Guardian Article on Academic Compensation for Student-Athletes

Submitted by Edward Khil on April 20th, 2022 at 10:42 AM

"New NCAA rules mean colleges can now pay athletes up to $5,980 per year for getting good grades." The last I heard, Michigan was in the majority choosing not to. Includes a reference to Harbaugh receiving bonuses for athletes' academic performance, and a tangential quote from the Head Coach.

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2022/apr/20/college-football-basketball-payments-players-academics

Hab

April 20th, 2022 at 11:19 AM ^

So basically, schools are permitted to pay athletes for getting good grades about what they would reasonably make at a part time job waiting tables or tending bar at Charley's.  Cool cool.  Not sure how I feel about the condition that they get good grades though.  That just seems silly to me.  It's not like the schools are some sort of benefactor grandparent, uncle, or parent.  Just pay the athletes for the "missed" opportunity.

Billy Ray Valentine

April 20th, 2022 at 11:39 AM ^

"The last I heard, Michigan was in the majority choosing not to."

 

This is not fully accurate. ESPN's lackluster, quasi-hit-job article on this subject indicated that Michigan was among the many schools that had not yet decided whether or not to pay athletes for "good grades." That said, kudos to the OP for pointing out how the Guardian article deceptively attempts to tie Coach Harbaugh's contract to this issue, as if the reason Michigan has not yet made a decision is because of Harbaugh's contract. Class warfare baiting at its worst, imho.

 

I am an unabashed supporter of paying athletes for NIL. Initially, I thought I would also support paying athletes for "good grades." The more I think about it, the more I'm against it. Paying for grades is ripe for abuse. It probably would discourage athletes from taking more challenging courses. It would be difficult to create a equitable system that pays all athletes, not just revenue sport athletes. If you want to financially reward full-time athletes, regardless of their scholarship/walk-on status, that earn a degree, maybe that'll work.    

 

bronxblue

April 20th, 2022 at 12:11 PM ^

This article basically reads like a thinly-veiled re-writing of the  lazy ESPN article that was published a couple of weeks ago, down to trying to tie Harbaugh's extension to Michigan (and seemingly a lot of schools) not wanting to discuss how they'd pay athletes for grades.

NotADuck

April 20th, 2022 at 6:30 PM ^

Yes but it was from ESPN.  The Guardian is a Britain-based news institution if I'm not mistaken.  Also this article tries to use different arguments than the ESPN article to support its ideas, not that any of it's ideas are good.

I haven't read either article so I really can't say for myself.