Best and Worst: Minnesota

Submitted by bronxblue on October 6th, 2013 at 3:32 PM

Quick programming note:  I was traveling for the first half of this game, so outside of some radio coverage and phone updates I missed the first half. I did catch it on DVR, but skipped around when it became clear that about 1/3 of the half was Minny running a 16-play drive. I was back in the saddle for the second half.

I also apologize for the overly-effusive tone I’m going to take with this recap.  After Akron and UConn, I’m just happy to write about a win that didn’t come down to the last drive.  Please pick up your complimentary salt shakers before proceeding.

Beorst: Dominetive

This is undoubtedly a pretty hacky way of saying this, but UM's 42-13 win against Minny was one that didn't feel nearly as one-sided as it looks on paper. On one hand, at no point did UM seem to be in danger of losing the contest; the only reason the score was so close at halftime was because UM had 4 drives that whole half and Minny wasted about 1/3 of it on a single TD drive that would have had the same effect as a Cialis for every announcer born between the years of 1930 and 1970. UM went the whole game without a TO, which is some type of record, and UM turned both Gopher TOs into 14 points. UM had 67 more yards, basically matched Minny on the ground, and averaged over 6.6 yards per play to Minny's 4.5 ypp. Outside of UTL II, this was the most complete performance by the team this season, even with the major caveat that Minnesota isn't really that good at football.

At the same time, unstoppable Minny Tebow Mitch Leidner averaged 6.9 ypa with a TD and added 66 yards on the ground, and Minnesota as a whole was able to move the ball semi-effectively all day; they drove deep into UM territory a couple of times in the 4th quarter but kicked FGs instead of TDs.  Linebacker coverage continued to be an issue, as TE Maxx “The Extra ‘x’ is for Extra Max” Williams caught 5 passes for 57 yards and a TD and was consistently able to get separation.  And two weeks after the defensive line seemingly awoke with 4 sacks against UConn, UM was limited to a single sack (by MGoForgottenSon Cam Gordon), and 3 QB hits. 

Excuse me while I turn over this broken record, but the team remains a work in progress, and this most recent performance was a perfect embodiment its highlights as well as its lowlights.  It remains a team that can beat a semi-competent football team by 29 with only 8 drives, but also let you see the numerous seams that can burst at any moment.

Best:  “Inaccurate” Devin Gardner

I’ll get into the gong show that was the announcers in a bit, but Gardner had an incredibly efficient game throwing the ball.  True, he was “bailed out” a couple of times by his receivers in the same way THAT EVERY QB SOMETIMES GETS BAILED OUT FNHJSADKFNSADKJFNSAD…sorry, got a little heated there.  While he’s never going to have Taylor Martinez’s exquisite form on the long ball, Gardner still displayed a bit of happy feet that caused some balls to sail on him (a third-down incompletion that flew over Dileo’s head was pretty egregious) and/or hang up.  [To his credit, he also had a beautiful throw to Funchess in the 4th quarter that set up a TD]  Against a team with mediocre corners like the Gophers, his receivers were able to make adjustments and pull in catches reminiscent of Carr’s last game.  Still, 13/17 for 235 and no turnovers is a certifiable revelation after the past couple of weeks, and credit to Borges for compressing the playbook a bit and running a fair number of 2 and semi-3 receiver plays so as to minimize the pressure Gardner was under.  Listening on the radio, the announcers noted that UM’s protection schemes kept Devin clean for most of the game (only 1 sack), and Minnesota only hit him 2 other times.  Just like I thought it was silly to read too much into his struggles the past couple of weeks, I’m not going to proclaim this performance a turning point in Gardner’s season, but one hopes that player and staff are getting more comfortable with each other and that results in the type of playcalling that maximizes the potential for an offense that has the ability to score on anyone.

Worst:  Heel Announcers

There is a subset of visitors to this blog who find it inconceivable that people like professional wrestling, and references to it drive them to the comments to comment on how they gave up reading as soon as they saw it.  So for those people, feel free to skip to the bottom (you’ll only miss one semi-logical diatribe and maybe 1/2 a joke). 

