200 Days: Rich Rod vs. Hoke
xkcd / Hoke pointing at xkcd / EDIT: which means you should click on it dammit so you will get the point!
This morning His Dudeness posted a throwaway discussion topic for the board comparing Rodriguez's 2009 recruiting to Hoke's 2012. This was taken by some as an attempt to reopen 2008-'10 wounds but really it's another "how many ways can we talk about how awesome our 2012 recruiting is going?" (So so awesome). Anyway this started as a reply to fisk of that thread and ended up at 2,000 words plus charts. Hi, I'm Misopogon, have we met?
It's been almost 200 days since Hoke took the job. That's not much to go on when trying to judge a coach. Basically there's 1) his previous resume, 2) the process of how he was hired, 3) how he built his staff, 4) how he integrates into the program, and then 5) a few months of recruiting. I literally wrote up the first four then figured what the hell would we want to go over that again, so let's skip right to recruiting.
Finishing the Class of…
Rodriguez additions to Class of '08:
Name | Pos | State | Stars | RR | Pos Rk | Nat Rk | State Rk | Rec'd By |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Michael Shaw | RB | OH | 4 stars | 5.9 | 7 | NR | 6 | |
Taylor Hill | LB | OH | 4 stars | 5.8 | 21 | NR | 16 | |
Terrence Robinson | RB | TX | 4 stars | 5.8 | 9 | NR | 34 | |
Ricky Barnum | OL | FL | 4 stars | 5.8 | 5 | NR | 37 | |
Roy Roundtree | WR | OH | 4 stars | 5.8 | 44 | NR | 17 | Bruce Tall |
Justin Feagin | ATH | FL | 3 stars | 5.7 | 41 | NR | 71 | |
Martavious Odoms | WR | FL | 3 stars | 5.7 | 71 | NR | 77 | Rod Smith |
Patrick Omameh | DE | OH | 2 stars | 5.1 | NR | NR | NR | Bruce Tall |
Hoke additions to Class of '11:
Name | Pos | State | Stars | RR | Pos Rk | Nat Rk | State Rk | Rec'd By |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chris Barnett | TE | TX | 4 stars | 5.8 | 14 | NR | 32 | Jeff Hecklinski |
Raymon Taylor | ATH | MI | 4 stars | 5.8 | 14 | NR | 6 | |
Antonio Poole | LB | OH | 3 stars | 5.7 | 26 | NR | 20 | Mark Smith |
Frank Clark | LB | OH | 3 stars | 5.6 | NR | NR | 52 | |
Thomas Rawls | RB | MI | 3 stars | 5.6 | NR | NR | 19 | Fred Jackson |
Russell Bellomy | QB | TX | 3 stars | 5.5 | NR | NR | NR | |
Tamani Carter | DB | OH | 3 stars | 5.5 | NR | NR | 60 | Mark Smith |
Keith Heitzman | DE | OH | 3 stars | 5.5 | NR | NR | NR | Greg Mattison, Mark Smith |
Matt Wile | K | CA | 2 stars | 5.3 | NR | NR | NR |
This is unfair to judge the coaches against each other. Rodriguez was hired in November and was taking over a Citrus-bound program with a retiring Hall of Fame coach, while Hoke was hired in the middle of January after a blowout Gator loss and following a fired guy. Rodriguez had less time than would have been optimal given the breadth of his transition, but it was no more of a transition than Hoke faces, and RR got a good two months, including the all-important December period, to bring the current class home.
The recruiting is reflected in that. Other than bringing Hill from W.Va., Rodriguez mostly grabbed guys to fit his offensive system. Shaw's a speed-back, T-Rob, Roundtree and Odoms were slot receivers, Barnum and Omameh were the kind of agile offensive linemen who fit best in zone blocking, and Feagin was a last-minute consolation prize when Pryor decided he'd get more out of attending Ohio State. Hoke on the other hand found a handful of Michigan and Ohio State Sad Joshes (Clark, Carter, Heitzman, Rawls, Poole, Bellomy and Taylor), at positions of great need, replaced the kicker lost in the transition, yanked the requisite Purdue recruit (Bellomy) to ensure Danny Hope stays petty, and pulled in a last-minute coup on a national tight end.
Both did okay, not fantastic. Hoke got a kicker back, which was a big deal, but needed to flip someone's 5.9+ OT and pick up another good-to-great linebacker to avoid scary depths at that positions starting in 2012; RR's failure to get more help at defensive back (Carr had Brandon Smith, J.T. Floyd, and Cissoko) would haunt him the rest of his Michigan career (nobody planned on losing 2/4 LBs by next summer). Oh, and, ahem, quarterback.
