancouver's pick also drew praise from Wheeler:

I really liked the Jacob Truscott pick in Round 5. I think he has a stronger case as a potential depth piece than some of the other NTDP kids who went ahead of him. He could become a smart, two-way defender at the next level but Truscott has always been a victim of a skillset that lacks a dynamic quality.

A guy without a major standout quality that still gets drafted in the fifth round is likely to be a long-term productive collegian.

The departed. For what it's worth, Michigan decommits Cole Perfetti (#10 overall) and Antonio Stranges (4th round) got drafted. Both used Michigan as a placeholder in an effort to manipulate the OHL draft. Perfetti was unsuccessful; Stranges did manage to direct himself to London in the second round. No other former commits got drafted. In the course of checking on this I discovered that Andrei Bakanov is back in Russia playing in the KHL, which is probably a first.

2021

This was set to be the Michigan draft even before they managed to flip Matt Beniers away from a Harvard commit at the last second. Now it is absurd. Corey Pronman's 2021 preview has Michigan recruits/players at #2, 3, 5, 8, and 17 overall:

  • #2 Owen Power, D: dubbed the "main challenger" to Aatu Raty for #1 overall(!), which would be the first time in program history that a Michigan player went first overall. (Jack Johnson, who went third, has the record for highest Michigan draft selection.)
  • #3 Kent Johnson, C: "elite stick skills and offensive IQ … fantastic passer … average skater … dynamo with the puck on his stick."
  • #5 Matthew Beniers, C: "elite competitiveness … highly intelligent offensive player who makes a lot of plays in the middle third of the ice."
  • #8 Luke Hughes, D: "Hughes family skating ability … skilled puck-mover … may not have the truly game-breaking ability of his brothers … great feet and size combination"
  • #17 Mackie Samoskevich, F: "doesn’t have great size at just around 5-foot-10, but he has everything else …great skater with great hands"

The first three of those guys are already on the team. In addition, Dylan Duke has gotten some attention as a potential first-rounder and is likely just outside Pronman's top 35, and Michigan has a solid shot at grabbing Adam Fantilli, the odds-on favorite to go first overall in 2023.

Further down the road, Michigan has three of the top ten 2004 birthdate players in North American—ie, including CHL kids—and Fantilli would be a fourth.

This is Kentucky basketball stuff.

Comments

lhglrkwg

October 8th, 2020 at 2:40 PM ^

Ok wow. I love the team but barely keep on recruits until they're in Ann Arbor. I didn't realize all those top flight 2021 guys were here already - I was thinking they were all freshmen for 21-22. Mel's killing it out there

Alton

October 8th, 2020 at 4:40 PM ^

From the article:  "Vegas's GM is Kelly McCrimmon, who played for Red in the 1980s."

Kelly McCrimmon did not play for Red, he played all four of his years at Michigan for John Giordano.

JonnyHintz

October 8th, 2020 at 9:14 PM ^

This really highlights why patience was needed with Mel. Lots of fans were souring on him with some subpar results, but the amount of talent he was amassing in these upcoming classes is absolutely insane. 
 

It takes a few years in hockey to get “your guys” into the program, and we’re finally starting to see the first of Mel’s guys instead of relying on the tail end of Red’s guys, where top end recruits were reluctant to sign on to play for a coach on the brink of retirement. 

lhglrkwg

October 9th, 2020 at 6:18 AM ^

Yeah I don't know how many of those being frustrated were people who actually follow the team closely. Anyone familiar with college hockey recruiting knows these guys often commit at 13, 14, and 15 years old so Mel was obviously gonna need a few years to catch up. These are probably his first 'real' classes where he's been able to recruit these guys early rather than play catch up late in the recruiting cycle

JonnyHintz

October 9th, 2020 at 9:21 AM ^

That’s kinda the problem with hockey fans, and a lot of the college sports in general. The most vocal detractors tend to be people who either don’t follow closely enough and just see results, or have no idea what the process even is.

Its easy to sit there and understand the sport in general, but you really have to understand the entire process to gauge a coaching staff and what they bring to the program. Michigan was in for a tough couple of seasons, no matter who the coach was, simply because Red had a tough time getting recruits in his final years. As you mentioned, Mel was left to supplement kids Red had committed with some lower level kids that weren’t already committed to top programs.
 

You’ll always be able to bring in a Hughes, York or Beecher here and there simply because of the status of the program and the fact that they’re only here for a year or two. But Michigan was severely lacking in the upperclassmen talent that sticks it out for 3-4 years. Now we’re at a point where we have 6 guys currently on the roster who either went in the first round in their respective drafts or are projected to next year. With a handful of guys who went in rounds 2-5. The talent difference between what we have now, and what we saw in the last 3-4 years is huge. 

Packer487

October 9th, 2020 at 1:35 PM ^

What pissed me off about the folks ripping him early last year was that Mel MADE THE FROZEN FOUR IN HIS FIRST YEAR! The second year was disappointing but they had injuries. You'd think the start they had year 1 would have bought a little time before the keyboard warriors went to town but....

Ah well, he's got em humming now on the recruiting trail, and it sure looked like they were being coached up too.

Frank Chuck

October 9th, 2020 at 1:17 AM ^

Mel is bringing in absurd level of talent to Michigan Hockey. (It feels like the classes Alabama or Ohio State brings into their football programs.)

It's time to win that elusive 10th National Championship.

We have an elite goalie. We have elite talent plus experienced depth. We have a quality coaching staff.

Just need some (puck) luck and we've got a great shot.