Growing up, part of what made professional wrestling so much fun/infuriating to watch was the heel announcers like Bobby “The Brain” Heenan, Larry Zbyszko, and Jesse Ventura, who simultaneously trumped up the virtues of guys like “Ravishing” Rick Rude and Curt “Mr. Perfect” Henning while also pointing out the numerous logical inconsistencies that exist in the wrestling universe.  [My favorite being Heenan pointing out the stupidity of fans chanting “U.S.A.!  U.S.A.!” in a match between Canadian-born Bret Hart and kayfabe Japanese sumo wrestler Yokozuna.]  In a medium that relies so heavily on arm-wavingly-obvious black and white knights, these announcers were the ultimate trolls on the mic, trying to convince 8-year-old me that a finger to the eye was accidental and manager interference didn’t occur while absolutely going (rightfully) ballistic when Hulk Hogan or Sting did the same thing and the crowd cheered. 

Well, listening to this game on ESPN2 was about as much fun as listening to Michael Cole do anything during a match.  By my rough calculations, the announcers droned on about Devin Gardner’s “poor” accuracy for 8.5 quarters of the game, and complained about a 30-yard completion to Gallon because it was behind him.  Of course, later in the day the ESPN ticker pointed out that Gardner has the second-best QBR line of the day (94.2), and that included QBs who played against Temple, Georgia State, and Colorado.  I know announcers wants to add drama to events that organically lack it, and Gardner clearly had some issue throwing the ball at times.  But you could have left the door and some commentors from RCMB and Bucknuts could have taken a turn on the mic without people noticing a difference in quality.  I suspect ESPN doesn’t care one bit, but when UM fans are clamoring for Spielman (who is fantastic) and Mason or Herbstreit (less so), you know you’re having troubles in the booth.

Best:  Funch-sized

After finally conceding that Devin Funchess is mostly an oversized WR and not much of a TE, he exploded for a 7/151/1 TD line and showed just so scary he can be during the conference slate.  He definitely needs to become at least a competent blocker to assure his time on the field, but his frying pan-sized hands and superior speed destroyed a Minnesota secondary has had a rough go of it already this year.  Seeing how well Indiana cut up the PSU secondary this week, one can only hope that this type of performances by Funchess (and hopefully the rest of the receiving core)  will continue.

Best:  Offensive Line Optimism++

So yeah, I’m not an offensive line guru, and as noted above there was definitely a focus on increased protection, but it sure felt like the changes to the offensive line were for the positive.  Glasgow handled the snapping duties pretty well, with only one exchange issue I noticed, and the amount of inside penetration seemed markedly down from the past couple of weeks.  Bryant didn’t break anything, and Borges moved Jake Lewan around quite a bit to help establish the run, particularly at the start of both halves.  While the stats were still unimpressive overall (3.3 ypc), Fitz was able to average 4.6 ypc and, more importantly, only had 1 negative run.  Considering about a quarter of his runs against Akron resulted in negative yardage, this can only be considered a massive improvement.  Just as important, the running performance was generated about as “organically” as you can expect given the personnel, with Devin only running 7 times for 17 yards (including the one sack) and a TD.  Again, it is only one week, but the offensive line play was demonstrably better than the past couple of weeks, and even if that only grades out to average I’ll take it.

Best:  So That’s What Linebackers Do

In the linebacker section of HTTV, Brian and co. were effusive about this unit being a strength of the defense even before Taylor Ryan returns from injury.  It’s a unit with established players, some real depth, and the most likely place to see the words “heady”, “gritty”, and “disruptive”.  But for the first 4 weeks of the season, it was a unit that seemed a bit out of place, facing quick-striking passing attacks that picked away at coverages and limited Mattison’s ability to unleash his second-wave rushers from the second line.  But in this game, Minnesota seemed more than willing to test out the front seven early on, and even with some minor breakdowns I thought they acquitted themselves well.  Morgan and Ross combined for 19 tackles, including 10 solo, and also recovered a fumble.  Beyer added 4 more solo tackles, and as noted earlier Gordon picked up the one sack on the day.  Coverage remains an issue that, frankly, may just be a weakness that won’t disappear without turnover and maturation, but overall it was a good day by a unit that was playing left-handed for large portions of the season.

Supplementary Best:  Man in Black

(I know that’s super corny.  Deal with it).

Special kudos should go out to Jibreel Black, who forced a fumble and who seemed to hold his own against a determined Minnesota offensive line.  He’ll never be a great defensive tackle, but his speed inside has been a pleasant surprise this year, and as a long-time fan from back in the RR years I’m happy he’s having a good final season.  I’m also less down on the defensive line in general despite limited pressure because Minnesota’s offensive philosophy was clearly designed to not force Leidner to hold the ball for long, and perhaps my expectations have been ratcheted down enough such that this felt like a competent performance.  So, yea?

