All Michigan Team-Who is yours?

Submitted by michman79 on
Here is my all-time Michigan team.  I grouped players by overall categry instead of position-specific so OL is tackle heavy and DL is end-heavy.... please forgive/ignore the bias towards more recent players, I'm only 30.  Would love to see others thoughts.

QB: Jim Harbaugh
RB: Tyrone Wheatley
RB: Mike Hart
WR: Desmond Howard
WR: Anthony Carter
TE: Jay Reimersma
OL: Jake Long
OL: John Runyan
OL: Steve Hutchinson
OL: Dan Dierdorf
OL: John Elliot

*Honorable Mention: Tom Harmon (HB), Jamie Morris (RB), Braylon Edwards (WR), Jon Jansen (OL), Steve Everitt (OL), Jeff Backus (OL)


DL: Glen Steele
DL: Lamaar Woodley
DL: Mark Messner
DL: Brandon Graham
LB: Jarret Irons
LB: Erick Anderson
LB: Ron Simpkins
DB: Charles Woodson
DB: Tripp Welbourne
DB:  Tom Curtis
DB: Ty Law

*Honorable Mention: Sam Sword (LB), Chris Hutchinson (DL), David Harris (LB), Calvin O'Neal (LB), Jason Horn (DL), Leon Hall (DB), Allan Branch (DL), Marlin Jackson (DB)

Special Teams:

Punter: Zoltan Mesko
Kicker: Remy Hamilton
Returner: Steve Breaston

Michigan has had so many great players.  It is hard to remember them all.  I would love to hear others thoughts and please forgive me f I have missed some obvious ones; going off of memory.

Papochronopolis

September 17th, 2009 at 11:31 PM ^

As much as I loved Tyrone, I'd put in Tim Biakabatuka, based on his single season Michigan rushing record (1818 yds w/ 6.0 ypc!) and his 313 yd performance against an undefeated OSU team. Tyrone was still sick with it (6.1 ypc for career [wow]) but I think Tim still deserves a mention, he was quite talented.

BILG

September 17th, 2009 at 11:58 PM ^

Mike Hart never beat OSU, nuff said. I go with Ty, and Biakabatuka and Perry in 3rd...Yes, that Chris Perry that was just nasty in 03 and ran over OSU. Sam Sword and Ian Gold probably make my starting lineup. Receiver looks good, but at returner...gotta go with Desmond, and therefore since he is in the lineup....I would replace him with Braylon at receiver. QB is a tough one....Had Brady been allowed to start all year instead of the ridiculous Henson shared playing time crap, he was probably the best qb. That being said, Harbaugh was pretty sweet.

BlueDog

September 18th, 2009 at 12:13 AM ^

Although he was too small to be a dominating pro, I believe DT Greg Morton won a Defensive Player of the Year award in the late 1970s....and a personal favorite of mine was LB Steve Strinko was big and fast and hit Archie Griffin so hard they had to help him off. That alone should be worth an honorable mention.

MadtownMaize

September 18th, 2009 at 12:14 AM ^

Since you went strictly by catagory, no FB is mentioned. If you were choosing one I would take Chris Floyd with honorable mention to BJ Askew. QB honorable mention: Rick Leach, Chad Henne. Comparing some of the guys who played in a different era is tough, but its hard not to pick Larry Foote and Ian Gold at LB. Those two certainly had to deal with a lot more coverage than Anderson who primarily just fought off blocks and plugged gaps.

chitownblue2

September 18th, 2009 at 12:20 AM ^

I didn't really follow Michigan until I got to school there - in 1996. So, my team is really a "Since 1996" team: QB: Drew Henson HB: Chris Perry FB: Chris Floyd WR: Braylon Edwards WR: David Terrell TE: Jerame Tuman T: Jake Long T: John Jansen G: Steve Hutchinson G: David Baas C: Rod Payne DE: Lamarr Woodley DE: Glenn Steele DT: Rob Renes DT: Alan Branch LB: Jarrett Irons LB: David Harris LB: Larry Foote CB: Charles Woodson CB: Leon Hall S: Marcus Ray S: Ernest Shazor Players I felt bad leaving out: Anthony Thomas, Ian Gold, Lawrence Reid (he was so good before freak illness), James Hall, Dhani Jones, Marlin Jackson, Victor Hobson.

J.W. Wells Co.

