OT: MGoGUN discussion: What's your favorite hand gun/semi auto pistol/rifle??

Submitted by Craptain Crunch on July 8th, 2019 at 9:36 PM

Long story short, I moved to a place where there have been recent break-ins. I ended up purchasing a Beretta Storm PX4 full sized chambered in 9MM (de-cocker and safety combo). I'll learn how to use it and then think about adding a shotgun later. 

Two questions:

1. Anyone have experience with this pistol? What do you like and dislike about it?

 

2. If you don't own a PX4, what do you own/swear by?

 

3. What do you use to clean and lube your guns?

 

And to tie in some football-related material, I can't wait to see Shea in the Pistol!

 

 

 

 

 

 

turtleboy

July 8th, 2019 at 11:12 PM ^

For home defense? You're worried about late night break-ins while you're sound asleep, I'd go pump action shotgun. Loud enough to scare intruders away when you pump it, highly unlikely to miss should you actually need to use it staggering out of bed at 3am.

Emergency concealed carry? Hammerless revolver. You get jumped and hit on the head and need to pull a weapon and fire to save your life, a hammerless revolver will easily pull from a holster and won't jam. 

My favorite pistol? CZ 97. Cheapest .45 you can get match grade, the internal slide rails help the barrel seat tight, as well. 

Entry level pistol? Buy a glock. I may personally dispise the human piece of garbage who stole the company, but the company makes the Honda civic of pistols. Relatively good, pretty reliable, and extremely cheap. 

drjaws

July 8th, 2019 at 11:17 PM ^

1.  No experience with that gun.

2.  Anything Sig Sauer or Glock I swear by.  Others love Beretta but I have no experience besides shooting them.

3. Hoppes is good shit 

So many good comments.  Particularly, know your firearm.  Practice enough to be able to use it via muscle memory.  I have put a few hundred rounds through my Sig Sauer P239 .40 cal and I can field strip it blindfolded.

i like shotgun for home defense but wife hates them so I stick with my pistol 

Sione For Prez

July 8th, 2019 at 11:19 PM ^

Sounds like you already made your purchase but otherwise I would have recommended making friends at your local gun range and renting a few different styles and manufacturers to see what you liked best. 

I have a Smith & Wesson M&P full size 9mm and a Benelli SuperNova 12ga. Neither leaves the house other than to go to the range or back woods. 

BlueArcflash

July 8th, 2019 at 11:20 PM ^

PX4 is a good gun, soft recoil, but the double/single action trigger takes time to learn to use accurately. If you get a chance, try the new Beretta APX. It's a better design overall IMHO, and also my current personal choice. Whatever you have, absolutely take the time to learn the safe handling. Also put at least 500 rounds through it to make sure it functions as it should. 

BlueArcflash

July 8th, 2019 at 11:20 PM ^

This started as a double post so I'll change it to say: Breakfree CLP for cleaning, lube, whatever

reshp1

July 8th, 2019 at 11:46 PM ^

I posted some advice on another reply but to answer the OP. 

 

1. I don't own one but didn't particularly like the way it felt in my hand. I just felt like I couldn't get my hand as high up on the grip as I wanted. I also hate the slide mounted decocker/safety. Decocker is fine to break your grip to reach, but it's a deal breaker for a safety to not be able to reach it without shifting my grip. The rotating barrel design os is pretty cool and unique and appeals to me as an engineer. 

 

2. My favorite pistol is a CZ-75B. It's a bit of a hipster cult classic compared to more popular guns, but is an incredibly shooting handgun that feels poured into your hand. My favorite rifle is my Bushmaster ACR. I've wanted one since playing video games before I got into guns. Recently I got one and went through the long painful process of obtaining approval from the ATF to make it into a short barrel rifle, as well as the going through the process to get a suppressor. For how much time and money I invested into it, it was still totally worth it.

 

3. I use M-Pro7 which is a low/no smell solvent as my cleaner and Mobil One 10W for oil, and white lithium grease as well. I know a lot of people that use CLP for everything and it works fine. 

