OT: In-N-Out or Five Guys

Submitted by DISCUSS Man on

inspired by user RedGreene

I say Five Guys because I'm from the midwest.

 

DISCUSS

white_pony_rocks

April 30th, 2015 at 1:49 PM ^

chick-fil-a because the hate makes it taste better

 

also, any burger place that used american cheese is fucking shit, there are so many good cheeses out there, why choose american?  yuck

Rocket Scientist

April 30th, 2015 at 1:56 PM ^

I'm living in Cali now, and Yes, In&Out is VERY popular. However, if I want a Burger, I go with 5 Guys.

In&Out : Delicious, fresh, Belly Bomb. 

5 Guys: Hearty Burger, Excellent Toppings, Best Fries

seegoblu

April 30th, 2015 at 2:02 PM ^

I've had it in LA, Las Vegas and Austin, TX...same quality burger every time, like it should be. I like the customization available at 5 guys (grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, relish, BBQ sauce) but its always a mess.

I feel gross leaving 5 Guys...I feel happy leaving I-N-O

ca_prophet

April 30th, 2015 at 2:07 PM ^

Manage expectations correctly, though. InAOut is a drive-thru fast food burger which is very good for that category. Five Guys is a step up from that, but that puts it in the category with your local sit-down burger joint. Both appear to be good places to work, though, and are decently run-businesses. I tend to go by Five Guys more often because there's one in the mall with my son's preferred option (Panera Bread).

bluewoody

April 30th, 2015 at 2:26 PM ^

I'm a Midwest guy. I think 5 guys has jumped the shark. It's not even that good anymore. In and Out by a mile.

However, this new spot in A2 is good:

Hunter house hamburgers on east William

Vice President…

April 30th, 2015 at 2:41 PM ^

I have always been a burger guy, but ever since I started raising my own grass-fed beef (serious) and my own pastured bacon (also serious) I cannot recommend anything else. 

Oh, and I like to throw on a fried egg from the chickens too, and, in summer, some greens from the garden.

I realize most people can't/won't do it this way, but a truly hand-crafted burger like that blows away the $100 billion beef supply chain burger every time. 

/steps down from soapbox

Number 7

April 30th, 2015 at 2:45 PM ^

It was barely distinguishable from McDonalds.  If the burger was at all fresh -- and it took damn long enough it better have been -- it was lost in a generic sugarplastic bun,

5 Guys also takes a while, but delivers the whole package.  I'd take it over Shake Shack, which is the conversation we have here on the other coast.

5 Guys also wins the fries contest by a landslide.

Wendyk5

April 30th, 2015 at 3:07 PM ^

Five Guys. I've been eating In n Out for years, and Five Guys since its inception. In and Out always had that regional cache if you lived in the midwest. But the last handful of times has been mediocre, and I figured out it's because a lot of places have caught up and surpassed them. There are made-fresh burger places all over now, so that aspect of In n Out isnt special anymore. What Five Guys has going for it is the meat. It's beefier tasting than In n Out. In n Out seems like its mostly lettuce and tomato, with a thin meat patty. I prefer the meat be the star of the burger. 

Willis

April 30th, 2015 at 3:15 PM ^

Ate at In N Out in two places a couple weeks ago when I was in California. It was good, but I think the taste of a 5 Guys burger is much better. It was the first time I'd ever had In N Out, I guess from all the talk I was expecting more, and a bigger burger as well. One definitely will not fill you up if you have a large appetite.



Sent from MGoBlog HD for iPhone & iPad

Nobody Likes a…

April 30th, 2015 at 3:48 PM ^

It's In 'n Out and it's not even close. It is a top 10 thing I miss about living in California and being able to pay $30 to play torrey pines doesn't make the top ten. Every time I am back I have the same couple I go to. the one just off Garnett in PB or the one the other side of the 101 from amphitheatre parkway.  This is literally the deep visceral connection I have with those burgers.

Five Guys is perfectly fine but every time I am done eating there my stomach takes a beating.

There is a chain in Toronto called The Burgers Priest which does a passable version of the In 'n Out burger but it's too greasy. Still though its nice to have options

 

James Burrill Angell

April 30th, 2015 at 3:49 PM ^

I was just in California for the first time since the 1998 Rose Bowl and had my first In N Out burger expecting to see Jesus after the first bite. Not so much. Don't get me wrong, it was good. Far better than McDonalds, BK, Fatburger etc. but it didn't blow me away and yes, I thought Five Guys was better.

lilpenny1316

April 30th, 2015 at 3:50 PM ^

It was great.  I don't know why, but none of the locations seem to be as good as the pre-expansion locations in Arlington and DC.  Don't know if they changed their formula (cheapened them) or what, but the burgers don't taste the same to me.

jaspersail

April 30th, 2015 at 4:42 PM ^

Agreed. Our Arlington office was a couple blocks from the original (?) Five Guys. It was my favorite thing about business travel to Arlington in the 90s. The burgers seem pretty similar though, but I think the fries used to be so much better. Weren't they curly fries back in the day?

steve sharik

April 30th, 2015 at 5:03 PM ^

...if the Five Guys founder got his concept from In-N-Out.  INO owners rebuffed several investors who wanted to help them go national b/c they thought the quality of the product would suffer and/or be impossible to be consistent.

That said, I like both, but I prefer INO.  But they're only in CA, AZ, NV, UT, and TX.  Not much help for those of us in the other 98% of the country.

Think it was Stamos who said it, but if you're in A^2, you should give Elevation a try.  INO concept but everything's organic, including the hand-made milkshakes.  It's not going to blow you away, but it is damn good.  Organic carries a price premium, though--e.g. I recently got a double burger with swiss, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, ketchup, mustard, mayo, plus fries and a shake for over $15.

Durham Blue

April 30th, 2015 at 7:16 PM ^

Depends on the circumstances.  Five Guys burgers tend to be more fatty and juicy.  In n Out burgers less so.  I like Five Guys more when I have a hangover or after a night of drinking.  I like In n Out if I want a great burger and I'm just hungry but prefer to be a little "healthier".  Tough choice but I think I prefer Five Guys, just barely.

VamosAzul

April 30th, 2015 at 11:30 PM ^

In-n-out is the biggest farce in the history of fast food!!! I don't understand! The burger is impressively mediocre and their fries are down right shitty. If you say in-n-out, you're a hype beast and you're lying to yourself and everyone you love.

Yes, I've had animal style.

uminks

May 1st, 2015 at 2:47 AM ^

My CA friends would tell me how great in-n-out was and to get everything animal style. But after my first time, I was not impressed. 5 guys and in-n-out are both good. My wife makes the best burgers and I grill them at home!