September 18th, 2009 at 9:48 AM ^

Is that the same Mike Hart who was habitually injured, never beat OSU, only won one bowl game (which he almost lost due to two goal-line fumbles), had a five-loss season, and lost four games his senior year? Yeah, that guy definitely belongs on the list. He's the all-time leading rusher because M didn't have much else in the line of RB's during his four years. Wheatley and Biakabutuka split time, Thomas split time with whomever was left from 1997, and Perry waited for Thomas to graduate. Hart was the whole show for four years. Just the fact that he was so injury-prone leaves Hart off the list for me. I never saw *him* carry the ball 52 times at MSU. And I never once saw him win a race to the house. Great back, yes. Better than Wheatley, Biakabutuka, Perry, and Thomas? No.

johng

September 18th, 2009 at 12:20 AM ^

Tyrone and Mike were great but ... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAmliH79D6Q (check out the more info for his sick stat line) Heisman, College HOF, #1 pick in draft, essential to the ultimate creation of Summer School and NCIS. OK, maybe not the last one. But there was this too: http://michigantoday.umich.edu/2008/09/harmon.php If you're going back to put him on as honorable mention, you need to put him on the team.

Section 1

September 18th, 2009 at 2:41 AM ^

-Willie Heston -Tom Harmon -Ron Johnson I saw Johnson run for 347 yards on a day when it rained, then sleeted, then snowed. Ron Johnson was Michigan's Jim Brown. I only saw films of Harmon; he was beyond good. Heston was, by all accounts, the Barry Sanders of his generation. (It is a virtual certainty that if there had been a Heisman Trophy during Willie Heston's playing days, he'd have been the first two-time winner of the award. He was the clearly the best player on what was clearly America's best football team, two years running.)

EGD

September 18th, 2009 at 1:03 AM ^

are of Jamie Morris routinely carrying five- and six-man piles for 3+ yards, so he'd be on my #1 team for sure. Of all the great receivers, I don't think UM ever had anybody quite as dominant as Braylon--maybe Anthony Howard but his college career was a couple years before my time. Derrick Alexander was pretty damn hard at Mich., so was Amani. Desmond is my kick returner though. Some FG kickers who haven't been mentioned are Mike Gilette and JD Carlson. Those dudes were money. QB may be the toughest to pick. Grbac probably accomplished the most at UM, or or maybe Harbaugh. Brady is obviously the best UM ever produced if you consider the post-collegiate resume.

Section 1

September 18th, 2009 at 1:23 AM ^

-Barry Pierson -Tom Curtis -Charles Woodson -Rick Volk I actually rate those guys in that order. With the fabulous Woodson as Michigan's third-best defensive back. That is how good Pierson, Curtis and Volk were.

The King of Belch

September 18th, 2009 at 1:35 AM ^

You might want to check out a guy named Don Bracken. Blasphemy? Maybe. I couldn't care less. Bracken was great.

Section 1

September 18th, 2009 at 2:22 AM ^

Thermopolis, Wyoming (pop. 3187), and the Green Bay Packers. Bracken; Monte Robbins; Zoltan Mesko... I couldn't choose between the three of them...

Section 1

September 18th, 2009 at 2:08 AM ^

I used to think Don Bracken was the best punter I ever saw at Michigan. Even more spectacular was Monte Robbins. Is Monte Robbins the best punter on paper that Michigan ever had? Maybe.

Seth

September 18th, 2009 at 8:52 AM ^

Coach: Fielding Yost O-Coordinator: Calvin Magee D-Coordinator: Lloyd Carr Barwis. QB: Drew Henson (not used as such but could run) RB: Tom Harmon RB: Tyrone Wheatley FL: Anthony Carter WR: Braylon Edwards Slot: Desmond Howard LT: Jake Long LG: Steve Hutchinson C: Mark Donahue RG: Dan Dierdorf RT: Jumbo Elliott If I was running Carr's offense, I think I would have gone with Runyan or Maurice Williams on the right side of the line, and Hart/A-Train would be the tailbacks. Also, maybe the BIG Payne at Center. But lo, this is the Spread n Shred. I took Braylon over Terrell because he had a bit more speed and ability to MAKE PLAYS in space -- not that Terrell couldn't be slippery. I love the idea of Dierdorf and Elliott pounding guys on the right side, while Henson's backside is an impenetrable wall. That's also why I reached back into history to pluck out Donahue -- a fleet-footed pulling guard and unstoppable motor. Likewise, my two running backs would be an all-everything ninja who could catch, zip through lines, and maybe even throw, and still be able to block, while the other would be even better at MINOR RAGE than Minor, never fumble, and have a top gear that nobody could catch. Perry and A-Train were considered for that spot, but ultimately it was Wheatley's extra speed that won him the job. I hated not having Hart on here, but I wanted guys who could break away.

