OT- Detroit Tigers 9/2

Submitted by BiSB on
Jhonny Peralta has made 3 errors through 5 innings. One more and he gets a set of steak knives. 3-1 Tigers, Top 6

MH20

September 2nd, 2009 at 9:00 PM ^

I would say he is "in the running" for ROY (as in, in the top 3). I was about to make a comment about the gem he was spinning and he promptly gave up a homer to Hafner. Oops. 5 hits and 2 runs over 7 IP is still a very impressive start.

b-diddy

September 2nd, 2009 at 11:33 PM ^

porcello is definitely a long shot for roy. outside of the relief pitcher mentioned, that matt neimman guy (the rays pitcher verlander beat last week and faces again this weekend) is a pretty good rookie, and white sox 3rd baseman beckham is a nice all around player. one of those 3 will get it, i'd think. but thats no slight on porcello. bailey is 25. bekham is 23 in 2 weeks. neiman was in verlander's draft class. fact is, porcello has had one great month (may), one good month (aug) and has been a mixed bag otherwise. however, he is justifiably getting a ton of attention, and i wouldnt look at missing the roy as any indication of what kind of potential he has vs the other guys.