MSU playing this weekend to secure Michigan spot in the B1G Championship Game
Mentioned earlier in an update on B1G standings, but deserves a little more of a spotlight/discussion I think.
Assuming the Wolverines dispatch Rutgers and Indiana (In Brown Winovich We Trust), there is the delightful possibility that this weekend in East Landfill:
(1) OSU loses again and we all enjoy the ensuing meltdown in Columbus
and
(2) Sparty gets to enjoy handing us our ticket to the B1G Championship Game. Even when they win, they lose. Perhaps they can lock arms and walk across the field in the Big House to hand us the ticket.
I've seen comments about wanting OSU to win out to enhance the quality of our (inevitable) win over the Bucknuts. I can't see where that is at all necessary if we run the table and win the B1G. 12-1 definitely gets us into the playoff.
I also think that if OSU is NOT playing for a spot in the B1G CG, they will Bosa the remainder of the season and players will focus on not playing school and Urbz will realize he really needs to spend more time with the family.
November 5th, 2018 at 9:25 AM ^
Michigan fans should ALWAYS root for OSU to lose no matter the opponent or other implication, even against MSU.
OSU having a 3 or 4 loss season (or better yet two in a row!) would be really helpful to M getting back to winning more Big Ten CC, beating OSU more than 50% of the time, returning Michigan to being the top program in the Big Ten, etc.
If OSU's "down" year is 10-2 (lost to Purdue and Michigan), second in the Big Ten East, and a Rose Bowl trip , then they will continue to be perceived (along with Clemson I guess) as the 1b to Alabama at 1a, and they will continue to recruit at a level second only to Alabama.
Much better to have OSU lose 3 this year (Purdue, MSU, Michigan), and go to the Citrus Bowl (and hopefully lose to LSU or whoever).
OSU having 3 or 4 losses, finishing third (!) in the East Division, and going to a secondary bowl this year breaks the notion that Meyer's program is unstoppable. That opens up better results for M in head-to-head recruiting battles, etc., etc.
So all of this talk of "I'd rather Michigan beat a 1 loss OSU than a 2 loss OSU" is...failing to see the the longer arc of things.
And so what if a Sparty win over OSU means that MSU finishes second in the East division? As long a M avoids disastrous coaching hires (RRod and Hoke, and may Harbaugh remain for a decade more fingers crossed), MSU will never be as much of the threat to M returning to being the top program in the Big Ten as is OSU.
November 5th, 2018 at 9:27 AM ^
For one, I think OSU will win in EL. MSU rarely if ever wins games where a win would benefit us.
Secondly, the whole “ we as fans can be cocky all we want, we’re not the players or coaches” notion is false. They are not battle cyborgs that are programmed to win, they are human beings who watch TV, check social media and have daily interactions with fans. Players have talked about how much the general “buzz” around the program affects them. If everyone tells you all day every day that you’re awesome, that you’re going to win this and that..it’s hard for anyone not to let that influence you, it’s almost impossible for a 18-23 year old man who already naturally has a ton of bravado. Coaches can say what they want, they cant control minds. Thats why upsets and trap games are a real thing.
November 5th, 2018 at 9:31 AM ^
Sparty's culture is such that if they know this, they will throw the game. I'm not joking. . .
November 5th, 2018 at 9:36 AM ^
I think with a team like we have this year, we want to do things on our own. If we're worried about beating OSU, then we will have big problems if we do by chance get in the playoffs......
I will be rooting for 1 team Saturday. And that's the one playing in NJ. Could care less what Sparty does. That's in the rearview mirror
November 5th, 2018 at 9:38 AM ^
I really don’t care what happens in other games. Just win ours. Not worth the energy to worry about CFP since it’s up to a bunch of douche nozzles to pick their 4 favorite teams.
If we win out we should be in the CFP, but I’m not going to lose any sleep over it. I’ve seen Michigan screwed over too many times by decisions from people who don’t even know how to tie their own shoes.
November 5th, 2018 at 9:50 AM ^
AN OSU gets a chance to get their "The" back from MSU (which they lost to Purdue, who then lost it to MSU).
And then we can take it!
November 5th, 2018 at 9:55 AM ^
After looking like a juggernaut at the beginning of the season OSU is now looking mortal. Personally, I'm trying not to think about OSU right now. 1 week at a time. What I want to see this Saturday is for us to jump out to a huge lead quickly and then get Peters a bunch of snaps. He's the #2 now and really is in need of some game-time reps.