Worst:  You can love your knowledge-All the things you learned in college

You know you can't go on kicking yourself

Until you’re more sore and you can never be warm.

And through the darkest hurts of the MRI's

That eats away as if the sun burst from the sky.

Due to my extreme Alt-Nation-y musical preferences, I’m not one to usually talk about my favorite bands because, well, I’ve seen High Fidelity and am totally fine being a square.  But one of my favorite songs is College by Rogue Wave, a song seemingly crafted from the leftover crumbs of Simon and Garfunkel’s I Am a Rock.  It’s seemingly-depressing lyrics about the largely-immutable characteristics of people and the cracks in even the most cultivated veneers are dressed up in catchy beats and and clean melodies.  It’s either one of those songs where an artist experiments with the genre and listener’s expectations to craft something memorable, or they decided they had some lyrics and melody and what the hell, let’s throw them together and see what happens.

So what does this have to do with Michigan football?  Well, my initial take was in reference to the still-undisclosed (at the time of this post) injury suffered by Ondre Pipkins late in the game, a game that was well in hand and that came, seemingly, due to an innocuous collision.  Shortly thereafter, Kyle Kallis also went down with a less-serious injury, but still a reminder that injuries can happen at any time.  Given UM’s shallow depth at certain positions, injuries take on greater significant and, unsurprisingly, a vocal group of fans tend to emerge decrying the “negligent” nature of leaving guys out there when the outcome is decided.  I was going to argue that (putting on Herm Edwards hat) football is a violent, unpredictable game, the minute you play not to get hurt, that’s the minute you are most vulnerable, so players and coaches are hard-wired to suppress those concerns whenever possible.  Not that it was requested or even necessary, but I was going to call for the exoneration of the coaching staff with any injuries that might come from this game, and for others to not worry about it.

Of course, that’s a bunch of crap.  Not the part about the coaches and injuries – that’s the nature of the sport and it certainly wasn’t abnormal to leave in some players even with the game decided, especially when the limited depth means you only have a couple of players who could conceivably play those downs anyway.  No, my issue with this initial take was the tone, that I was somehow clear-eyed and objectively viewing the proceedings without a gnawing, festering sense of doubt and dread lurking just below the surface.  For the first time in what felt like eons (or, if you are a Gregorian calendar fan, 3 weeks), the team was playing pretty well in all three facets, and so ofcourse important people started to get hurt against freaking Minnesota.  This may be one of the less impressive 5-0 outfits you’ll see in football, but it is still an undefeated team and as such my illogical fandom expects this team to go 13-0 every year.  Injuries aren’t supposed to happen, and when they do all of those lost games and missed opportunities because Henne can’t move his shoulder and Antonio Bass tears up his knee come rushing back.  Ugly wins sting more than blowout losses, and the Horror and the last play of the Alamo Bowl run on infinite loops in my brain.  One should never stop, for it is bat country.

In my day-to-day operations I consider myself pretty even-keel and thoughtful, an “educated” man with an appropriate worldview, capable of understanding that two teams matriculating a piece of leather up and down a field doesn’t mean much compared to wars, disease, economic collapse, and the rest of the human condition’s underbelly.  But every Saturday in the fall, I devolve into the type of guy who watches youtube clips of famous motivational speeches from movies, who cries out for every phantom hold and missed pass interference, who only knows that the other team is full of cheaters, thugs, and idiots, and who wants nothing more than a victory and a “Hail to the Victors” as a nightcap.  I love my admittedly one-sided relationship with UM and its football team, but it has definitely helped to expose the inner lunatic that resides in me (and I presume in a significant portion of its fandom).


Worst:  Big Turrible

By gawd was that a depressing weekend in conference football outside of the UM game.  Michigan State and Iowa rock-fought to a 26-14 final that was every bit as painful as it sounds, and Nebraska beat another one of those schools from the Great Plains that feels like it was made up by a video game’s random-name generator, but not before giving up 17 first-quarter points.  Indiana pantsed PSU, proving that neither team is particularly good at defense but at least IU can score, and gave UM fans hopes of a nice 3-week lead-up to the first meaningful game of the conference slate in East Lansing.  And to top it off, NW totally unexpectedly and without precedent blew a late lead to OSU, giving us all another week of undefeated talk out of Columbus for what may be the least impressive 18-0 run in the history of college football.  I know people continue to question how good UM is, and I guess the answer is “not great, but have you seen these other guys?”  No teams other than Clemson, Stanford, and Oregon have really looked dominant all year (apologies to FSU and Louisville), but even the best teams in this conference look a clear step or two behind the leaders in the other AQ conferences besides the AAC.  On one hand it means UM will probably finish with a better record than I initially expected, but on the other hand it portends a pretty ugly bowl season.