Recruiting the Class of…
Rodriguez 2009 recruits as of July 26, 2008:
Name | Pos | State | Stars | RR | Commit'd | Pos | Nat | State | Rec'd By: |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
William Campbell | DT | MI | 5 stars | 6.1 | Oct. 2007 | 5 | 26 | 1 | (Carr's staff) |
Justin Turner | DB | OH | 4 stars | 6.0 | Mar 28 | 3 | 35 | 1 | Bruce Tall |
Bryce McNeal | WR | MN | 4 stars | 6.0 | May 1 | 10 | 75 | 1 | Tony Dews |
Kevin Newsome | QB | VA | 4 stars | 5.9 | Apr 24 | 4 | 163 | 9 | Fred Jackson |
Jeremy Gallon | ATH | FL | 4 stars | 5.9 | Jun 05 | 11 | NR | 31 | Rod Smith |
DeQuinta Jones | DT | LA | 4 stars | 5.8 | Jul 21 | NR | NR | 10 | Jay Hopson |
Shavodrick Beaver | QB | TX | 4 stars | 5.8 | Apr 29 | 8 | 206 | 24 | Rod Smith |
Fitz Toussaint | RB | OH | 4 stars | 5.8 | Apr 18 | 8 | NR | 14 | Tony Gibson |
Michael Schofield | OL | IL | 4 stars | 5.8 | Jun 16 | 18 | NR | 6 | Scott Shafer |
Teric Jones | RB | MI | 3 stars | 5.7 | Mar 29 | 37 | NR | 12 | Tony Dews |
Isaiah Bell | LB | OH | 3 stars | 5.7 | Mar 31 | 26 | NR | 27 | Tony Gibson |
Hoke 2012 recruits as of July 26, 2011:
Name | Pos | State | Stars | RR | Commit'd | Pos | Nat | State | Rec'd By |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kyle Kalis | OL | OH | 4 stars | 6.0 | Jul 10 | 4 | 18 | 1 | Greg Mattison |
Royce Jenkins-Stone | LB | MI | 4 stars | 5.9 | Apr 16 | 7 | 87 | 1 | Fred Jackson |
Erik Magnuson | OL | CA | 4 stars | 5.9 | Jun 10 | 8 | 34 | 6 | Dan Ferrigno |
Blake Bars | OL | TN | 4 stars | 5.8 | Jun 26 | 34 | NR | 6 | Mark Smith |
Joe Bolden | LB | OH | 4 stars | 5.8 | Apr 29 | 16 | NR | 11 | Greg Mattison |
Pharaoh Brown | DE | OH | 4 stars | 5.8 | May 07 | 20 | NR | 17 | Greg Mattison |
Terry Richardson | DB | MI | 4 stars | 5.8 | May 19 | 18 | NR | 4 | Greg Mattison |
James Ross | LB | MI | 4 stars | 5.8 | May 2 | 4 | NR | 3 | Fred Jackson |
Tom Strobel | DE | OH | 4 stars | 5.8 | Jun 10 | 18 | NR | 14 | Greg Mattison |
Jarrod Wilson | DB | OH | 4 stars | 5.8 | Jul 8 | NR | NR | NR | Greg Mattison |
Ben Braden | OL | MI | 3 stars | 5.7 | Mar 24 | 59 | NR | 9 | Greg Mattison |
Devin Funchess | TE | MI | 3 stars | 5.7 | Apr 22 | 17 | NR | 6 | Fred Jackson |
Allen Gant | DB | OH | 3 stars | 5.7 | May 31 | 22 | NR | 29 | Al Borges |
Matthew Godin | DT | MI | 3 stars | 5.7 | May 12 | 27 | NR | 7 | Fred Jackson |
Kaleb Ringer | LB | OH | 3 stars | 5.7 | Apr 12 | 11 | NR | 25 | Mark Smith |
Caleb Stacey | OL | OH | 3 stars | 5.7 | Mar 26 | 12 | NR | 22 | Mark Smith |
Anthony Standifer | DB | IL | 3 stars | 5.7 | Jun 01 | 37 | NR | 14 | Jeff Hecklinski |
A.J. Williams | TE | OH | 3 stars | 5.7 | Apr 22 | 16 | NR | 28 | Mark Smith |
Mario Ojemudia | DE | MI | 3 stars | 5.6 | May 7 | NR | NR | 14 | Fred Jackson |
Jeremy Clark# | DB | KY | 3 stars | 5.5 | Jun 24 | NR | NR | 6 | (Camp offer) |
Sione Houma | RB | UT | 0 stars | NR | Jul 25 | NR | NR | NR | Dan Ferrigno |
# = entering as grayshirt
By the way those are end-of-cycle rankings so it's not an exact match, e.g. Newsome was at one point rated the 20th player in the country by Rivals and was around 40-something by mid-summer. For our purposes it gets the point across: RR had some great gifts for the tree had they hung on, but still needed a lot of stocking stuffers.
