OSU fan here. Given that it is slow, I thought that I would tip you off that OSU fans expect there to be a lot of arguments the next two years regarding whether Rashan Gary or Nick Bosa is the better player.
Arguments for Gary: you already know them. I do not dispute any of them, and expect him to be elite.
Arguments for Bosa: OSU press has reported that OSU coaches think that (1) Nick has been better than his brother Joey at the same age (in HS and as college freshman). I think each team would be thrilled if either player has the career that Joey did (http://www.ohiostatebuckeyes.com/sports/m-footbl/mtt/joey_bosa_854118.html) (2) Nick was the best player on the team last year (Nick played limited snaps, particularly early, since he was recovering from injury).
Freshman stats: I think they are meaningless, since both players were behind excellent upper classman. If you are neverthelss curious, Nick's were a little better -- 5 sacks/7 TFL for Nick v. 1/5 for Gary.
Obviously, too early to call, and each team likes there guy.