Fishbulb

July 9th, 2019 at 12:15 AM ^

Glock 19! Can’t go wrong with a Glock. Their Safe Action trigger is very, uh, safe. Glocks are so reliable. I agree with the poster above who mentioned going single/double action could get confusing for a beginner. And yes, pump a bunch of rounds through to get comfy. I also have a Ruger SR22 for plinking and playing around with single/double action. Guns for self-defense—you need A LOT of practice. It’s more of a lifestyle than a habit. You need to consider what you wear, where you go, are you drinking or not, are you crossing into a weapons-free zone...and guns for home defense need to be readily accessible. Like in a drawer or a biometric safe. And as others mentioned, you have to consider the other people in the house and others who visit. For kids, I say eliminate the curiosity. Show them you have a fun. Tell them what it can do and the damage it can cause. Teach them what to do if they see it somewhere it shouldn’t be. That way, you’ve eliminated the curiosity and temptation for them to handle it if they happen upon it. 

I feel a shotgun is the most effective home defense firearm. A pump action. Not your daddy’s deer gun—one made for self-defense. Don’t have to be precise. They are intimidating. And the sound of a 12 gauge shell being racked is VERY loud...which is good. 

Steve in PA

July 9th, 2019 at 9:02 AM ^

Glock 19 is my next purchase.  It needs to be small enough for my wife to be confident or me to CC but big enough that it isn't a toy in my large hands.

For home defense I prefer 20ga over 12ga.  My wife & daughter need to be comfortable and confident with it.

For someone thinking about a purchase, go to a gunstore  with a range.  Most have rental guns you can try to see what you like & don't like.

Maximum Effort

July 9th, 2019 at 1:35 AM ^

1.  Never finger banged one but I hear they're nice.

2.  For HD/carry, basically any striker-fired pistol:  I have a Glock 19 and FNS-40 hidden in secret stashes in the apt.  Oh, also have a 300 Blackout AR pistol (9" barrel) with brace under the bed, next to the plate carrier.  I love my 1911 (super accurate) but limited mag capacity and it has a thumb safety so it's a range toy (or if I ever shoot heavy metal division, I guess.)

3.  Hoppes #9 for general carbon fouling and then I use Hoppes with some Kroil for scrubbing the barrel to get out copper and stubborn deposits.

I agree with the guys encouraging training and familiarity with whatever tool(s) you choose.  Learn the ins and outs of your particular weapon, how it feels in the dark, practice changing mags and dry firing until your fingers are sore.  After you get training and can squeeze the trigger w/o the front sight moving, maybe step up your game and try shooting competitions.  USPSA, IPSC, 2-gun, 3-gun, pick your flavor.  Staying safe while shooting and moving under time stress will hone your skills that a square range can't provide.  And it's hella fun. 

Be safe and shoot straight!

A2YpsiBlue

July 9th, 2019 at 8:25 AM ^

Lots of good comments in here so I'll simply reiterate the most important point:  whatever gun(s) you have (and there are many good ones out there), train regularly.  Your brain is still the most important weapon and the firearm is only there if all else fails.  

Booted Blue in PA

July 9th, 2019 at 9:05 AM ^

If I were ever to own or carry a firearm, for the record and big brother's spying eyes, I DON'T.... but it would be a Smith and Wesson Shield.  I'm very familiar with the 9mm only because ammo is fairly inexpensive and if I were to decide to own and carry, i would want to shoot fairly often, to be proficient and practiced.  However if you wanted a little more knock down power, they do also chamber the Shield in a .40 and now a .45.    Great, smooth shooting little piece that hasn't had a jamb or miss fire in several thousand rounds.

I would also consider a Double Tap derringer chambered in .45.... cuz well..... bigger holes are better.  The DT is not a weapon to take to the range and put more than a couple rounds down range, unless you like feeling as if someone pounded your hand with a sledge.  She is purely a critical defense tool.   

all the above is hypothetical, of course.

 

Harbaughfense

July 9th, 2019 at 9:43 AM ^

If you aren't looking to spend a boat load of money and want something good to learn on that is reliable, its hard to beat a Smith and Wesson M&P. Dunham's sells them on sale for like 350 some months.

