Michigan's Prospects for 2011-2012 Director's Cup

Submitted by WolverineBlue on

As you most likely know, the National Association of College Directors of Athletics (NACDA) awards an annual Director's Cup to the nation's top athletic program, based on a points formula that encompasses all men's and women's varsity sports (more info here). Stanford has won the award for the past 17 years in a row, but Michigan has been among the top performing schools in the annual standings, finishing in the top ten in 14 of the 18 years the rankings have been compiled.

Unfortunately, the past two seasons have been down years, with Michigan placing 25th (2009-2010) and 15th (2010-2011). With some resurgent programs this year, I have been hoping that our maize and blue heroes could return to their rightful place in the top ten. I decided to  take a look at MIchigan's current status and forward-looking expectations.

In the last published update (3/22/12), Michigan fell from 5th place to 12th place in the standings. This Thursday, the updated Winter standings will be released, adding results for men's and women's basketball, men's swimming, and fencing. If my figurin' is correct, the updated standings should look something like this:

Rank Prev School Points
1 1 Stanford 876.75
2 7 Ohio State 707
3 4 Penn State 655.5
4 2 Florida State 636.5
5 9 Florida 612
6 5 Texas 583
7 3 Wisconsin 582
8 10 North Carolina 578
9 11 Texas A&M 526
10 12 Michigan 517.75
11 34 Notre Dame 503.5
12 28 Duke 490.5
13 6 Minnesota 486.5
14 33 Louisville 464
15 25 California 453

Michigan should climb barely back into the top ten, while Ohio State shoots up to the number two spot, based not only on basketball success, but also on winning the recent national fencing championships held in Columbus. Unfortunately, the NACDA points accumulated by the Buckeye sabre-rattlers will exceed the total points registered by the combined efforts of Michigan's men's and women's basketball teams plus Ice Hockey team. Curses! Foiled again. Yeah, the scoring system is a little flakey.

Looking ahead to the home stretch, some schools are traditionally stronger in spring sports and are likely to make a late move. If we were to project that each school's spring teams will match their performance from last year and tally up the resulting standings (allowing points for no more than 10 sports in either men's or women's categories), the projected final standings would turn out like this:


Rank School Points
1 Stanford 1491.75
2 Ohio State 1164.05
3 Florida 1145.75
4 California 1132
5 North Carolina 1055.75
6 UCLA 1026.25
7 Duke 983.5
8 Virginia 967
9 Michigan 956
10 Texas A&M 950.5
11 Florida State 923
12 USC 913.75
13 Penn State 888.8
14 Texas 887.75
15 Oklahoma 839

Of course, there is likely to be a great deal of variance in actual results, but this should pretty well identify who the top contenders are.

Michigan's spring prospects vary by team. Wolverine men and women gymnasts and tennis racketeers are likely to pile up some points, but it will be a challenge to just match the output of last year's successful teams. Struggling golf teams on both men's and women's side will be hard pressed to make the NCAA's this year (still, we can hope). The inaugural men's lacrosse team will not register any NACDA points this year, but it can only help to have a men's and women's varsity lacrosse program in years to come. Prospects also do not look very promising for the baseball team or either track and field team. Surprise us, please!

On the plus side, there is room for improvement over last year from the young and developing softball team, the women's rowing team, and the women's water polo team. Gals, we're counting on you!

Summary

It is all but certain that Stanford will repeat as the trophy winner for the 18th straight year. Ohio State, Florida, and California are likely to battle it out for the runner-up spot.

Michigan has a very realistic shot at returning to the top ten. We should almost certainly improve over the past two seasons. Sadly, there is very little chance of a top five finish this year or of overtaking that ohio school. Don't taze me bro', I'm just crunching numbers here. I personally have faith in Dave Brandon's determination to continue to elevate the competitive level of all of Michigan's varsity programs and I expect that we will once again become a consistent top finisher in the NACDA standings. Go Blue, one and all!

 

 

Comments

hart20

April 3rd, 2012 at 6:47 AM ^

Is just insane. They've got the smarts and the athleticism aspects going for them, they just need some good looking girls on campus and they have everything that they'll ever need.

Stonecoldwolv

April 9th, 2012 at 6:51 AM ^

The sears cup only takes the schools top 20 sports. 10 for men and 10 for women. They don't take all of ohios sports. Don't get me wrong winning a nc in fencing or shooting is a hell of a lot easier than swimming or softball. Less teams you have to defeat. Michigan in 5-8 years will starting getting solid points in lacrosse.

cstalionsuofm

April 7th, 2012 at 6:18 PM ^

If you look at the biggest sport-- football-- Michigan clearly has the edge over Ohio. More wins, national championships, and even more wins over Ohio. Enough said!

Stonecoldwolv

April 9th, 2012 at 6:33 AM ^

Typical weak ass Michigan fan response. Our athletic department has dropped off big time. Only one sport matters and that is football. REALLY??? We finally beat Ohio and we clearly have the advantage over them? Get real we have dropped off big time with all our sports especially football. Ohio has dominated us in football. We like to fall back on our 11 NC that all happened before 1950's besides the 97 year. In the last ten years they have been to three NC games, won multiple BCS games, and have won 7 big ten championships. Ohio has more BCS wins then we do bowl victories. We have in that same period won 2 big ten championships, won 3 bowl games and have beaten Ohio twice. You are right we are far superior. Ohio's athletic department kills ours, there fans are better. They want to beat us in every sport and anytime Michigan shows up they have a club that shows up to cheer on Ohio in beating michigan in any sport. Our fans only want to win in football. During our football games over half our fans sit on there hands and complain when people stand up to cheer on our team. Basketball they embarass us. I cheer on all Michigan sports not just football like the majority of our weak fan base. We should be demanding more from our athletic department. It has become about making money and marketing not the product on the courts, the fields, the gyms, and the pools. I guess our athletic department and fan base go hand in hand. It's time for our FANS to wake up and smell the coffee. stop coming up with excuses and stop failing back on the 1900-1950's successes. Besides the 97-98 NC year our last 20 years in football have been unacceptable to Michigan standards.