Both coaches worked quickly to over-address positions of the greatest whiffs in years previous. Rodriguez got two of the top QBs in the country signed on, and had 5-stars or near enough at cornerback and DT. To the groans of smurf-haters everywhere, RR also had secured two more scat-backs and another (highly rated) slot receiver. Schofield was considered a good system OT; Isaiah Bell was a S/LB sleeper adored by one Ohio site but not the national scouts. Hoke meanwhile has killed, already having secured five OL commitments, three of whom are already past the "just a 4-star" threshold, and also swept the region in LB recruits, faring almost as well in DEs. Hoke's clearly got the advantage.
You'll note a lot of the 2008 haul never made it to campus. The 3-9 year was partly to blame of course, however as of late July 2008 many of RR's guys were soft. Will Campbell (right) committed to Carr in the middle of his junior (2007) year and remained a softie; he eventually de-committed in September only to re-up after a long and pulmonarily destructive flirtation with SEC schools. Bryce committed but looking around; he lost interest in October, presumably after many sleepless nights spent thinking of Nick Sheridan passing to him. Newsome was entertaining a camp visit at Virginia Tech this time three years ago, but turned it down and sounded like he was rock. He and Beaver gave up around the same time (right after you mentally gave up on the 2008 offense) and were immediately replaced by Tate and the hard pursuit of some supersonic kid in Florida who Urban wanted badly and nobody thought was a QB.
And then there's DeQuinta Jones, a 4-star DT from Louisiana who just kind of randomly pretended to commit to M without visiting, kind of the way that my buddy once announced that he was in love with the hottest girl in camp, whom we will call L.H.*, so that other girls in camp would take him more seriously. If this seems at all weird to you welcome to the wild and wacky world of Louisiana recruiting; bring a funny hat. The DeQuinta/LH gambit worked surprisingly well in both cases, except not for the faux commit-ee.
If you take away the guys who de-committed from RR's 2009 class it looks more like this…
…and it's Hoke like whoa. A bad year in 2011 and maybe his class starts falling apart as well, but it is important to note that nobody on that list above is considered soft except the grayshirted Jeremy Clark** if he gets something better than high-ish MAC offers, whereas that label applied to half of RR's first full class by July.
Stick their late additions to the hybrid class with their first-year recruiting by July and you get:
Not hugely dissimilar except that Hoke's got a lot more 3-stars and is missing four blue chips. In a worst case scenario the 2011 team starts losing a la 2008, while Ohio State's dancing along having gotten off virtually scot-free from the most obvious case of Failure to Monitor and Lack of Institutional Control I've ever witnessed in 20 years of college football fandom, and Hoke's Goodwill Ride of 2011 comes to a crashing, sudden stop, and then entire position groups are destroyed, and the 2012 guys start decomitting and the university hires Freakbass to rebrand us. If all those things don't happen, well, this probably turns out better than the last time.
Brian penned a State of Recruiting article in early August '08 that's worth a look-back so you can remember your comparable state of mind. How does that compare to now? And I didn't even make you compare "Denard: The Upperclassman Years" to "gee I hope this Sheridan guy really is a Basanez."
--Summer Glau
P.S. Don't miss the next exciting episode of 'Alphas' on Sci-Fi!
---------------------------------------------
* Fellow period Tamakwans will agree that this wasn't debatable. Maaaybe a few votes for E.C. or L.C. (EDIT: L.B.!!! HT Schram, Schram, Schneider, & Luria)
** He'll get a YMRMFSPA Charles Stewart if he makes it, but the Phillip Brackins comparison is so go, unless we decide you can all remember Eric Rosel.
Good catch.
The part I deleted (which was worth deleting) had the timeframe correct and even links to a bunch of goings on around then so I don't know why i screwed it up later.
Thanks for doing the work that nobody would've ever cared enough to do. Can we just put some kind of sitewide block on the word Rodriguez? Is all this work supposed to be some kind of affirmation that we made a good hire? If Dave Brandon is not having one of his underlings put together charts like this in order to quantify the progress, there is really very little need for anyone to do it. Put this power towards constructive pursuits.
Let's shutdown MGoBlog.
Day 201: RR got up early did a some extra stretching, popped in a Josh Groban CD and went about his business of opening up a recruiting pipeline at Lifeskills. Huge advantage to Hoke who spent his 201st day pointing Michigan Men in the right direction.
Hoke 148 RR 53
Comments