November 5th, 2018 at 9:56 AM ^
Obviously I want it all, but a Big Ten championship has even more value to me than a CFP bid. It is silly to not want that CCG bid to be guaranteed in advance. No matter its record, there are scarce annoying hot takes this offseason if Michigan wins the Big Ten**. They may even go extinct.
**("Oh yeah, Harbaugh can with the Big Ten, but he's never been to the CFP" is a terrible take. If that's how the season plays out, I welcome that take gleefully ... and the unfathomably sad Spartan or Buckeye to utter it)
November 5th, 2018 at 12:25 PM ^
Winning the Big Ten was always the main goal before the BCS. Since the BCS/CFP are still just glorified popularity contests, I still care more about winning the conference.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:00 AM ^
12-1 is not an automatic trip to the playoff. If Georgia wins out, beating Bama in the SEC title game, we are out. Both UGA and Bama would go ahead of us.
November 5th, 2018 at 12:27 PM ^
I would not count on that - would be hard to put in Bama (no championship and late season loss) over a 1 loss P5 conference champ (possibly 2 depending on the Big 12).
November 6th, 2018 at 5:34 AM ^
They had no championship and a late season loss last season too.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:14 AM ^
Hard to imagine MSU winning that game mainly because Haskins will probably light them up through the air. And MSU doesn't have the offensive firepower to keep up. Maybe the over is a good bet.
November 5th, 2018 at 2:33 PM ^
They came close to beating OSU the year they went 3-9, Mork went for 2 late and didn't get it.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:19 AM ^
Between the risk of Alabama losing and OU/WV pushing from behind, I think we definitely need OSU to beat MSU.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:25 AM ^
1. You people wanting OSU to win out prior to the Game are weird. It's like we're choosers rather than the beggars we really are. How about we win a Big Ten championship or just win The Game a bit before you all start mincing about what kind of bow rests on top of it all? Further, you would prefer risking an OSU game where OSU can take away all the good feels from this season and win the conference vs a game where even if they win we still play for and likely win the Big Ten championship, shutting up most Harbaugh haters? Just weird, all of you.
2. You do realize the more OSU loses, the more recruits we take from them right? That if OSU goes 0-13 we likely become much more likely to dominate recruiting and more likely see ourselves into a national championship right? Or doesn't any of that register? Can any of you guarantee that if Michigan had lost 15 of 17 to OSU back in the day that Ohio guys like Woodson and Howard choose to go Blue over the home team? Think men, think. Down with OSU and may they lose every game always.
3. Mortgage your house on OSU to cover this weekend on Sparty, who will likely throw the game because never forget that undermining Michigan is the beginning, middle and end to all Sparty existence. I can't recall a single time Sparty helped us out in a situation like this in following Michigan now going on 40 years. Don't expect it to start this weekend either.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:28 AM ^
It is HUGE for us if Sparty wins this game, which has to eat Dantonio alive. Good.
But this game is intriguing nonetheless. This past weekend, MSU had the luxury of playing against a Maryland team that had been through a week of non-stop drama and team morale had to have been at an all time low. Even so, Sparty had so many damn bounces go their way. They fumbled the ball into the end zone and were able to fall on it for the touchdown. Later, Lewerke threw what should have been a horrid pick six but the stupid Maryland player fumbled the ball into the end zone at the 1 and MSU fell on it for a touch-back. Their defense is good but their offense is kind of meh and Lewerke still doesn't look good throwing.
OSU's problems are the same and they continue. I was shocked how quiet that stadium was against Nebraska even when they were up 16-7.
This game will be like two assholes fighting in a bar. One will win but in the end, they're both still assholes.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:31 AM ^
Just win and it will fall into place.
MSU playing OSU are two turds in a toilet duking it out.
Either way...an OSU loss helps Michigan and a MSU loss hurts MSU. MSU has one good win on the year aginst PSU and that doesn’t look very impressive now either.
go blue!
November 5th, 2018 at 10:35 AM ^
Not sure I agree with the "inevitable win" statement. As we've all seen before, records don't mean much when it comes to rivalry games.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:39 AM ^
"12-1 definitely gets us into the playoff."
If ND and Clemson win out, OSU loses to MSU, and a one-loss Georgia beats an undefeated Alabama in the SEC championship, there's nothing "definite" about Michigan getting into the playoff.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:47 AM ^
A 12-1 Michigan team with a conference championship beating 4 ranked opponents (2 on the road) is more impressive then Alabama. Especially since Michigan held all to season lows. So if Alabama loses to Georgia it would be 1. Clemson 2. Nd 3. Georgia 4. Michigan. 5. Alabama.
