Goodbye Weis

Submitted by HartAttack20 on
It was ridiculous to watch Notre Dame fail over and over this season. I almost felt bad. Sadly, it is starting to seem more and more likely that Charlie Weis will get canned by those Golden Domers. I kind of want him to stay for the chance that he continues to mess up, but I also hate the guy. I realize everybody will want to give their sentimental goodbyes, so I'll give you that chance. Personally, I'm not good at the whole haiku thing, but the rest of you can go for it. Charlie Weis Haikus live here.

SysMark

November 29th, 2009 at 12:17 AM ^

That is really the perfect description. Remember this guy learned his deal under Parcells (even bigger windbag, and I am a Giants fan) and Belichick. His bluster stems from trying to live up to those two guys - it didn't work because he was simply in way over his head. This is the Peter Principle at its absolutely clearest - he went one large step beyond his capabilities.

outwest

November 28th, 2009 at 11:59 PM ^

We will soon be hearing news stories about how South Bend buffets are closing down and not because of the economy but because of the leaving of Charlie

UMalum1997

November 29th, 2009 at 12:02 AM ^

His great knack for putting together a charmin soft defense against either the pass or the run year after year. His ability to waste the talent of several 5 star recruits season after season. Thanks for keeping us ahead in the all-time winning %. Your undying efforts are appreciated.

Marshmallow

November 29th, 2009 at 12:10 AM ^

I think what Herbie says is right: why fire Weis? ND has been a 6-5 team for the last 15 years on average. The only thing that needs to change is the sense of entitlement held by the Irish fans. The way things seem to be going around here though, that might be a pot-kettle-black statement soon enough, unfortunately.

letsgoblue213

November 29th, 2009 at 12:17 AM ^

This is probably good for us short term, because now there's a higher chance of players like Clausen and Tate leaving. That would give us a much higher chance at winning next year. But, if they get a good coach, this is definitely going to be bad long term, unless somehow they find someone who can screw up more than Weis has.

jmblue

November 29th, 2009 at 12:48 AM ^

Weis will finish with a worse winning percentage than the dreaded Tyrone Willingham, who was the root of all the world's evil. I'd feel bad for the guy if he had actual sympathetic qualities. I'll never forget his brilliant line in one of his first press conferences: "It's X's and O's time now. Let's see who has the advantage."

Brodie

November 29th, 2009 at 12:53 AM ^

That's pretty much it. Like, if RichRod ends up failing I will be sad because I truly like the guy and want him to succeed as much as I want Michigan to succeed... but Weis had nothing going for him. There was no "WIN ONE FOR CHARLIE" sentiment in South Bend. He was a cold, mechanical dude who nobody really liked, even when he was winning 10 games. Ultimately, I think this is a good lesson for college teams. Personality is more important at this level than it is at the NFL level, for a variety of reasons. Hiring a guy who has no personality to speak of puts you at an instant disadvantage.

gobluesasquatch

November 29th, 2009 at 1:36 AM ^

Charlie was much more likable than his predecessor at Notre Dame. That is partly why he got the huge contract extension so early. He understood how to fire up the alumni base, how to bring back former players, get boosters excite. Ty Willingham had so little personality, it was easy to wack him after three years with no remorse - no one really knew the guy. The problem with Charlie Weiss is he wasn't very good at overall game management. But I'm sure New England will take him back in a heartbeat. Or maybe the Browns can hire yet another Belicheck disciple.

Brodie

November 29th, 2009 at 1:58 AM ^

That's not "likability". Weis talked the big talk about his schematic advantage and dragged Ara Parseghian out of the retirement home to talk to alumni groups and gave everyone huge "OMG HE GETS OUR TRADITION AND WE'RE GOING TO WIN ELEVENTY BILLION NATIONAL TITLES" boners. But when push came to shove, none of those people really liked Charlie anymore than they liked Willingham, who I'd agree was also dull.