J.W. Wells Co.

September 18th, 2009 at 10:04 AM ^

Yost? In his most famous era, the Point-A-Minute teams, the forward pass was still illegal. The most free-wheeling and wide-open plays in Yost's most dominant time were reverses and end runs. Aside from the fact that clearly the best coach for RR's offense is RR, if you want to pick one of Michigan's great coaches of the past, why not Fritz Crisler? Check out the YouTube video of Crisler's Mad Magician backfield (Yerges, Chappuis, Elliot, and Weisenberger). There was some CRAZY stuff goin' on in that backfield. From a TIME magazine article on the 1947 team: "Michigan's sleight-of-hand repertory is a baffling assortment of double reverses, buck-reverse laterals, crisscrosses, quick-hits and spins from seven different formations. Sometimes, watching from the side lines, even Coach Crisler isn't sure which Michigan man has the ball." Tell me that doesn't sound like Brian's UFR rock-paper-scissors-candle bit.

Seth

September 18th, 2009 at 12:45 PM ^

I had to kind of imagine Yost was alive today, and thus knew about modern schemes. I wanted the guy who could adapt and get the best football out of his guys. I also wanted a man who could represent the program, and had an eye toward the future. Yes, the point-a-minute teams pre-dated the forward pass. And the magnificent run ended exactly after the forward pass entered football. But that's also the time when a lot of major programs rose out of the dust, and Michigan stopped playing nummy nums (which had the unfortunate side-effect of 5-game seasons). And yet in a time when there was no recruiting, Yost still hung on for almost another two decades, winning the Big Ten title five times out of the first nine years of our involvement, won two more national championships, and had four more undefeated seasons. You've heard of the Rose Bowl? That thing started because the West Coast wanted to show it could play football as well as the "real" teams. At the time, it was unheard of, and Yost traipsed into Pasadena and beat Stanford so handily the Cardinal left the field in the 3rd quarter, and the city felt an elephant racing a camel would be less lopsided entertainment going forward. But our coach had the foresight in 1902 to realize the value in what would become college football's signature bowl game for five generations. He also built the Big House, at a time when few imagined it was possible to put even half as many as it held that far from a major population center (automobiles were still pretty young). That, to me, sounds like the kind of football coach who transcends his time, and could have functioned at that level no matter what year it is. His guys were as tough as Bo's teams, as schematically sound (he was an engineer, remember) as Crisler or Rich Rod, and in a time before recruiting, made Michigan such a national power that he managed to hoard more top talent than Bo and Moeller and Kipke combined. Even when Michigan faltered for a decade in the middle of the 20th century, the tradition and the very stadium that Yost personally designed kept the program from sinking anywhere near irrelevance, and it's the cachet that he built that still makes Michigan the place that can, say, pull a guy like Rich Rodriguez out of his home state and a near national championship-caliber team. Michigan has had some fantastic coaches. But Yost is the best football coach who ever lived, period.

Njia

September 18th, 2009 at 9:08 AM ^

3 Rushing TDs 2 Passing TDs 4 PATs 3 Interceptions 3 Punts (50 yd avg) *EDIT* I just found Harmon's other stats from the OSU game in '40: 25 carries for 139 rushing yds Completed 11 of 22 passing attempts for 151 yds Returned 3 punts for 81 yds In all, he played for 59 minutes of the game and accounted for 371 of Michigan's total yards. Talk about a one-man wrecking crew. The MGoBlue site (it was from a Google cache -- no longer on the site) also states that when he left the game with 15 seconds left, the crowd at Ohio Stadium gave him a standing ovation; the only Wolverine so honored before or since. He kinda sorta sounds like a young lad we've got taking snaps at Michigan in 2009......

Six Zero

September 18th, 2009 at 3:14 PM ^

QB: Brian, of course RB: MGoObes RB: Formerlyanonymous WR: Michigan Student WR: Chrisgocomment TE: Dex OL: Misopogon OL: Big Boutros OL: MaizeandBlueWahoo OL: ChiTownBlue2 OL: MyrtleBeachMaizenblue DE: jg2112 DL: Sommy DL: Blazefire DE: ME! (I just wanna be the right DE) LB: Timmmaaay LB: GSimmons LB: The Other Brian DB: Dex DB: MCalibur DB: ShockFX DB: of course, Tom VanHaaren