Tater

January 7th, 2015 at 11:09 PM ^

Borges did a great job everywhere he went and had mixed results at Michigan after being forced to watch game tapes on a regular basis with David Brandon.  I bet he does great at SJSU and proves that Michigan was his "outlier."

Yeoman

January 8th, 2015 at 12:34 AM ^

He came in mid-season when they were in total disarray--they'd just given up 550 yards rushing to BYU the week before he was hired--and by year's end he'd somehow lifted them to #31 in dFEI.

And SJSU's defense last year was a great improvement over the year prior. They were #115 out of 125 in 2013, #74 last year. 74 may not seem all that great but it's better than anyone in their division except SDSU.

Jinxed

January 8th, 2015 at 12:17 AM ^

HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Tony Franklin installed the spread in Auburn with 8 days of practice after Borges was let go and that was enough for Auburn to have its best offensive game of that season.

Yeoman

January 8th, 2015 at 12:48 AM ^

...that was winning games 3-2 the following season and getting Franklin fired halfway through.

You're probably the only person that remembers the Tony Franklin era at Auburn as a success. He lasted seven games and put up something like 13 ppg if you don't count the cupcake games.

growler4

January 8th, 2015 at 10:49 AM ^

Stop with this nonsense. You weren't there and have NO idea to what extent DB had any interaction with the staff or ANY influence on game planning.

The staff and players are accountable for THEIR successes and failures. DB was likely as responsible for game plans as Hoke and Nuss were for Gardner's lack of field vision and inconsistency.

BIGBLUEWORLD

January 7th, 2015 at 11:59 PM ^

I'm surprised how some people have forgotten that Borges said Denard Robinson would improve in his second year, and instead he got worse.  Al did a lousy job for Denard.  

Remember that?

And what about how he used to throw the players under the bus with his B S, "They didn't execute."  That is disrespectful to the players.  Who's responsible for not teaching them how to properly execute?

How about watching the game while our wives or girlfriend or ten year old kid told us the play he was going to run next?  

He didn't give our football players the best opportunity to succeed, which they deserve.

 

 

Danwillhor

January 8th, 2015 at 2:27 AM ^

but nothing he said was false. My sister's (who know nothing about the intricacy of football) would often correctly guys what we were going to run when we used then to prove a point. They'd seen enough out of the corner of their eyes watching "the guys" watch UM games to know what was coming. He'd call one, maybe two decent games a year. He threw players under the bus. He didn't recruit outside of AA. QBs regressed under his watch. Etc. The guy slowly craters offenses and he's an arrogant dick. I've met him. That is fact.

xtramelanin

January 7th, 2015 at 11:15 PM ^

than most of our favorite DC's and OC's if i'm not mistaken.   and he got hired by RR to run a defense he'd never run before and with only 28 scholarships on his side of the ball.   easy to cast aspersions, not so easy to actually put in proper perspective. 

xtramelanin

January 8th, 2015 at 5:46 AM ^

when he showed up.  he had b. graham (we now know his true name was magnus) and one particularly good corner who left early iirc.  then he had craig roh who greg thought very highly of even though roh was small for his position, and greg had/made walk-on kovacs into a stud- said he loved the guy, loved his heart and his head and didn't care that he was the slowest safety in the big10.  i'm sure i'm forgetting a couple of guys, but  i would like to see the comparison with other P5 programs about inheriting a team with only 28 schollies on one side of the ball (and not a lot of great ones) to see just how rare that is. 

then run that 3-3-5 D, which i personally have never run nor have i played or coached against.  i don't think it is a great D, especially for the B10.   i don't know many college teams that run it nor do i think i have ever heard a single pro team run it, but would be curious to see if that's accurate. 

Class of 1817

January 8th, 2015 at 2:01 PM ^

Again, agreed on all points.

It's just the fact that anyone on this board could've led Michigan's defense to The Worst in the Program's History.

I have a feeling that some people on here could've actually led them to Not The Worst in the Program's History...if even only by a few yards.

Compare that to a professional coach...it's just bad all around, that's all. I'm glad it's over. Watching M run a 3-3-5 vs Wisconsin was one of the worst things I've ever seen on any level of football.

State Street

January 7th, 2015 at 11:13 PM ^

What if I told you, you could log onto an FBS programs' football roster and see "Offensive Coordinator: Al Borges; Defensive Coordinator: Greg Robinson" and it'd be real.