2019 Recruiting Board

Submitted by Gentleman Squirrels on June 24th, 2018 at 4:09 PM

Thought it'd be good to look at our recruiting board for the class since it seems we're getting a bunch of commits soon and we're expected to have a mid size class that is half full already (total is expected to be around 20-24)

  • QB (1)
    1. Cade McNamara - committ
  • RB (1-2)
    1. Eric Gray - 25% CB
    2. Zach Charbonnet
    3. Wandale Robinson (could be being recruited for the slot)
    4. Giles Jackson - offered recently and immediately visited
    5. Isaiah Spiller (long shot)
  • WR (1-2)
    1. George Johnson III
    2. Cornelious Johnson
    3. Quintel Kent
    4. Kyle Ford (long shot)
    5. Jammie Robinson
    6. Asa Turner
  • TE (1-2)
    1. Erick All - commit
    2. Isaiah Foskey
    3. Josiah Miamen
  • OG (3?)
    1. Jack Stewart - commit
    2. Nolan Rumler - commit
    3. Zach Carpenter - commit
  • OT (3-4)
    1. Karsen Barnhart - commit
    2. Trente Jones - commit
    3. Trevor Keegan - 60% CB
    4. William Harrod - 100% CB
    5. Danielson Ike
  • WDE (3-4)
    1. Stephen Herron Jr. - commit
    2. Gabe Newburg - commit
    3. Zach Harrison (long shot but one can hope)
    4. Aeneas Dicosmo - 20% CB
  • SDE (2-3)
    1. Chris Hinton - commit (possible move to DT)
    2. David Ojabo - 88% CB
    3. George Karlaftis (Purdue legacy and commit)
  • DT (2-3)
    1. Mazi Smith - 100% CB
    2. Rodas Johnson - 18% CB (but recent CBs to Wisconsin)
    3. Tyrece Woods (not sure if committable offer yet)
    4. Jeffrey M'Ba (might be a wait and see situation to see how he performs in his first year at St. Frances Academy)
  • LB (2-3)
    1. Charles Thomas - commit
    2. Joey Velazquez - commit (VIPER)
    3. Quavaris Crouch (maybe RB too)
    4. Lance Dixon
    5. Kalen Deloach
  • CB (1-2)
    1. DJ Turner - 100% CB
  • S (1-3)
    1. Quinten Johnson - 100% CB
    2. Lewis Cine
    3. Daxton Hill
    4. Jamal Hill (idk if committable yet)

Comments

Georgia Avenue

June 24th, 2018 at 5:17 PM ^

Harding committed to Hoke, first of all.

Second, none of these guys signed with Michigan. So who cares? What this is supposed to prove? That Jim Harbaugh is a bad judge of talent because he took commitments, then recruited better guys and processed the ones he wasn't as high on?

Bluey

June 24th, 2018 at 5:23 PM ^

Harding did commit to Hoke, then stayed committed to Harbaugh for 10 months.

As for your 2nd question, I'd say it proves Harbaugh doesn't exactly exercise good judgement when it comes to deciding who to accept commitments from. He has a habit of saying yes to any and everyone who comes to campus. Tosses out scholarship offers like candy. Those guys were just in 2016. Anyone else remember Chase Lasiter, Anwuan Johnson, and Carter Dunaway? 

Mr Miggle

June 24th, 2018 at 5:55 PM ^

Harding stayed committed to Harbaugh, but every recruiting insider said he wouldn't be part of the class. Harbaugh couldn't publicly rescind the offer, so it was up to Harding to announce what he was going to do whenever he was ready. 

Harbaugh was rightly criticized for accepting commitments, then pulling the offers. He stopped that practice shortly after the 2016 class was signed. 

 

rainingmaize

June 24th, 2018 at 8:10 PM ^

Ironic that you left out guys like Mckeon, Evans, A.J. Dillon, St. Juste, Metellus who also were very lightly recruited but either shot up the rankings after they committed or look very promising. 

 

This isn't rocket science in what Harbaugh is doing. A lot of camps haven't taken place yet, senior years haven't been played, and recruiting sites are still evaluating players. Its clear Harbaugh recruits guys with a lot of potential, but knows when to move on if they don't develop the way they are supposed to. 

 

Also, I sure hope Blue Balls over here is so negative because he wants someone to address his concerns, because if his idea for fun is lame ass attempts at trolling on a message board, it doesn't bother me although I feel really sorry for his life. 