If Michigan don’t take care of business...wisc is a top 10 team being 7-2, MSU is a top 15 team being 7-2, psu is a top 10 team being 7-2. Michigan dropped them and made them all look very bad doing so.
Alabama has one good win...against a now 2 loss LSU team and decent wins against unranked Texas am and ole miss. They play miss state who is ranked 21 and an unranked citadel and auburn to finish the season. They would also have no conference championship. Can’t let a team in just on a name alone.
November 5th, 2018 at 10:41 AM ^
I don’t give a fuck what Sparty does. We will win the division after we beat osu in Columbus. Don’t need any help from nobody!
November 5th, 2018 at 10:44 AM ^
Did the national pundits care back when Henne, Hart, and Long could barely play due to injuries? NO
Did they care that Gardner and Shoelaces were hurt for The Game? NO and NO
Did they care that O'Korn was playing because Speight and Peters were hurt? NO and NO
OSU can burn to the ground, there has been FAR too many instances where we have been short handed in the Game.
I want everyone good to go, I want OSU to lose, and I want to curb stomp them right there in front of their fans.
No one will give a damn how you won a Championship, there will be no '*', no exception clauses in the history books.
Just WIN DAMNIT!
November 5th, 2018 at 10:53 AM ^
Agree!!!
and is it just me or after every time michigan crushes a team they are making excuses for injuries?
Hornibrook didn’t play the next week.
lewerke didn’t play the next week.
mcsorley got pulled mid game.
maybe Michigan really is just beating the shit out of players.
they all started against Michigan and could hardly finish...
November 5th, 2018 at 11:28 AM ^
Agreed. No astricks are in the history books.
Win big in the first half of Indiana & Rutgers, get the starters off the field and rested for the big show down. Let’s hope little bro comes through on Sat
November 5th, 2018 at 11:25 AM ^
Honestly, I would like to secure a big ten championship birth no matter what. I would rather the buckeyes come in with nothing to play for other then pride. They are a talented enough team that accidents can happen with 1-2 motivated players. Coming in helpless know that there is nothing they can do and nothing they can get from a W......... I will take it. And, if it gets us into a nice bowl game vs. NOT Bama instead of a playoff game vs Bama.... I will take 12-1, B1G champs, in a nice bowl, feeling snubbed by the committee to motivated for next year ANY day of the week. (Not saying I wouldn’t celebrate being in the playoffs, but I would be content with the above outcome. Especially if it means the Rose Bowl)
November 5th, 2018 at 12:31 PM ^
I've seen comments about wanting OSU to win out to enhance the quality of our (inevitable) win over the Bucknuts. I can't see where that is at all necessary if we run the table and win the B1G. 12-1 definitely gets us into the playoff.
Probably not, but with Northwestern looking like the overwhelming favorite to come out of the West, possibly at 7-5, I could definitely see a lot of discussion from the powers that be of a 1 loss OU getting in over them. Or the worst case scenario for Michigan which is a 1 loss Georgia team beating undefeated Bama in the SEC title game.
November 5th, 2018 at 1:33 PM ^
Would be priceless to see MSU beat OSU, we win out, then sit our guys against OSU.
November 5th, 2018 at 1:56 PM ^
Don't worry about OU...their Texas loss is looking worse and worse. Be worried about Georgia running the table & beating Bama in the SEC Championship. Assuming ND & Clemson stay undefeated, the committee will definitely take a 12-1 Bama over a 12-1 UM.
Regardless, Beat OSU!!
November 5th, 2018 at 2:17 PM ^
No they won’t if Michigan wins out. Michigan looks better and has a tougher schedule. Michigan/Harbaugh is just a big a draw as Alabama/saban and brings more revenue. Plus a loss the first week on the road by 7 to a playoff team is better than losing the last week.
November 5th, 2018 at 2:35 PM ^
They wouldnt take a non conference champ at 12-1 over a conference champ
November 5th, 2018 at 3:55 PM ^
Correct. Especially with the same record and tough schedules.
November 5th, 2018 at 7:38 PM ^
Calling a win over OSU inevitable hasn’t been paying attention the past decade or so. Probably want to focus on one game at a time. And maybe have some humility.
November 9th, 2018 at 2:43 PM ^
Forgive me if wanting to win the BTN East is my main concern. We haven’t won any titles in more than a decade. If Sparty beats OSU we are a virtual lock for Indy. We can still blow away OSU for added fun and ranking. But we can avoid a possible screw job in Columbus where everything is lost. First things first.