October 6th, 2013 at 5:33 PM ^

...agreed. They pick up a storyline from the coaches during the week ("We're worried about his accuracy") and then pound that storyline, no matter what is really happening...

Double Wolverine

October 6th, 2013 at 6:45 PM ^

Funchess on the outside was a great move. He has great speed for his size and creates a huge mismatch on jump balls.

The o-line looked like it gelled a lot better. Pass protection was good and as you noted the YPC was better than it had been considering Devin didn't break a few big ones like in past weeks. Minny's best player is the DT, he was pretty much neutralized by the interior line all day.


October 6th, 2013 at 9:12 PM ^

Funchess's move to the outside was an excellent decision, and one you could see coming with the playint time received by Butt leading up to this game.  UM's wide outs have always blocked well, and i expect him to so so at least as well as those that have preceeded him, and the mismatches he creates are nightmares. A "TE" of his size that can run pass D1 dbs on a contnuous basis is a 6'4" wide receiver. Get used to it.    Also the attempt at a cialis joke was just that, a joke. Many of the people that fall into that age bracket would clean the floor with the kids growing up today toggling away in their free time instead of accomplishing something that gives the hint of becoming a man.  And any reference to wrestling somehow being entertaining, in any measureable form, pretty much made your 2 to 3 hours of work on this piece rather meaningless.  But keep trying. That's how one improves.


October 6th, 2013 at 10:36 PM ^

When that joker announcer started talking about the poor D Line play while Pickens was on the ground being tended to, I absolutely lost it. Incompetence is one thing, but have some damn class. 


October 7th, 2013 at 9:46 AM ^

I am not at all worried about the lack of pressure from the D-line based on this game. A couple things led to there only being 1 sack.

1. Minnesota ran and ran and ran, then ran the QB.

2. Minnesota's Tebow-running, Peyton Manning-throwing, football God of a QB never got past his first read before he took off to scramble. All you have to do as a line is hold off the rush for two seconds, and get away with a little holding before your QB has already gotten past the line of scrimmage. 

3. Line stunts. Which are effective on long developing passing plays, but not much else. Especially if you're trying to contain a rushing QB. A line stunt is asking for that QB to get the hell out of the pocket. When your end (who should have contain responsibilities) cuts inside, and the DT busts outside, an entire half of your DL loses all containment. A running QB will eat that up all day.

Not once in that game did I think, "get to the QB gakdhjlfnsdas!" More often than not, I was thinking, "why the hell aren't you keeping this guy in the pocket asking him to beat you with his arm!?"


October 7th, 2013 at 11:20 AM ^

I don't think it can be understated as to how bad the announcers were.  At some point in the 2nd half, (when Michigan was up by a minimum of 2 scores), Minnesota rushed for 2 yards.  1, 2.  Announcer:  "Minnesota is just blowing Michigan off the ball."  

If I was actually watching the game and just listened to the announcers, I would have thought Michigan lost 42-13.  

Chris of Dange…

October 7th, 2013 at 12:11 PM ^

13-0?  Not good enough!  Anything less than 14-0 is failure!


But seriously, is there any way a team in a conference with a CCG can end up 13-0?  We know 12-0 is possible (right, Ohio?), but under non-sanction circumstances if you're 12-0 you're going to your CCG and will end up playing 14 games either way.

I dumped the Dope

October 7th, 2013 at 2:21 PM ^

Northwestern needs a bigger gas tank...they run out in the 4th...

I have also been saying to myself that UM should aspire to be like Stanford.  Dominant OL and drive off the line of scrimmage.  Solid D and a nice passing attack too.  Good use of TEs.

El Jeffe

October 8th, 2013 at 9:36 AM ^

That Rogue Wave song is pretty good. I like the Shins too. It's also the second-best video to depict nerds fighting in armor in a forest.

#1? Obvsly: