lhglrkwg

September 4th, 2012 at 12:54 PM ^

Given that it's early in the season I think people a) still haven't figured out that both MSU and Boise are overrated to some degree and b) people don't know exactly who else to vote for.

I think Boises gonna be like a 9-3 MWC team and State's probably going to be an 8-4 B1G team

Brhino

September 4th, 2012 at 12:54 PM ^

We're (a significant contributing factor in a different team becoming) number one!  We're (holy shit did you see what Alabama did to our D-line no wonder they're) number one!

nyc_wolverines

September 4th, 2012 at 1:13 PM ^

Yes, we need to remember this is a season and that the media hype of a blow-out will give way to the typical media line of  what is a team's "Body of Work" and "late season Michigan" versus "early season" Michigan.

 

Media builds you up, tears you down, then discusses the "underdog comeback".

turtleboy

September 4th, 2012 at 5:01 PM ^

Michael Poll I made up last night

1 Bama (win against top 10)

2 USC

3 LSU 

4 Oregon (highly convincing win)

5 FSU (highly convincing win)

6 Oklahoma (struggled to score for most of the game)

7 Georgia

8 Arkansas

9 SC (ranked those 3 by recent gameplay)

10 Michigan State (unconvincing win, but beat a ranked opponent)

11 West Virginia (soundly beat a cupcake, who also scored a lot on them)

12 Clemson (beat a psudo ranked Auburn)

13 Virginia Tech

14 Nebraska (most convincing win in the B1G)

15 Wisconsin (got passed a little after I reranked the B1G)

16 Texas (push)

17 Ohio 

18 Oklahoma State (huge blowout against tiny opponent)

19 Michigan (above didn't-play TCU)

20 TCU (didn't play)

21 Louisville (beat an SEC team, but it was just Kentucky)

22 Kstate (convincing win)

23 Stanford (close scrape)

24 BYU/ND (couldn't decide but gave the opponent edge in Wazzo over Navy)

25 Florida (lol)

not TOM BRADY

September 4th, 2012 at 1:03 PM ^

MSU is not the 11th best team. There QB is awful and cannot do anything. He looked like Steven Threet against Boise State. 

Where do people think Michigan would have been ranked if they beat Bama. I say 4, FWIW. 

BornInAA

September 4th, 2012 at 1:05 PM ^

The polls unwritten law is that unbeatens get ranked higher.

That said, I think Michigan is better than Clemson, South Carolina, Nebraska, Ok St,  and Virgina Tech.

I think we should be around 14 an will move into top ten if we beat MSU/Neb and beat Wisc in the B1G championship.

LSAClassOf2000

September 4th, 2012 at 1:51 PM ^

This is fair, I think. I believe that there is enough that we can walk away with even after the game on Saturday that says that we belong on this list. It is interesting to note that the average ranking of a Big Ten team in this poll fell two spots from about 12 to 14 (compared to an average drop of only one spot of ranked Big Ten teams in the AP poll). That doesn't mean a whole lot right now, but I have wondered if that is more or less the range we will inhabit if we do in fact go 9-3 (i.e., 9-2 the rest of the way). Would that be a 12-14-ish performance going into a possible BTCG?

Jfox1020

September 4th, 2012 at 2:19 PM ^

I do believe this is where we belong right now.. We did not belong in the top 10 ten (YET) or deserving of a first place vote. When all is said and done and we beat on the Big Ten then top 10 here we come...

Logan88

September 4th, 2012 at 2:22 PM ^

I agree that UM should be around #20 but I disagree with dropping them 11 spots for losing to a team that has now vaulted to #1 with a majority of the first place votes.

I will be VERY interested to see what happens to good SEC teams (e.g. Arkansas) who get taken behind the woodshed by Bama this season. Will they suffer such a precipitous drop as UM? Survey says: not likely.

wigeon

September 4th, 2012 at 6:53 PM ^

it was the manner in which we lost - we could not have looked worse on a national stage, particularly scheme/QB play and looking completely outmanned.

19 to 25 range sounds about right, and probably a realistic bracket where we should've been going into the game. 

 

 

BlueHills

September 4th, 2012 at 3:04 PM ^

Granted that Alabama is a phenomenal team, however, I don't think Michigan looks like a good Michigan team based on how our guys played. #19 may even be too high a ranking.

 

WolvinLA2

September 4th, 2012 at 3:07 PM ^

I feel like I'm the only one who watched the MSU-Boise game. Boise State looked like garbage, yet MSU wasn't really winning until the fourth quarter, and even then it was right down to the wire. MSU is really lucky Boise turned it over as much as they did, otherwise this game could have gotten out of hand. This Boise squad is not like Boise teams of the last half decade, and MSU almost got beat at home.

beachbum69

September 4th, 2012 at 9:12 PM ^

"Turned it over as much as they did"

I think that part is backwards.  MSU had several more turnovers than BSU did, including one before the half iirc in BSU's red zone.  BSU only put up 3 points on their own (offensively), so it should actually be that Boise is really lucky that MSU turned it over as much as they did because that's the only reason they were in it.  It could have otherwise been an MSU blowout and I HATE to imagine the slurping we'd be hearing if that happened.

WolvinLA2

September 4th, 2012 at 11:58 PM ^

Says the guy who still pretends to not be an MSU troll.

Look, no one is saying Boise is better than MSU. What I'm saying is that Boise isn't very good, and if they didn't have two untimely turnovers, they probably would have won. Which means MSU shouldn't be the #8 team in the country.

mgobleu

September 4th, 2012 at 5:06 PM ^

I dont really care where M is ranked right now. In fact, I wish every one of their opponents were ranked higher than them, because despite the throttling they took, I dont see a single unwinnable game on the schedule.

MGoClimb

September 4th, 2012 at 7:40 PM ^

This is a good spot.  About where I thought we would be following the loss to Alabama.  Perhaps we are better than some of the teams in front of us, but we have the rest of the season to prove that.  It's why the games are played.  

Bring on Air Force.  Is it Saturday yet?

TdK71

September 5th, 2012 at 8:28 AM ^

so that the Cowboy Classic game could generate maximum dollars for ABC and the SEC and B1G.

I like where we're at in the rankings now.

Just win and everything will take care of itself.