Cali's Goin' Blue

July 11th, 2016 at 5:12 PM ^

He is definitely in the top tier of athletes in college with Leanoard Fournette and Christian Mccaffrey, and he has a coaching staff that will put him in the best position to succeed always. On defense, he has maybe the best DC in college football using him as the hybrid space player he was meant to be. And on top of that, he has a head coach who knows how gamechanging an athlete like him on the field can have to an offense, whether it be as a decoy, or as a primary option, Peppers is the most interesting and fun college player in years, when you add in the coaching schemes for him. 

Tater

July 11th, 2016 at 6:10 PM ^

I think Fournette is the best of tham all, but he's stuck with Cam Cameron and Les Miles running the offfense.  I think Fournette would threaten 3,000 yards on the ground at Bama or Michigan this year.  He won't get 2,000 running in the world's most boring and predictable offense.    

Danwillhor

July 11th, 2016 at 6:34 PM ^

our OL isn't getting any HB to 3,000 lol. LSU doesn't have an issue in the rub game. Sure, a passing game would help and that may be what you mean but we don't have a proven QB or OL to say he'd be better off here. That said, he'd be better off here (ha).

othernel

July 11th, 2016 at 5:19 PM ^

The Lewis / Peppers debate sort of reminds me of the Yankees of the 90's where people would say "Jeter should win the AL MVP" and then when asked who the best player on the Yankee team was was, the answer was near-unanimously "Mariano Rivera".

Seems like UM fans are "Peppers for Heisman... Lewis for team MVP"

CRISPed in the DIAG

July 12th, 2016 at 10:10 AM ^

Rivera was a modern closer. Meaning, he usually only appeared at the beginning of the 9th of save situations.  I'm too lazy to veriffy, but he was as tough on LHH and RHH because of that weird frisbee curve that broke in on LHH's. That's what made Bill Mueller's big hits in '04 (regular season fight game and Game 4 ALCS) so spectacular.

Torre used the hell out of his situation BP guys. Burned 'em up. It usually worked.

getsome

July 11th, 2016 at 7:05 PM ^

agreed.  ive seen interviews where jeter instantly replied with a simple "mo" when asked to name the most vital and irreplaceable yankee.  also heard similar from bernie williams.

jeter drove that engine and acted as the teams rock but riveras sheer dominance allowed them to carry the necessary attitude and edge.

i always enjoyed rooting against the yanks and socks but i certainly respected the play of some of those squads

Tyrone Biggums

July 11th, 2016 at 5:40 PM ^

Can't argue with this top 5. Anyone on the list could win the Heisman with the exception of Garrett. Heisman voters hate on defensive players. That being said we all know the formula...

3-5 sacks

3-5 INTs

3-5 Special Teams TDs

1-3 Offensive TDs

Show up to play in every big game and we have our second primarily defensive Heisman winner.

And, we'd have to say goodbye so F that. We need one more year of Jabrill after this one. I think a '97 repeat would see him bolt, degree or not.

stephenrjking

July 11th, 2016 at 5:51 PM ^

I think the only thing that keeps him from leaving is a bizarre, catastrophically disappointing year. Just on physical tools alone he's a first-rounder, and last season already displayed astonishing explosiveness and versatility. He's a millionaire in waiting. I would be flabbergasted if he came back.

Danwillhor

July 11th, 2016 at 6:38 PM ^

Sadly, I think we only get 2 years of his ability. I think the biggest question will be whether he would have been better or helped more at HB if he doesn't win a ton of awards on defense. Truly bittersweet to have such a crazy talent and essentially have him for no more than 27 games.

Wolfman

July 11th, 2016 at 6:22 PM ^

You'll actually see a better second year than normal due to the extra year of being in the system, never having the need to get rid of habits due to bad coaching. The kid came in as a workout warrior so in addition to his crazy speed, jumping ability, timing, read and react ability second to none, he's probably the strongest 205 lber in cfb. You do rememember the SPARQ QB toss his freshman year, don't you. I thought, "Oh My, someone is going to get hurt." 

Let's face it. Jim isn't going to try to talk this young man out of millions of dollars, and we're talking lot of millions if he is only as good as last season, but he will be much better. He also was hurt his freshman season. I am glad he made it through last year injury free. 

As much as we'd love to see him come back, the degree talk should be put on the back burner for his young man who will have at least 2 1/2 years worth of credits after the season. I think it's a good idea to come back in his spare time and get the degree for business purposes after he leaves the league, but I'm hoping for a long NFL career as well. Get through 2016 in good health Mr. Peppers and take your money. The talk about staying until he gets his degree is the type of talk you want to hear from a 17 or 18 year old young man. After a few years of maturity, money starts to become real for these young men. 

Tyrone Biggums

July 11th, 2016 at 6:40 PM ^

Your window to be "big man on campus" is sooooo small. The money will be there, the college experience won't. Jabrill has reiterated many times how important the degree is to him. I believe he will be the first in his family. And if nothing else he can come back as team captain and usher in our back to back B10 championships. It's gonna be a young team and guys are gonna need some peer role models to show them what it takes to win. Not to mention, how many great players who left early say that they wish they had stayed and fufilled their eligibility? Most of them.

Wolfman

July 11th, 2016 at 6:47 PM ^

except two words, Phil Hubbard. Damn, that would be a frickin shame and this kid is gold. Selfishly, I want him to come back, and I'm certain he will speak to a lot of people to discuss those things you speak of.  Almost all these young men know what a Michigan degree is worth and that is why our team is going to beat a lot of other teams. In addition to talent, our team is very smart. I won't campaign for or against. He'll make the right decision. I know I just can't wait to see what Mr. Brown has waiting for us this season and well, that Harbaugh guy on the other side of the ball for No. 5 as well. Should be Big Fun. 

getsome

July 11th, 2016 at 7:21 PM ^

yep - the funny thing is garrett wont win the heisman but stands a great chance at being drafted #1 (since its typically QB, OT or  DL).

another thing - i love peppers game and all he brings to the team but adoree jackson at usc might just have an even better chance at putting up those type all around #s and winning the heisman.

hopefully peppers breaks a few on special teams and gets more O touches so thats not the case though (bc he certainly has the ability)

getsome

July 11th, 2016 at 5:45 PM ^

these type lists are arbitrary in nature and while i could pick several guys id shift around or drop / add, i actually think its a fairly decent top 10