OT: PSU: another one gone (walk-on kicker Matt Marcincin)

Submitted by Jon06 on September 14th, 2012 at 11:19 AM

This time a kicker. I guess backup kickers don't take it kindly when the starter goes 1-5 on FGs, 1-2 on XPs, and somehow keeps his job. The latest departure, Matt Marcincin, is just a redshirt freshman walk-on, but it suggests PSU's kicker situation is not going to change much this season.

To give this thread a chance of being about something other than whether you should complain about its existence, I do have a question that might be interesting. Is there a reason PSU hasn't just given one-year scholarships to most of the walk-ons on the roster? They must've lost enough players to have some free scholarships. It'd be a nice thing for them to do for those who have stayed.

Comments

UMgradMSUdad

September 15th, 2012 at 1:21 AM ^

I felt bad for him and the other players too, and I still do.  I even started to feel sorry for the PSU fans.  Then I went to a PSU sports blog and read yet another thread with hundreds of posts talking about a convoluted conspiracy involving Freeh and the BoT to besmirch JoePa's reputation.  The misplaced anger and tortured logic of these fans showed how wrong I was to feel any sympathy toward them.

State Street

September 14th, 2012 at 11:29 AM ^

I think it was less his dissatisfaction with playing time and more "Holy shit this is how they treat kickers when they fail in State College."

He left the team, not the school.

APBlue

September 14th, 2012 at 1:59 PM ^

The kicking game is a disaster and this kid still can't get on the field.  I don't know about you, but that gives me a pretty good indication of this kid's kicking ability.  

I just don't think it's necessary to post a thread everytime some kid, especially a walk-on kicker leaves PSU.  If it were a starter, or someone on the two-deep, then I would understand.  At this rate, we may as well open a thread everytime a preferred walk-on recruit decommits from PSU.  

APBlue

September 14th, 2012 at 2:12 PM ^

A school going thru chasos - check.

PSU kicking game is a disaster - check.

This makes it worse - ch...wait.  What?  How does this make it worse?  He was a back-up walk-on kicker.  If he were pushing the starter...at all...he would have seen the field.  This does not make it worse.  Nothing to see here.  Move along.

I'm not too busy to read stuff like this.  I obviously read it.  I enjoy the debate about whether it's thread worthy more than the PSU kicking situation itself.  

APBlue

September 14th, 2012 at 3:11 PM ^

I'm on my phone, or I would. I'll be sure to log on from my computer later and register your -1. I hope that makes you feel better.

If you don't understand the difference between the leading returning WR leaving and a back-up, walk-on redshirt freshman kicker leaving the program, then I can't help you. I understand a post for the former, not the latter, but that's just me.

This is the 13th player that's left the PSU Program since the punishments were levied and "one of these kids is not like the other(s)".

CRex

September 14th, 2012 at 12:08 PM ^

Enh, it's not like we're pushing worthy topics off the front page right now.  I logged in this morning to see Glee and Cracked on it.  Given PSU isn't on our schedule though I don't think we need a post whenever someone leaves.  If this is still happening once we're in the B1G schedule and content is getting pushed, I'm all for negbombing.  Right now though, meh.

MGlobules

September 14th, 2012 at 11:36 AM ^

want to talk about it, they can; telling people they shouldn't have posted, etc. seems unproductive. But I do think that the point comes when the best thing to do with a tragedy like PSU's is leave them all alone to their grief.  

Jon06

September 14th, 2012 at 11:52 AM ^

who is piling on? do you see celebrating? 

there was a multi-post discussion of the PSU kicking game in the last thread about a PSU defection, and nobody had mentioned this yet on the mgoboard. the other thread's off the front page, so i made a new one with the new information. get over yourselves.

Mr. Yost

September 14th, 2012 at 11:41 AM ^

Guys, we can't have a thread every time someone leaves this team. On top of that...a walk-on backup kicker!?!

REALLY?!

Do you guys think PSU fans give a shit if Seth Broekhuizen or Anthony Capatina leave the team? Do you guys even know who Anthony Capatina is?

There are going to be plenty of guys who leave the team. Some because of PT, some because it's "not worth it," some for reasons that a lot of kids leave school. We don't need a thread every time. Silas Redd? He was an All-Conference player and he's going to the #2 team in the country...I get it. Matt Marcincin? Really?

justingoblue

September 14th, 2012 at 12:04 PM ^

after the Thursday Night Football Open Thread (a thread about two Big East schools and an NFL game), we've had a thread about a Glee quote, one article about Kramer's grandaughter, one about Michigan Stadium expansion with no substance and one about a Big Ten school losing a player on roster.

Call me crazy, but I don't see a reason to get all bent out of shape. This wasn't a snowflake diary about Alabama that pushed a big Mathlete diary off the page or anything.

BlueDragon

September 14th, 2012 at 11:17 PM ^

I started following this site back in 2008, and there were many more of those "snowflake diaries" day in and out. Hooah speeches and so on, or why Michigan will win on ______. Good times. The signal-to-noise ratio improved a bit since then in the diaries section but on the board of today no more than a quarter, typically, of the threads on the front page contain useful information.  Check as of right now: 8/15 of the threads contain what I would consider useful or at least time-sensitive information, so that's decently productive for information flow.

MGOTyrone

September 14th, 2012 at 12:19 PM ^

It seems to me a lot of people around here would prefer this place to be a ghost town. I might be in the minority but the only thing more annoying than "unworthy" threads is every single thread containing posts about how "unworthy" it is.

LSAClassOf2000

September 14th, 2012 at 12:58 PM ^

So, yeah, this leaves them with Ficken, who is 2-7 con FGs and 4-5 on PATs in his career to date, DiSanto, who has never seen action, I believe (and DiSanto is a junior, I think, so that might be telling). You would think that Penn State would be willing to experiment at this position given the situation. In a strange way, it does help to explain Penn State's comparatively good 4th down efficiency this season, if this is the kicking situation. If they weren't 5 of 7 on 4th downs, what would these first two games have looked like?

oakapple

September 14th, 2012 at 1:20 PM ^

Without 12 teams, the B1G would not be eligible to stage the lucrative conference championship game. Their TV deals would also be negotiated downard, since they'd have a smaller inventory of games to offer. And despite the sanctions, Penn State games still get better TV ratings than most other B1G schools.

Now who would you replace them with? There is no available school that is as valuable as Penn State, that meets the B1G's academic standards, and that would accept an offer to join. Notre Dame is obviously off the table. The entire ACC is off the table. Texas is off the table.

If you think any of the remaining Big East scraps (Rutgers, Louisville, UConn) is as valuable to the B1G as Penn State, you're kidding yourself. Anyhow, it's pretty clear that if the B1G were going to expel Penn State, they'd have done it already.