Gathering data for Part II of my "Decimated Defense" feature. Tide and Lion fans, I need your help: check my rosters below and let me know if there are mistakes. I'm willing to bet the PSU one is in better shape than Bama's, just because I follow Penn State a lot closer. Things to check for:

• Players listed who were walk-ons
• Scholarship players (not including walk-ons who earned schollies) on your defensive roster from those classes who were not listed
• Defensive players and "Athletes" signed to Letters-of-Intent not listed
• "ATH" recruits who played out full careers on offense (e.g. Derrick Williams) I don't want to penalize defensive recruiting for losing a player to their same team's offense

Penn State

table.tableizer-table {border: 1px solid #CCC; font-family: Verdana, Verdana, Geneva, sans-serif; font-size: 12px;} .tableizer-table td {padding: 4px; margin: 3px; border: 1px solid #ccc;} .tableizer-table th {background-color: #000042; color: #FFF; font-weight: bold;}

Name	Pos (Roster)	Pos (Recruited)	Stars	Year
Justin King	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	*****	2005
Lydell Sargeant	NOT ON ROSTER	ATH	****	2005
Jerome Hayes	DE	LB	****	2005
Willie Harriott	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	***	2005
Anthony Scirrotto	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	***	2005
Knowledge Timmons	DB	ATH	***	2005
Sean Lee	LB	LB	***	2005
Devin Fentress	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	**	2005
Chris Baker	NOT ON ROSTER	DT	**	2005
A.J. Wallace	DB	DB	*****	2006
Maurice Evans	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	****	2006
Aaron Maybin	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	****	2006
Phillip Taylor	NOT ON ROSTER	DT	****	2006
Tom McEowen	DT	DT	****	2006
Jared Odrick	DT	DT	****	2006
Navorro Bowman	LB	LB	****	2006
Bani Gbadyu	LB	LB	****	2006
Abe Koroma	NOT ON ROSTER	DT	***	2006
Cedric Jeffries	DB	WR	***	2006
Eric Latimore	DE	DE	***	2006
Ollie Ogbu	DT	DT	***	2006
Johnnie Troutman	OL	DE	***	2006
Nick Sukay	DB	DB	****	2007
Andrew Dailey	DB	LB	****	2007
Devon Still	DT	DE	****	2007
Chris Colasanti	LB	LB	****	2007
Nathan Stupar	LB	LB	****	2007
Chaz Powell	WR	DB	****	2007
Kevion Latham	DE	DE	***	2007
Chimaeze Okoli	DT	DT	***	2007
Drew Astorino	DB	ATH	**	2007
Stephfon Green	RB	DB	**	2007
Michael Mauti	LB	LB	****	2008
Mike Yancich	LB	LB	****	2008
Mike Zordich	LB	LB	****	2008
Brandon Beachum	RB	LB	****	2008
D'Anton Lynn	DB	DB	***	2008
Jack Crawford	DE	DE	***	2008
Pete Massaro	DE	DE	***	2008
Brandon Ware	DT	DT	**	2008
James Terry	OL	DT	**	2008
Darrell Givens	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	****	2009
Glenn Carson	NOT ON ROSTER	LB	****	2009
Derrick Thomas	DB	DB	****	2009
Gerald Hodges	DB	LB	****	2009
Stephon Morris	DB	DB	***	2009
Stephen Obeng-Agyapong	DB	DB	***	2009
Malcolm Willis	DB	DB	***	2009
Sean Stanley	DE	DT	***	2009
Mike Wallace	DB	DB	**	2009
Garry Gilliam	DE	DE	**	2009
Jordan Hill	DT	DE	**	2009

Bama

table.tableizer-table {border: 1px solid #CCC; font-family: Verdana, Verdana, Geneva, sans-serif; font-size: 12px;} .tableizer-table td {padding: 4px; margin: 3px; border: 1px solid #ccc;} .tableizer-table th {background-color: #760A18; color: #FFF; font-weight: bold;}

