July 20th, 2012 at 10:47 PM ^

Actually, it was my question in the OP that was the joke that wasn't... um... gotten.  Fans get so fixated on ridiculous "head to head" recruiting "wins" or "losses."  It's silly.


July 21st, 2012 at 2:08 AM ^

Scouting and offering the right guys is way more important than winning mythical offseason recruiting battles (SEE Notre Dame football, 1994-PRESENT).  OSU fans are going to continue regretting that their coaching staff "lost" guys like Omameh, Fitz (120 yards on 20 carries against OSU), Ryan, and most recently Frank Clark, whether they got an offer or not. 

Then again, if their current coach had given a young dreadlock'd gentleman a chance to play QB, he'd probably still be at UF and who knows where they would be right now.  Perhaps it's all some kind of complex strategery I can't even understand.


July 20th, 2012 at 9:41 PM ^

Is it even commitable? Also, with him now offering a flip should be coming real fast at least according to bucknuts on message boards. I mean you all realize Urb's NEVER loses a recruit he offers or wants.

turd ferguson

July 21st, 2012 at 4:12 PM ^

Fair request but the difference:

The everyday Michigan fan goes to MGoBlog; Mlive gets the outliers.  The everyday OSU fan goes to Bucknuts; Eleven Warriors gets the outliers. 

And yes, the everyday MSU fan goes to RCMB with The Only Colors getting the outliers. 

I hereby endorse continued judgment on this front.


July 20th, 2012 at 9:58 PM ^

Lol so someone over at 247 posted a Twitter comment from Billy Price where he tells Alex at 11W (their TomVH wannabe) saying offering Dawson is a waste of time! Even ol boys for Ohio know it ain't happening


July 20th, 2012 at 10:06 PM ^

Dawson should mail him Billy Price's shredded t-shirt from the Columbus NFTC with a note: "I did the same thing to your letter"

Phil Brickma

July 20th, 2012 at 10:01 PM ^

If Urbz wants to waste his time by offering a solid UM commit, that's fine with me.

In all seriousness, Urbz does have some intriguing selling points that U-M doesn't . With Michigan, he is part of an AMAZING o-line class. With OSU, he would be THE guy because their current o-line draw sucks. It really depends on how he sees the positives and negatives of each situation.

Luckily, David seems like a bright, young man and chose wisely long ago.

Phil Brickma

July 20th, 2012 at 11:22 PM ^

For a kid hellbent on early playing time, being THE guy comes into play. I get what you are saying on the focus, especially pertaining to WRs, but certain players want to be the hero, the star, the focus of the team. It's hard to match that vibe when you are one of five blue-chippers on one recruiting cycle of one position group.

Perkis-Size Me

July 20th, 2012 at 10:21 PM ^

I know Dawson is a "solid" UM commit, but I don't feel safe until Hoke has his faxed LOI in his hands.

By the way, has anyone noticed that UM and OSU are set for the next few years of brutal wars in the trenches? UM bringing in studs of O-linemen, while OSU is doing the same on the D-line.


July 20th, 2012 at 11:27 PM ^

I wonder if this rather late offer means that the plans to clone Evan Lisle to beef up OL recruiting for 2013 have somehow gone south. All that Meyer is doing now is cementing his position as a bit of a recruiting poseur in the Big Ten. 


July 20th, 2012 at 10:36 PM ^

I thought I read somewhere that an OSU recruit said they were done recruiting O-line. Meyer doesn't seem like a guy who would lie to a recruit though, so it was probably a load of crap.


July 20th, 2012 at 11:12 PM ^

You nailed it.  He knows landing Dawson is a long shot, but he want to get some face time at Cass Tech.  Urban said he wants to successfully recruit in Michigan and Cass appears to have the most talent these days.


July 20th, 2012 at 11:29 PM ^

I can understand why he would want to get in the door at Cass, but I think it is pretty much useless on his part. It is our strongest pipeline and Wilcher will do everything he can to make sure his kids don't go to Ohio. Honestly I hope Meyer spends a lot of energy trying to recruit Cass because all it will do is waste a lot of time they could spend on other guys.

Mr Mxyzptlk

July 21st, 2012 at 5:11 AM ^

For obvious reasons, Michigan fans are blissfully unaware of a offensive line recruiting battle going on at Cass Tech for the services of Dennis Finley.  Finley is a 6-7 300 lb OT who is rated as a mid 3 star on all the recruiting sites except ESPN where he was awarded a fourth star (just barely).  Given the fact that most of the OL talent in the Midwest has already committed elsewhere, Urban Meyer is going after Finley pretty hard at this point I believe.  Michigan State wants him too as well as Wisconsin and Illinois and some lower tier schools too.

Unfortunately, there's just not enough room for every Cass Tech kid at Michigan.  Cough, cough....Delano Hill.


July 21st, 2012 at 8:15 AM ^

I agree with your general sentiment... there is just too much talent at Cass Tech for all of them to go to Michigan.  It's probably just a matter of time before another Cass Tech kid picks ohio.  It's similar to the state of ohio.  To expect Meyer to "lock down" ohio is kind of absurd simply because there is so much talent there, even if Meyer wanted all of them, he wouldn't have enough scholarships.

But we're not there yet with Cass Tech.  Your examples are both kids that did not get Michigan offers.  It will be interesting to see what happens with next year's class, as it seems the top Cass Tech kids for 2014 are more interested in looking around than in previous classes.  I sometimes worry that our confidence in this pipeline might be a little unrealistically high.


July 21st, 2012 at 8:39 AM ^

Also, there won't be enough room for all three (or even two) of the Cass Tech LBs, especially if 2014 OH Ferns commits.

It's just bad luck sometimes; there probably would have been room for Hill in this class if we didn't take three probable safeties in 2012 (Clark, Gant, Wilson).  There would have been room for Gibbs if Poggi didn't commit, and we didn't take a flier on Willie Henry last year.

But at least the Cass guys are getting solid D1 schollies at BCS schools;  hopefully, they won't end up biting us in the a$$ in the coming years.

Leaders And Best

July 20th, 2012 at 11:11 PM ^

Florida is rumored to have picked up six 2014 commits at their Friday Night Lights camp today.  Sorry for the threadjack.

Trevor Darling, Dalvin Cook, J.C. Jackson, Jacob McCrary, Joseph Yearby, & Kain Daub off the board for '14. All are Top 100 types from Fla.

My point with last tweet, NCAA tried to slow the recruiting process. They failed. It is speeding up, rapidly. More to come with FNL at UF.


July 21st, 2012 at 8:04 AM ^

Dawson said he was going to camp at Florida. Michigan fanbase flipped shit. Rumors of a possible decommitment flew. He talked to Hoke, cancelled the Florida trip, and reaffirmed his commitment for the seventy-eleventh time. All is well. 


July 21st, 2012 at 2:38 AM ^

Ended about the same time as Marcus Baugh's commitment around early April. Buckeye fans were more confident about Mike Heuerman than they were about McNeil. Once Baugh committed McNeil stopped showing interest because he "didn't feel welcomed anymore."