KC Wolve

June 24th, 2018 at 8:23 PM ^

Completely agree. Jim Fucking Harbaugh obviously has no idea what he is doing. If only he would hire an obnoxious teenager that spends his free time littering every thread on this board with the same drivel over and over. Better yet, maybe you could just replace him and get those 5 Star kids that are just sitting there and waiting for someone to say the magic words and then they will come to Michigan. 

Winchester Wolverine

June 24th, 2018 at 5:24 PM ^

He doesn't want to generate discussion, man. Just arguments. He enjoys making people upset online, which is funny, because whatever person is sitting on the other end of that username is one of the saddest dudes I've ever seen. At this point, if we're going to respond, we should comment something like "get a life".  Maybe if we say it enough times he will.

Space Coyote

June 24th, 2018 at 5:22 PM ^

Reese led Florida in tackles and 2nd in TFL as a RS FR.

Weaver started 5 games for Pitt as a RS FR.

Falcon was no longer a take when he got injured again.

Enis had off field problems but was a talented RB.

Scott didn’t qualify at Marshall, so that’s also a big reason he wasn’t a take to UM. No saying his play on the field.

Vic was wanted as a LB, no saying how that could have worked out had he started there.

Harding committed to Hoke effectively (day he was fired I believe) when he was a highly regarded prospect; was a mid 4 star at one time.

Richardson made 3 starts as a true Soph at Maryland.

so it seems some were better regarded than their rank

Farnn

June 24th, 2018 at 6:14 PM ^

Weaver is most definitely out performing his ranking, he was the first non-QB taken in the Pitt spring game and the team/fans think he will be great.  The rest there are legit reasons they haven't worked out and Space Coyote gave a good breakdown.  Plus, even your prized 5 starz aren't 100% hit rates.   Just going by 2016 top 10, Eason lost his job and transferred, Paterson was a mixed bag and according to Ole Miss fans was losing his starting job, and Ben Davis has played in 1 game at Alabama.  For the top 10 players in the class, that's 30% who hasn't done much at all.

Farnn

June 24th, 2018 at 7:48 PM ^

Viramontes-Michigan wanted at LB, he has kept trying to make QB work

Falcon-Injuries, Michigan realized and put him on track for a medical before his senior season

Enis-Legal issues

Scott-Qualifying

Harding-Not a Harbaugh recruit and stayed "committed" while he looked for another school

Richardson-Played as a true sophomore and started several games but couldn't stay healthy

Every player who is healthy and playing on a college team is exceeding their rankings.  

SMart WolveFan

June 24th, 2018 at 5:52 PM ^

Camp offers, increase the spotlight on camps: "if you camp, you can earn an offer no matter what bluey sez", increase the players profile so he can get better offers even if he probably won't stick with the class.

Because David Reese was a player they liked, they didn't have room to EE him so he went to Fla. but you probably would say his offer wasn't committable.

Magnus

June 24th, 2018 at 8:21 PM ^

Reese is starting at MLB for Florida. Weaver had several sacks for Pitt last year as a backup. Richardson is projected as the starting SS at Maryland. Harding is projected as the starting MLB at Illinois.

Enis had off-the-field issues. Falcon had injury issues, and he was kindly told Michigan wasn't interested after he hurt his knee again (and he was recently medically DQed by WMU). Viramontes was a flyer as an ATH.

Sir Patrick Scott is the only guy with no known answer for why he's not contributing somewhere.

Caesar

June 24th, 2018 at 5:22 PM ^

I'm not really sure what to think. I usually don't buy the 'trust the coaches' talk, except Brian's articles have cast some doubt on the reliability of recruiting rankings given the industry's collapse/reorganization. Maybe Michigan really is snagging 2015's 4 stars in 2018 3 star (and below) clothing. Another thing not usually mentioned is Don Brown's fairly savant-like ability to nail down the right guys who fit his system; this is usually reflected in sharply upwards recruiting rankings after Michigan makes an offer. On the other hand, 3 3-stars at about the same time as a big recruiting weekend doesn't look too great. 

there_in_2005

June 24th, 2018 at 6:09 PM ^

bluey, this community does not want to hear your opinion, yet you don’t care and feel the need to continue to offer it. why are you here? are you in that much agony that everyone else does not see things with as much negativity as you do? can you explain what is your point in continuing to act with so much negativity? do you take pleasure in making this experience worse for almost this entire community?