Name	Pos (Roster)	Pos	Stars	Year
Tyrone King	DB	DB	**	2004
Chris Keys	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	****	2005
Lorenzo Washington	DL	DT	****	2005
Brandon Fanney	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	****	2005
Lionel Mitchell	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	***	2005
Bobby Greenwood	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	***	2005
Travis McCall	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	***	2005
Prince Hall	NOT ON ROSTER	LB	***	2005
Michael Ricks	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	***	2005
Chris Rogers	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	***	2005
Ali Sharrief	DL	ATH	***	2005
Desmond Jennings	NOT ON ROSTER	ATH	***	2005
Antonio Forbes	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	***	2005
Zach Schreiber	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	***	2005
Marlon Davis	NOT ON ROSTER	OL	***	2005
Cole Harvey	NOT ON ROSTER	OL	***	2005
Byron Walton	NOT ON ROSTER	OL	***	2005
Brandon Deaderick	DL	DE	***	2005
Cory Reamer	FB	LB	***	2005
Scott Deaton	NOT ON ROSTER	OL	**	2005
Baron Huber	FB	LB	**	2005
Sam Burnthall	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	**	2005
Evan Cardwell	NOT ON ROSTER	OL	**	2005
Travis Sikes	DB	DB	**	2005
Eryk Anders	LB	LB	****	2006
Earl Alexander	WR	ATH	****	2006
Marcus Udell	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	****	2006
Alex Stadler	NOT ON ROSTER	OL	****	2006
Marquis Johnson	DB	DB	****	2006
Justin Woodall	DB	DB	****	2006
Tremayne Coger	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	***	2006
Andy Davis	OL	DB	***	2006
LaBronski Hutchins	NOT ON ROSTER	LB	***	2006
Milton Talbert	DL	DE	***	2006
Jake Jones	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	***	2006
Charlie Higgenbotham	NOT ON ROSTER	LB	***	2006
Charlie Kirschman	NOT ON ROSTER	LB	***	2006
Javier Arenas	DB	ATH	***	2006
Michael Ricks	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	****	2007
Rolando McClain	LB	LB	****	2007
Alex Watkins	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	****	2007
Phelon Jones	DB	DB	****	2007
Chris Lett	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	****	2007
Kareem Jackson	DB	DB	****	2007
Luther Davis	DL	DT	****	2007
Alfred McCullough	OL	DT	****	2007
Patrick Crump	NOT ON ROSTER	OL	***	2007
Josh Chapman	DL	DT	***	2007
Nick Gentry	DL	DT	***	2007
Marquis Maze	WR	ATH	***	2007
Tarence Farmer	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	***	2007
Chavis Williams	LB	DE	***	2007
Jeremy Elder	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	**	2007
Jennings Hester	NOT ON ROSTER	LB	**	2007
Burton Scott	DB	ATH	*****	2008
Alonzo Lawrence	NOT ON ROSTER	DB	****	2008
Mark Barron	DB	ATH	****	2008
Kerry Murphy	DL	DT	****	2008
Jerrell Harris	LB	LB	****	2008
Courtney Upshaw	LB	LB	****	2008
Melvin Ray	LB	WR	****	2008
Michael Williams	TE	DE	****	2008
Devonta Bolton	NOT ON ROSTER	ATH	****	2008
Brandon Lewis	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	****	2008
Robby Green	DB	DB	****	2008
Robert Lester	DB	DB	****	2008
Glenn Harbin	DL	DE	****	2008
Chris Jordan	LB	ATH	****	2008
Don'ta Hightower	LB	LB	****	2008
Mark Ingram	RB	ATH	****	2008
Marcel Dareus	DL	DT	***	2008
Damion Square	DL	DT	***	2008
Undra Billingsley	TE	DE	***	2008
Terrence Cody	DL	DT	***	2008
Wesley Neighbors	DB	DB	**	2008
Corey Smith	TE	K	**	2008
Dre Kirkpatrick	DB	DB	*****	2009
Trent Richardson	DB	RB	*****	2009
Nico Johnson	LB	LB	*****	2009
Tana Patrick	LB	LB	****	2009
Darrington Sentimore	NOT ON ROSTER	DT	****	2009
Rod Woodson	DB	DB	****	2009
Quinton Dial	NOT ON ROSTER	DT	****	2009
William Ming	DL	DE	****	2009
Brandon Moore	DL	OL	****	2009
Ed Stinson	LB	DE	****	2009
Anthony Orr	NOT ON ROSTER	DE	***	2009
Petey Smith	NOT ON ROSTER	LB	***	2009
Chris Bonds	DL	DT	***	2009
Anthony Steen	DL	OL	***	2009
Jonathan Atchison	LB	LB	***	2009
Darius McKeller	NOT ON ROSTER	OL	***	2009

Any help you can provide will basically make your team look better. My ultimate purpose for this will be to analyze Michigan against like programs (yours are the first two I categorized) to see what happened to our defense. However, hopefully the analysis will be just as useful to you. Please share with all relevant blogs, etc. Thanks!