Rutgers fan celebrates a first down, 2016 [Patrick Barron]

Introducing The Rutger Comment Count

Brian October 25th, 2018 at 11:38 AM

One of our photographers, Patrick Barron, has been trying to make fetch happen in our Slack for a little while now, except in this case "fetch" is actually a useful way of measure how grisly a blowout is. (Also we've discovered that SBN's Jason Kirk had the same idea a couple weeks before Patrick, so he's now Rutger Leibnitz.)

I mentioned it in the game column but here's a more complete introduction to…

The Rutger

A rutger is when you have fewer yards in some aspect of the game than your opponent has points. For example, the 2018 Michigan-Michigan State game saw Michigan (21 points) hand MSU (15 rushing yards) a rushing rugter, at least by NCAA stats.

A Total Rutger, where you have fewer yards than the opposition has points, is a rare event. Total rutger events in the past decade of college football, with FBS matchups bolded:

Season Week Offense Defense Def Pts Off yds Rutger
2013 4 Florida Int Louisville 72 27 2.67
2017 8 Kansas TCU 43 21 2.05
2016 6 Rutgers Michigan 78 39 2.00
2012 2 Savannah State Florida St 55 28 1.96
2008 14 Mississippi St Mississippi 45 24 1.88
2015 20 N Illinois Boise St 55 33 1.67
2014 2 South Carolina State Clemson 73 44 1.66
2017 1 Charleston Southern Mississippi St 49 33 1.48
2016 2 Savannah State Southern Miss 56 41 1.37
2009 4 UTEP Texas 64 53 1.21
2014 1 Delaware Pittsburgh 62 57 1.09
2014 13 Savannah State BYU 64 63 1.02

Michigan-Rutgers 2016, TCU-Kansas 2017, and Louisville-FIU 2013 were all Double Total Rutger events, which sit in a subclass of the rutger: the Rutgers. Nobody has achieved the Triple Rutger in recent CFB history.

Congratulations to Mississippi State, which is the only team to both rutger and be rutger'd, and the only team to get rutger'd in a rivalry game. FCS-level Savannah State is the most generous rutger provider in all the land.

Rushing rutgers, aided by NCAA sack accounting, are stunningly common: about 600 rushing rutgers over the past decade. There have been approximately 200 passing rutgers. With about 8000 games in the data set, any particular game has about a 10% chance to be a single-phase rutger.

[After THE JUMP: beyoooond the ruuuuuutger]

Beyond The Rutger

The Hoke. There is a level of statistical ineptitude even beyond The Rutger wherein you have more negative yards than the opponent has points, a special accomplishment indeed since the bar keeps getting raised the worse you are. This is only realistically possible in a single-phase rutger, and even then it's only because the NCAA counts sack yardage as rushing yardage. This is nonsense, of course, but that does not stop people from referencing historically grisly box scores that sport this nonsense. This is right and just and emphatically happened to Brady Hoke against Michigan State:

image

It is thus dubbed The Hoke. Hoke has the second-worst hoke of the last decade and is the only coach to manage it twice in a single season. The only other coach to show up twice is Mike Leach, who is doing it on purpose. 

Season Offense Defense Def Pts Off Rush Yards Hoke Level
2009 Washington St Arizona St 27 -45 1.67
2013 Michigan Michigan St 29 -48 1.66
2016 Washington St Arizona St 32 -52 1.63
2014 Southern Miss Louisiana Tech 31 -45 1.45
2013 Michigan Nebraska 17 -21 1.24
2014 Louisiana Mon Louisiana Laf 34 -40 1.18
2014 Wake Forest Louisville 20 -22 1.10
2017 Cal Washington 38 -40 1.05
2011 Tennessee Georgia 20 -21 1.05
2010 Rutgers Army 20 -20 1.00
2009 Oklahoma Texas 16 -16 1.00

The bolded games are, incredibly, wins for the team that suffered a hoke.

The Autorutger. Occurs when you have fewer yards than you have points and will never ever happen. The closest approach to a total autorutger was Missouri's 42-13 win over Florida in 2014. Mizzou gained just 119 yards and achieved a remarkable 0.35 autorutger. The next closest autorutger also involves Florida, but this time they're on the good end after a 44-11 win over South Carolina in 2012 in which they gained just 183 yards. Will Muschamp, man.

Individual phase autorutgers are common enough that they don't warrant too much attention, but the Div By Zero Autorutger is a special case. This occurs when a team has zero passing yards and still wins. It's a list populated by the usual suspects and Louisiana Lafayette, somehow.

Season Offense Defense Def Pts Off Pts Off Pass Yards
2016 Louisiana Laf Louisiana Mon 3 30 0
2017 Army FCS 6 64 0
2017 Navy Virginia 7 49 0
2018 Army Miami (OH) 30 31 0
2017 Navy SMU 40 43 0
2011 Navy SMU 17 24 0
2017 Army E Michigan 27 28 0
2012 Air Force Hawaii 7 21 0
2013 Georgia Southern Florida 20 26 0
2017 Army Air Force 0 21 0
2009 Navy Wake Forest 10 13 0

This concludes your introduction to the rutger.

Comments

killthereds

October 25th, 2018 at 5:41 PM ^

I’d be curious to see about a penalty related Rutger. It could be called a Fulmer when you commit more penalty yards than your offense gains, in (dis)honor of the Fulmer cup.

I assume it would be impossible to go back and find stats on offsetting or declined penalties, but MSU would probably have been close this year.

Mr. Owl

October 25th, 2018 at 9:36 PM ^

Is a RichRod when you regularly score 60, but lose because you give up 62 and never can beat anything other than mediocre teams?

BBQJeff

October 26th, 2018 at 12:50 AM ^

I'd love to know what the Rutger factor was in the Georgia Tech vs Cumberland game.  I've read that Cumberland had negative offensive yards in that game but since Georgia Tech outscored them 222-0 they probably didn't hoke since 222+ negative yards seems like an impossibility.

tybert

October 26th, 2018 at 1:07 AM ^

My FAVORITE Michigan Rutger of all time was 1976 - UM 22 OSU 0. We "tied" OSU when we passed for ZERO yards. Ricky Leach had no completions (0 for 6) and an INT.