OT: Dune Part 2(no spoilers)

Submitted by The Shredder on March 1st, 2024 at 1:14 PM

Big Dune reader here, saw part 2 about a week ago, going tonight again. Also a big fan of Denis Villeneuve(arrival, sicario, prisoner). 

I highly suggest you see this on the biggest screen you can. I thought it was great, some changes from the book but I think they make sense. Amazing pace that breezes by. If you loved part 1, you'll love this. 

Brian created mgoblog to train the faithful. 

treetown

March 1st, 2024 at 5:28 PM ^

The book series has a very devoted following (although the first few books were probably the most accessible). 

And like any huge work (like Lord of the Rings) it can be hard to watch a film if you don't have a sense of what it is about ahead of time and it isn't for everyone - so if you go, don't expect a star wars like pew pew movie. David Lynch's 1984 version had its moments and the first few scenes which basically lay out the plot of the film really was clever solution to this problem:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IR8tbNKxBhE

"I did not say this. I was not here" - one of many great lines. Look also, as the Navigator leaves, his crew cleans up after him. In the book it is retrieve any stray bits of Spice, but it looks like they are trying to buff out any scuff marks they made in the Emperor's beautiful marble floor with their transport tank.

Villenuve having the benefit of more time - took a more leisurely measured pace but it is a stunning film. 

Brian created mgoblog to train the faithful - truly, and Seth can explain the allusions to the Ottoman Empire, the symbolism of the Spice standing in for oil, 

Louie C

March 2nd, 2024 at 6:46 AM ^

I guess that settles it. I will be seeing this after hearing multiple rave reviews. Still haven't seen the first one yet. I was a bit leery because I was a big fan of the books, and was afraid of being let down.

Yeah, I'm that "the book is better guy" on for the reason that the novels paint of version of your own personal picture in your mind, and if a movie version doesn't jibe with it, shits on the novel, or the director takes many liberties with the film version, it's such a letdown. 

XM - Mt 1822

March 2nd, 2024 at 7:33 AM ^

saw D2 yesterday with some of the kids.  i am like you that in general the book is better, but they did a great job in both movies so as a fan of dune you will like it, probably love it.  D2 overall was very good with a few parts that i thought were A+/outstanding.  they do some slight changes to the plot, but nothing of great substance and it doesn't detract from the overall movie.  

suggestion:  rent the new D1 on netflix or some other service.  you'll enjoy it.  then go see D2.