CFraser

July 9th, 2019 at 11:31 AM ^

Can’t beat simple ol’ 12 gauge buck shot for home defense. Cheap and by far the most effective. 

My kit:

Springfield XD-S .45ACP for carry

.300 BLK/AAC w/ 7.5” barrel AR-15 for “rifle” with a suppressor is my load out for zombie apocalypse.

JamesBondHerpesMeds

July 9th, 2019 at 2:27 PM ^

My favorite gun is one that is registered, safeguarded, and used only by mentally sound people with a history of responsible behavior.

Please, be this kind of gun owner. Meanwhile, I own a Remington 20 gauge.

Wolverine Gene

July 9th, 2019 at 4:18 PM ^

My preference would be a pistol grip shotgun for home defense. Easy to get the barrel around corners and the aim needs not be perfect in a very stressful situation. 

Also, a 9mm pistol can easily shoot through the walls and hit someone next door or unintended target. Then you could have civil and or criminal issues.  You are responsible for the bullet once it leaves the gun.  

Plus the racking of a shotgun can be a deterrent in itself. 

jsquigg

July 9th, 2019 at 8:29 PM ^

I've live in an inner city neighborhood for basically my whole life and have never felt the need to get a gun to protect myself.  It wouldn't make a positive difference if I did, anyway.

To each their own, I guess.

cKone

July 10th, 2019 at 12:45 PM ^

To the OP questions..  

Beretta PX4 is a good quality, reliable weapon.  I don't own one but have shot one a few times.  I had a Beretta 92 for many years and when I got my concealed carry permit found it to be too heavy for daily carry.  It was just too bulky and uncomfortable.

For daily carry I got a Smith and Wesson M&P Shield.  It has a very narrow profile and is comfortable enough that I almost don't know it's there when it's in the IWB (Inside the Waist Band) holster.  For a gun with a very short barrel I find it to be incredibly accurate.  That being said, I am not a big and tall guy, and friends of mine with much larger hands than me find it uncomfortable to shoot because of it being too small for their hands.

For cleaning a pistol I use Hoppe's No.9 Bore cleaner first on cotton patches followed by a wire bore brush and another few passes with the Hoppe's.  Finally I use Hoppe's Elite Gun Oil on patches.  I then go over the receiver with an old toothbrush and some of the bore cleaner on the dirty areas.  I wipe it clean with a dry cotton cloth followed by a small dot of oil on any parts that move or have metal on metal contact.  You can usually tell by the wear lines in the finish.

For a quicker cleaning I also have a product called Hoppe's Bore Snake.  It's essentially a piece of para-cord that has sections for each of the steps mentioned above.  one section has the wire brush built in another to dip in the bore cleaner and another for the oil.  Make sure you get one in the appropriate caliber for your gun.  you simply put the solvent and oil on the appropriate sections and run it completely through the barrel several times and the bore is clean.  You should still disassemble and clean the receiver frequently.

Finally I do agree with the other on here with using an AR-15 for home defense, but as someone who is just getting familiar with firearms, you may find a pump action shot gun with buckshot or some other heavy load for home defense to be more your speed.  a bit less reliant on accuracy in a stressful situation like defending from a break in and plenty intimidating when a criminal is staring at such a large diameter barrel pointed in their direction.

Take as many defense and shooting courses as you can.  If nothing else you may gain a new and enjoyable pass time.

Hope you find this useful.

Panther72

July 11th, 2019 at 7:08 PM ^

Smith and Wesson Shield single stack is easy to carry because its light and thin. The 9mm doesn't have the knock down power of my Glock 45 cal modle 30 but it's much skinnier and more compact. 

UserAbuser

November 2nd, 2019 at 6:25 AM ^

Hello friends. To be honest, I don't really interested in guns and this stuff 'cause this is not my aesthetics but I often see the shops which sell the best ar 15 under 1000. In my opinion, this is a really beneficial offer that should be taken into consideration. My brother often admires such sales.